Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · the new minister's wife and Anne's warm Sunday-school teacher

Mrs. Allan

in Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery

Mrs. Allan is the young wife of Avonlea's new minister and one of the most relatable supporting characters in the novel. She arrives with her husband as a "young, pleasant-faced couple, still on their honeymoon, and full of all good and beautiful enthusiasms for their chosen lifework," quickly winning over the town. Anne falls "promptly and wholeheartedly in love" with her, sensing a "kindred spirit" — the same instinctive connection she has with Matthew and, later on, with Miss Stacy.

Mrs. Allan teaches Anne's Sunday-school class with a refreshing openness, encouraging questions instead of just asking them, showing Anne that religion can be "a cheerful thing" rather than a burdensome duty. Throughout the middle and later chapters, she serves as a steady moral compass for Anne: Anne measures her own behavior against Mrs. Allan's example, seeks her advice on grief and growing up, and even adopts the guideline "it's always wrong to do anything you can't tell the minister's wife" as a practical rule for her actions.

Her role goes beyond mere symbolism. She comforts Anne personally after the liniment-cake mishap, visits her fourteen times during her recovery, assists Marilla in selecting fabric for Anne's evening dress, and offers gentle guidance when Anne grapples with grief after Matthew's death. By the final chapter, she is one of the few people whose approval truly matters to Anne, and she is one of the few in the community who openly support Anne's choice to stay home and teach instead of attending college.

About this character

Role
the new minister's wife and Anne's warm Sunday-school teacher
Form
Novel
Author
L. M. Montgomery
First published
1908

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Mrs. Allan?

Mrs. Allan is introduced in Chapter XXI as part of a newly married ministerial couple who bring a refreshing spirit to Avonlea. She's depicted as the bright, gentle little lady who assumed the mistress-ship of the manse. To Anne, her most striking trait is her genuinely cheerful approach to religion: Anne says she never knew before that religion was such a cheerful thing. Anne had always thought religion was kind of melancholy, but she finds that Mrs. Allan's is not. She candidly shares her own imperfect past with Anne, admitting she was a dreadful mischief as a girl and always getting into scrapes, a confession that deeply encourages Anne.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Mrs. Allan's arc and motivation?

Mrs. Allan doesn't experience a personal transformation; instead, she serves as a steady, kind presence against which Anne's development is measured. Her motivation stems from her calling: she and her husband are "full of all good and beautiful enthusiasms for their chosen lifework." Within this role, she takes a special interest in Anne, recognizing her brightness and responding with genuine warmth instead of condescension.

03·Key moments

What are Mrs. Allan's key moments?

  • Chapter XXI — The liniment cake: When Anne hides upstairs in embarrassment, Mrs. Allan comes to find her, laughs kindly, and tells her it is all just a funny mistake that anybody might make, then asks to see Anne's flower garden. Her instinct to comfort rather than scold is typical of her.
  • Chapter XXII — Tea at the manse: Mrs. Allan invites each Sunday-school member individually; during Anne's visit, they have "a heart-to-heart talk" in which Mrs. Allan shares that she too struggled with geometry and recognizes Anne's singing talent, inviting her to join the choir.
  • Chapter XXIII — Convalescence: While Anne recuperates from her fall, Mrs. Allan visits fourteen times — a detail Anne proudly cites as proof of her genuine care.
  • Chapter XXIX — The Exhibition: Anne declines to bet on a horse race partly because "it's always wrong to do anything you can't tell the minister's wife," showing how thoroughly Mrs. Allan has become Anne's internal moral guide.
  • Chapter XXXVII — Matthew's death: In the manse garden, Mrs. Allan listens as Anne expresses guilt about finding joy in life again, offering the novel's most extended piece of comforting wisdom by gently explaining that grief and happiness can coexist.
  • Chapter XXXVIII — Anne's decision: Mrs. Allan is one of the few in Avonlea who do not think Anne foolish for staying home to teach, and she tells Anne so in approving words that bring tears of pleasure to her eyes.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Mrs. Allan's most important relationships?

Mrs. Allan's relationship with Anne is central to her role in the story. Anne places her alongside Matthew as someone "you can love right off without any trouble," and she spends pleasant Saturday afternoons at the manse during her teenage years. Mrs. Allan's influence is both practical and spiritual: she assists Marilla in selecting Anne's evening dress, endorses books for Anne to read, and invites her to join the Sunday-school choir. With Marilla, Mrs. Allan acts as a quiet supporter — helping Marilla choose the material for Anne's evening dress — although their relationship is only glimpsed at times.

05·Connected characters

How is Mrs. Allan connected to the other characters?

Anne Shirley

Anne loves Mrs. Allan "passionately" and regards her as a kindred spirit and a model of cheerful, natural goodness; Mrs. Allan reciprocates with consistent warmth, personal visits, practical encouragement, and gentle counsel at every significant moment of Anne's adolescence.

Marilla Cuthbert

Marilla respects Mrs. Allan's judgment enough to ask her help choosing the material for Anne's evening dress.

Miss Stacy

Anne names Mrs. Allan alongside Miss Stacy, Marilla and Matthew as the good friends who make her want to be good and help her grow up successfully.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Mrs. Allan

Why does Anne love Mrs. Allan so much?

Anne quickly sees Mrs. Allan as a "kindred spirit." She's attracted to Mrs. Allan's cheerful and open approach to religion, her readiness to engage with questions instead of just throwing them out, and her sincere warmth. Anne notes that there are some people "you can love right off without any trouble," and Mrs. Allan is definitely one of those.

What happens with the liniment cake and Mrs. Allan?

Anne bakes a layer cake for Mrs. Allan's visit to Green Gables, but she mistakenly flavors it with anodyne liniment instead of vanilla. Mrs. Allan eats the cake without saying a word, but soon the mix-up is revealed. Embarrassed, Anne hides upstairs, and Mrs. Allan comes to look for her. She reassures Anne that it is all just a funny mistake that anybody might make, and asks to see Anne's flower garden, transforming the mishap into a moment of kindness.

How does Mrs. Allan influence Anne's moral thinking?

Anne actively looks up to Mrs. Allan, using her as a practical guide for ethics: she declares it is always wrong to do anything you can't tell the minister's wife. She also appreciates that Mrs. Allan taught her to strive to inspire others toward goodness and that the ultimate goal should be to make a positive impact in the world.

What comfort does Mrs. Allan offer Anne after Matthew's death?

In the manse garden, Mrs. Allan tells Anne that it's normal to feel guilty about enjoying life again after a loss. She explains that we all resent the thought that anything can please us when someone we love is no longer here to share the pleasure with us. She urges Anne not to shut her heart against the healing influences that nature offers.

Does Mrs. Allan approve of Anne staying home instead of going to college?

Yes. Once it becomes known that Anne has given up going to college to stay with Marilla, Mrs. Allan is one of the few people in Avonlea who openly supports her choice, expressing her approval in a way that brings tears of joy to Anne's eyes.

What practical help does Mrs. Allan give Anne beyond spiritual guidance?

Mrs. Allan assists Marilla in selecting the fabric for Anne's evening dress during Marilla's trip to town, invites Anne to join the Sunday-school choir after being impressed by her singing, and presents Anne with "a few good pictures" that adorn the walls of her room at Green Gables.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Mrs. Allan as a model of "cheerful" Christianity

    In what ways does her example reshape Anne's view of religion, and what does this imply about the novel's perspective on faith?

  • The minister's wife as a moral compass

    Explore how Anne depends on Mrs. Allan as an external conscience ("it's always wrong to do anything you can't tell the minister's wife") and what this indicates about Anne's moral growth.

  • Kindred spirits and female mentorship

    Compare Mrs. Allan's role with Miss Stacy's — both are recognized by Anne as figures who inspire her to "grow up successfully." What unique function does each serve?

  • Comfort and grief in Chapter XXXVII

    Analyze Mrs. Allan's remarks about sorrow and joy as a thematic statement on loss and resilience in the novel.

  • Approval and belonging

    Mrs. Allan's support of Anne's decision to stay home serves as one of the novel's final affirmations of Anne's value. How does the book use Mrs. Allan's approval to validate Anne's choices throughout?

Anne of Green Gables

Continue

Full study guide →