Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · the Avonlea schoolmaster before Miss Stacy

Mr. Phillips

in Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery

Mr. Phillips is the schoolmaster at Avonlea school during Anne's first year there, before Miss Stacy takes over. He comes across as an ineffective and often unfair teacher, primarily focused on courting Prissy Andrews, an older pupil he is preparing for Queen's. Mrs. Rachel Lynde bluntly expresses local opinion: "Mr. Phillips isn't any good at all as a teacher. The order he keeps is scandalous," and he only holds his position because his uncle controls the school trustees. In the classroom, he is inconsistent and biased — punishing Anne as a scapegoat while ignoring other equally guilty students, publicly humiliating her over her spelling and name, and spending lesson time composing verses "To Priscilla" or focusing on Prissy Andrews's Latin while the rest of the class does as they wish. However, he does show some awareness: he tells Matthew privately that Anne is "the smartest scholar in school and was making rapid progress," and he promotes both Anne and Gilbert into the fifth class by the end of the term. His departure at the end of the school year brings unexpected tears from students who claimed to dislike him, and his "beautiful farewell speech" even moves Anne to tears despite her list of grievances against him. Three years later, Miss Stacy's farewell is compared to his as the emotional benchmark for a teacher leaving Avonlea.

About this character

Role
the Avonlea schoolmaster before Miss Stacy
Form
Novel
Author
L. M. Montgomery
First published
1908

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Mr. Phillips?

Mr. Phillips is the schoolmaster at Avonlea during Anne's early school years. He boards at Eben Wright's home and is described by Mrs. Rachel Lynde as maintaining "scandalous" order, often neglecting younger pupils while focusing on older students he is preparing for Queen's — primarily Prissy Andrews, whom he is also courting. His position is not earned through merit, but rather secured by his uncle's influence over the school trustees.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Mr. Phillips's arc and motivation?

In the novel, Mr. Phillips doesn’t undergo any personal development; he serves as an obstacle and a backdrop for social interactions. His motivations stem from self-interest (his pursuit of Prissy Andrews) and a desire for the easiest path (punishing the most convenient scapegoat instead of addressing the real issues). He leaves in Chapter XXI, where his farewell is described at the very start, and is replaced by Miss Stacy, being mentioned once more in Chapter XXXII merely for comparison.

03·Key moments

What are Mr. Phillips's key moments?

  • Chapter XV: On Anne's first day, he embarrasses her by displaying her misspelled slate for the class to see. While he is hearing Prissy Andrews's Latin, Gilbert pins Ruby Gillis's braid to her seat, and when Ruby shrieks his stern glare makes her cry while Gilbert goes unnoticed.
  • Chapter XV: Following the slate incident, he ignores Gilbert's confession and makes Anne stand on the platform with a misspelled condemnation above her head ("Ann Shirley has a very bad temper"). He later seats her next to Gilbert as a sarcastic punishment for being late — an act that ultimately drives Anne to refuse to attend school altogether.
  • Chapter XV (Mrs. Lynde's verdict): Mrs. Lynde tells Marilla that Mr. Phillips was in the wrong, holds his position only because of his uncle, and "neglects the young fry."
  • Chapter XVII: He instructs Anne to sit with "the model Minnie Andrews" upon her return, having earlier been caught up in writing verses "To Priscilla" during class on the day he seated her beside Gilbert. Despite his shortcomings, Anne and Gilbert are both promoted to the fifth class by the end of the term, and in Chapter XVIII Matthew reports that Mr. Phillips told him Anne is the smartest scholar in school.
  • Chapter XIX: At the Avonlea concert, he recites Mark Antony's oration, looking at Prissy Andrews after every sentence, and rumors suggest he ordered the carnations she wears from town.
  • Chapter XX: He gives all the gathered Mayflowers to Prissy Andrews and is overheard saying "sweets to the sweet."
  • Chapter XXI: His farewell speech ("The time has come for us to part") brings all the girls to tears, including students who claimed to dislike him.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Mr. Phillips's most important relationships?

Mr. Phillips's relationship with Anne is the most significant: his public humiliations — the misspelled name, the platform punishment, the forced seating beside Gilbert — compel her to refuse school and intensify her competitive spirit upon returning. However, his private praise of her to Matthew highlights a disconnect between his classroom behavior and his true assessment of her abilities. His relationship with Prissy Andrews drives his neglect of the classroom; he spends lesson time focused on her Latin, openly courts her at the concert, and shows her favoritism in public gestures. Mrs. Lynde expresses the community's low opinion of him with her usual authority, and her judgment is weighty enough to convince Marilla to allow Anne to stay home rather than confront him.

05·Connected characters

How is Mr. Phillips connected to the other characters?

Anne Shirley

Mr. Phillips repeatedly singles Anne out for public humiliation — misspelling her name on the blackboard, making her stand on the platform, and seating her beside Gilbert as a punishment — yet privately praises her to Matthew as the smartest scholar in school.

Mrs. Rachel Lynde

Mrs. Lynde is his sharpest critic in the community, declaring his teaching scandalous and attributing his tenure entirely to his uncle's influence over the trustees.

Marilla Cuthbert

Marilla privately suspects Mr. Phillips has been "carrying matters with a rather high hand" but is careful not to say so to Anne, consulting Mrs. Lynde about how to handle Anne's refusal to return to his school.

Gilbert Blythe

Mr. Phillips ignores Gilbert's honest admission of fault during the slate-breaking incident, and later uses Gilbert as an instrument of punishment by forcing Anne to sit beside him.

Miss Stacy

Miss Stacy succeeds Mr. Phillips as Avonlea's schoolmaster; her farewell three years later is compared directly to his as an emotional event for the pupils.

Jane Andrews

Jane declares for a month that she will be glad when Mr. Phillips leaves, yet ends up crying harder than anyone at his farewell.

Ruby Gillis

Ruby Gillis always declared she hated Mr. Phillips but is the first to burst into tears at his farewell speech, setting off the rest of the girls.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Mr. Phillips

Why does Mr. Phillips make Anne stand on the platform in front of the class?

After Anne smashes her slate over Gilbert's head, Mr. Phillips overlooks Gilbert's confession and chooses to blame Anne instead. He forces her to stand on the platform for the rest of the afternoon and writes on the blackboard above her head — misspelling her name — "Ann Shirley has a very bad temper. Ann Shirley must learn to control her temper."

Why does Mr. Phillips seat Anne beside Gilbert Blythe?

The next day, Anne returns late from the spruce grove, but she's not alone; many other students are as well. Mr. Phillips, not wanting the bother of punishing a dozen latecomers, singles out Anne as a scapegoat and sarcastically tells her that since she seems so fond of the boys' company he will indulge her taste for it, directing her to sit with Gilbert.

Is Mr. Phillips considered a good teacher?

No. Mrs. Rachel Lynde clearly states that "Mr. Phillips isn't any good at all as a teacher," that his classroom management is scandalous, and that he pays more attention to the older students he’s prepping for Queen's while neglecting the younger ones. She also claims he only has his job because his uncle is in charge of the school trustees.

What is Mr. Phillips's relationship with Prissy Andrews?

He is trying to win her over. Almost every evening, he visits her home, claiming it’s to help with her lessons. During class, he focuses on her Latin, gives her all the Mayflowers he finds on the school picnic, and at the Avonlea concert, where rumor says he sent to town for the carnations in her hair, he looks at her after every sentence he recites.

Does Mr. Phillips ever say anything positive about Anne?

Yes. He tells Matthew privately in Blair's store at Carmody that Anne is "the smartest scholar in school and was making rapid progress" — even though he often treats her harshly and dismissively in class.

Why do the pupils cry when Mr. Phillips leaves?

Ruby Gillis, who always insisted she hated him, is the first to break down in tears during his farewell speech, prompting the other girls to join in one by one. Anne struggles to stay composed by recalling his harshness, but she can’t hold back either. Even Jane Andrews, who had spent a month saying how relieved she would be when he was gone, ends up crying more than anyone else.

When does Mr. Phillips leave Avonlea school?

He leaves on the last day of June, which is also the end of the school term, as mentioned in Chapter XXI. Miss Stacy then takes over the school, and her departure three years later is compared to his in Chapter XXXII.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Mr. Phillips as a figure of institutional failure: How does his time at Avonlea illustrate the novel's critique of authority based on connections rather than competence?

  • Public humiliation as a theme: Trace the moments when Mr. Phillips shames Anne in front of the class and analyze how each incident shapes her character and rivalry with Gilbert.

  • The gap between public conduct and private judgment: Mr. Phillips humiliates Anne in class yet praises her as the smartest student to Matthew

    what does this contradiction suggest about performance and power in the classroom?

  • Sentimentality at departure: Anne cries at Mr. Phillips's farewell despite listing his cruelties. What does this moment reveal about her emotional nature and the novel's perspective on forgiveness?

  • Mr. Phillips versus Miss Stacy as contrasting educators: Using evidence of his teaching methods and Mrs. Lynde's verdict, build an argument about what qualities the novel suggests make a great teacher.

Anne of Green Gables

Continue

Full study guide →