Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis

Josie Pye

in Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery

Josie Pye is a recurring minor antagonist in Anne of Green Gables, primarily acting as a social foil to Anne Shirley within the Avonlea school community. Coming from the well-known Pye family, Josie is introduced early on as one of the girls Anne meets at school, but she quickly makes her mark with her sharp tongue, competitive spirit, and unkindness toward others.

In contrast to the loyal Diana Barry or the diligent Jane Andrews, Josie stands out for her tendency to mock and belittle. Her most significant moment occurs when she challenges Anne to walk along the ridgepole of the Barry kitchen roof. Unable to resist a challenge to her pride, Anne accepts, leading to a fall that breaks her ankle. This incident highlights Josie's role: she provokes Anne's vanity and recklessness without facing any repercussions, which emphasizes Anne's impulsive nature.

Josie is also part of the "Story Club" and the wider group of Avonlea girls, where she tends to make deflating or snarky comments instead of offering support. She is openly competitive about academics and social status, often reminding Anne of her perceived flaws. However, Josie never truly embodies villainy; she remains a realistic representation of petty schoolgirl rivalry.

Her character arc is essentially flat—she doesn't experience growth or change—which serves a narrative purpose: against Josie's constant meanness, Anne's growing empathy and maturity stand out even more. Josie represents the everyday social cruelties that Anne must learn to rise above.

About this character

Form
Novel
Author
L. M. Montgomery
First published
1908

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Josie Pye?

Josie Pye occupies a precise social niche in Avonlea: she is neither outcast nor queen bee, but something more insidious — the girl in the middle of every group who knows exactly where to press to cause the most discomfort. Montgomery introduces her as one of the cluster of schoolgirls Anne meets shortly after enrolling at Avonlea school, and she is immediately distinguishable by her manner rather than any dramatic action. She belongs to the Pye family, a name that carries enough local standing to give Josie confidence, and she deploys that confidence almost entirely as social capital. Where Anne earns admiration through imagination and warmth, Josie asserts herself through deflation. She is not a bully in any gothic sense; she is recognisably, uncomfortably real — the classmate who phrases every observation as a slight and calls it honesty.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Josie Pye's arc and motivation?

Josie's arc is deliberately flat, and Montgomery makes that flatness do narrative work. She begins the novel sharp-tongued and competitive and ends it exactly the same way. Her motivation is consistent: she is driven by the need to rank herself above others in a community where academic standing, looks, and social approval constitute the only available currency for young women. Because she cannot match Anne's intellectual brilliance or Diana's genuine popularity, Josie competes on the only terrain available — she chips away at others' confidence. This static quality is not a flaw in characterization but a deliberate structural choice. Josie does not grow so that Anne's growth is thrown into sharper relief. Every step Anne takes toward grace and self-mastery is visible precisely because Josie remains the fixed point of petty rivalry against which that movement can be measured.

03·Key moments

What are Josie Pye's key moments?

The ridgepole incident is Josie's defining scene and one of the novel's most consequential episodes. When the girls gather at the Barry house, Josie issues the dare — walk the ridgepole of the kitchen roof — with the calculated nonchalance of someone who understands that Anne's pride makes refusal almost impossible. She does not push Anne; she simply identifies the lever and pulls it. Anne climbs, falls, and breaks her ankle. Josie faces no punishment, suffers no guilt, and the scene closes with Anne's injury and Marilla's alarm. Montgomery is deliberate here: consequences fall on the person who accepted the dare, not the person who designed it. This is socially realistic and thematically pointed — Anne must learn that her own vanity is the real vulnerability Josie exploits.

Within the Story Club, Josie's role is smaller but consistent. While Ruby Gillis gushes and Jane Andrews offers sensible praise, Josie contributes deflating commentary, positioning critique as superior judgment. These moments are quieter than the ridgepole dare but cumulatively important: they show that Josie's unkindness is not situational but habitual.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Josie Pye's most important relationships?

Anne Shirley is the axis around which Josie's entire characterization revolves. Josie reads Anne accurately — she sees the pride, the hunger for acceptance, the inability to back down from a challenge — and she uses that knowledge as a weapon. Their dynamic is less a friendship rivalry than a case study in how Anne's greatest strengths (passionate engagement, fierce pride) are also her greatest vulnerabilities.

Diana Barry and Jane Andrews function as structural contrasts. Diana's uncritical loyalty and Jane's steady decency make Josie's competitive spite look starker by comparison. The three together represent a spectrum of female social behavior in the Avonlea peer group, from nurturing to neutral to corrosive.

Gilbert Blythe adds a dimension of social jealousy to Josie's antagonism. Her noted interest in Gilbert's attention means that Anne's eventual closeness with him is not merely an academic or personal matter — it is another arena in which Josie perceives herself as losing ground.

05·Connected characters

How is Josie Pye connected to the other characters?

Anne Shirley

Josie is Anne's primary social antagonist among the Avonlea girls. She issues the ridgepole dare that causes Anne's fall and injury, and consistently offers cutting remarks that test Anne's temper and pride. Their rivalry underscores Anne's growth in self-restraint and magnanimity.

Diana Barry

Both are part of the same circle of Avonlea schoolgirls, but Josie and Diana represent opposite poles of friendship toward Anne. Diana's loyal warmth contrasts sharply with Josie's competitive cattiness, making the two a study in contrasting social attitudes.

Ruby Gillis

Ruby and Josie move in the same peer group and are often mentioned together as classmates. Ruby's good-natured silliness differs from Josie's deliberate sharpness, but they share scenes as part of the broader Avonlea girls' social world.

Jane Andrews

Jane and Josie are fellow members of the Avonlea school circle and the Story Club. Jane's steady, sensible temperament provides a quiet contrast to Josie's tendency toward provocation and one-upmanship.

Gilbert Blythe

Both Josie and Gilbert are academic competitors of Anne, but Josie's rivalry is rooted in social spite rather than genuine intellectual contest. Josie is notably interested in Gilbert's attention, adding a layer of social jealousy to her antagonism toward Anne.

Mr. Phillips

As students under Mr. Phillips, Josie and Anne share the same classroom environment. Josie's social maneuvering within the school setting is partly enabled by Mr. Phillips's ineffectual oversight of student dynamics.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Josie Pye

Who is Josie Pye in Anne of Green Gables?

Josie Pye is a recurring minor antagonist and social foil to Anne Shirley within the Avonlea school community. She belongs to the well-known Pye family, which gives her a confidence she uses primarily as social capital — deflating others through sharp, cutting remarks rather than through any dramatic villainy. Montgomery presents her as a realistic portrait of petty schoolgirl rivalry.

What does Josie Pye do to cause Anne's fall from the roof?

Josie dares Anne to walk along the ridgepole of the Barry kitchen roof, knowing Anne's pride makes refusal nearly impossible. She does not push Anne — she simply identifies the lever and pulls it. Anne accepts, falls, and breaks her ankle, while Josie faces no punishment or guilt. The incident serves as Montgomery's sharp illustration of how Josie weaponizes Anne's own vanity against her.

Why does Josie Pye antagonize Anne Shirley?

Josie is driven by the need to rank herself above others in a community where academic standing, looks, and social approval are the main currency for young women. Unable to match Anne's intellectual brilliance or Diana's genuine popularity, she competes by undermining others' confidence. Anne's pride, hunger for acceptance, and unwillingness to back down from a challenge make her a particularly readable — and exploitable — target.

Does Josie Pye change or grow over the course of the novel?

No — Josie's arc is deliberately flat. She begins sharp-tongued and competitive and ends exactly the same way. Montgomery uses this static quality to illustrate the contrast: because Josie never changes, she becomes the fixed point against which Anne's growing empathy, self-restraint, and maturity can be clearly measured. Josie remains unchanged so that Anne's growth stands out.

What is Josie Pye's relationship with Diana Barry?

Josie and Diana are part of the same circle of Avonlea schoolgirls but represent opposite ends of friendship toward Anne. Diana's loyal, uncritical warmth contrasts sharply with Josie's competitive cattiness, making the two a study in contrasting social attitudes. Together with Jane Andrews, they form a spectrum of female social behavior in the Avonlea peer group — from nurturing to neutral to corrosive.

Is Josie Pye interested in Gilbert Blythe?

Yes — Josie is notably interested in Gilbert's attention, which adds a layer of social jealousy to her antagonism toward Anne. While Gilbert competes with Anne academically out of genuine intellectual interest, Josie's rivalry is rooted in social spite. Anne's eventual closeness with Gilbert becomes another arena in which Josie perceives herself as losing ground.

Is Josie Pye a villain in Anne of Green Gables?

Not in any gothic or melodramatic sense — Montgomery is careful to portray Josie as recognizably, uncomfortably real. She is the classmate who phrases every observation as a slight and calls it honesty, not a dramatic schemer. Her antagonism is mundane rather than evil, part of Montgomery's social realism: Josie embodies the everyday cruelties that Anne must learn to rise above, not an outsized obstacle to defeat.

What role does Josie Pye play in the Story Club?

Within the Story Club, Josie consistently offers deflating, snarky commentary instead of support, positioning her critiques as superior judgment while Ruby Gillis gushes and Jane Andrews offers sensible praise. These moments are quieter than the ridgepole dare but cumulatively important: they establish that Josie's unkindness is not situational but habitual, a default mode of social interaction rather than a reaction to any particular provocation.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • The function of the static antagonist

    Argue that Josie's refusal to grow is a deliberate narrative strategy — examine how Montgomery uses her unchanging nature to make Anne's development legible and measurable.

  • Vanity as vulnerability

    Using the ridgepole incident as a central text, explore how Josie's role is less to act than to reveal — specifically, to expose the ways Anne's pride makes her susceptible to manipulation.

  • Social realism and "petty" cruelty

    Consider how Montgomery's portrayal of Josie challenges the conventions of children's fiction by depicting antagonism that is mundane rather than melodramatic, and what that realism argues about the actual social world girls navigate.

  • Gender and competition

    Analyze how Josie's competitiveness — over grades, over Gilbert's attention, over social standing — reflects the limited arenas available to young women in a rural, late-Victorian community.

  • The Pye family name as social shorthand

    Examine how Montgomery uses Josie's family background to suggest that certain dispositions are community-reproduced, and what that implies about Avonlea's social structure and its treatment of outsiders like Anne.

Anne of Green Gables

Continue

Full study guide →