Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · Anne's sharp-tongued classmate and rival

Josie Pye

in Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery

Josie Pye is Anne Shirley's sharp-tongued classmate and relentless social rival during their time at Avonlea school and Queen's Academy. She comes from the Pye family, which Marilla considers rather disagreeable. While Josie is never a close friend to Anne, she consistently appears in Anne's social life — whether in the classroom, during dares and games, at the concert, or later at Queen's.

Josie's most notable characteristic is her tendency to make cutting remarks: she tells Anne that her short hair makes her look "like a perfect scarecrow," points out that Anne's nose and eyes turn red when she cries, and even asserts at the end of the novel that Anne's hair is redder than ever. She cheats in spelling class, stirs up petty social disputes after the school concert, and mocks Anne for having an unlucky examination number. However, she isn't purely malicious: she skillfully walks a board fence, wins first prize for knitted lace at the Exhibition, and even brings Anne news about the Avery scholarship. Additionally, she visits Anne during her ankle injury, seeming to feel some guilt for having suggested the ridgepole dare.

At Queen's, Josie gains the reputation of being "the sharpest-tongued young lady in attendance." She barely passes the Entrance examinations, scraping through with just three marks to spare. By the end of the novel, she is heading back to Queen's for another year, and Mrs. Lynde notes with satisfaction that Josie was the last of the Pyes to attend Avonlea school.

About this character

Role
Anne's sharp-tongued classmate and rival
Form
Novel
Author
L. M. Montgomery
First published
1908

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Josie Pye?

Josie Pye is an affluent girl from Avonlea, known locally for her family's unpleasant reputation. She has a knack for walking on board fences and even wins first prize for her knitted lace at the Exhibition, but her social standing is largely built on her sharp tongue and her tendency to poke fun at others. Marilla's assessment — "Josie is a Pye, so she can't help being disagreeable" — along with Mrs. Lynde's remark that the Pyes' "mission in life was to keep school teachers reminded that earth isn't their home," paint her as a type rather than just an individual.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Josie Pye's arc and motivation?

Josie remains unchanged throughout the novel. She starts as a cheater in spelling class and ends up still taunting Anne about her hair being redder than ever. Her motivation seems to blend social competitiveness with a genuine inability to hold back unkind comments. Anne keeps trying to like her, but by the last chapters she concludes that Josie simply refuses to be liked. At Queen's, Josie's carefree attitude toward failure — "If I don't pass this year I'm coming back next. My father can afford to send me" — sharply contrasts with the financial pressures Anne and Gilbert face, highlighting a divide in both class and character.

03·Key moments

What are Josie Pye's key moments?

  • Chapter XV: Josie is caught looking at her book during a spelling contest; Anne gives her "a look of freezing scorn," establishing their rivalry from the outset.
  • Chapter XXIII: Josie dares Anne to climb Mr. Barry's kitchen roof, resulting in Anne breaking her ankle. The chapter notes that even Josie has "horrible visions" of being blamed for Anne's death, hinting at a flicker of conscience beneath her bravado.
  • Chapter XXIII: During Anne's seven-week recovery, Josie visits her. Anne interprets this as remorse for the dare and receives her as politely as she can.
  • Chapter XXV: At the school concert, Josie, described as "envy," cannot deny that Anne is "the bright particular star of the occasion."
  • Chapter XXX: Josie's claim that she's attending Queen's solely "for education's sake" because she won't need to earn a living — sharply contrasting with orphans "living on charity" who "have to hustle" — is one of her cruelest remarks.
  • Chapter XXXIV: Josie brings news of the Avery scholarship to Anne, unintentionally sparking Anne's highest ambitions.
  • Chapter XXXV: At Queen's, Josie is noted as "the sharpest-tongued young lady in attendance" — a backhanded compliment that solidifies her role.
  • Chapter XXXVII: Anne tells Marilla she has "almost decided to give up trying to like Josie Pye," signaling the end of her efforts at Christian forbearance toward her rival.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Josie Pye's most important relationships?

Josie's relationship with Anne exemplifies a rivalry that never resolves. Anne's repeated attempts to like Josie — framed as a moral self-improvement inspired by Mrs. Allan — are consistently undermined by Josie's next cutting remark. The ridgepole incident is pivotal: Josie orchestrates Anne's most dangerous moment, yet she visits her afterward, and later, it's Josie who inadvertently delivers the news of the Avery scholarship. This pattern of harm followed by unintentional benefit complicates their relationship, preventing it from being straightforward villainy. With Gilbert, Josie acts as a satellite: she sits next to him at the concert and openly supports him over Anne, making her a living symbol of the rivalry Anne is determined to overcome.

05·Connected characters

How is Josie Pye connected to the other characters?

Anne Shirley

Josie is Anne's chief female rival and most persistent critic, trading barbs and dares with her from Avonlea school through Queen's Academy. Anne repeatedly tries and largely fails to genuinely like her.

Diana Barry

Josie gossips about Anne to Diana, telling her that Anne was "infatuated" with Stella Maynard at Queen's, which briefly stirs Diana's jealousy.

Gilbert Blythe

Josie is driven by Gilbert to the hotel concert at White Sands, and earlier she had declared that Gilbert was sure to come out first in the Entrance examinations.

Miss Stacy

Josie is one of Miss Stacy's Queen's class pupils; she is the one who asks Miss Stacy directly whether she will return for the final year.

Jane Andrews

Josie dares Jane to hop around the garden on one leg, and later, at Queen's, Josie is for a time not speaking to Jane.

Marilla Cuthbert

Marilla dismisses Josie with the verdict that "Josie is a Pye, so she can't help being disagreeable," and compares the use of such people to the use of thistles.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Josie Pye

What is Josie Pye's most consequential action in the novel?

Josie challenges Anne to walk along the ridgepole of Mr. Barry's kitchen roof in Chapter XXIII. Anne slips and breaks her ankle, which keeps her off her feet for seven weeks. During this time, Josie is overwhelmed by "horrible visions" of being held responsible for Anne's death, and she goes to see Anne while she is recovering.

Does Josie ever do anything kind or positive?

She visits Anne during her seven-week recovery, which Anne sees as an apology for the dare. She also wins first prize for her knitted lace at the Exhibition, and she's the one who brings Anne the news about the Avery scholarship — but she does this without any clear intention of helping Anne.

How does Anne feel about Josie by the end of the novel?

In Chapter XXXVII Anne confesses to Marilla that she has "almost decided to give up trying to like Josie Pye," because even after what she calls a heroic effort Josie will not let herself be liked.

What does Josie achieve academically?

She passes the entrance examinations but only "scraped through with three marks to spare." At Queen's, she earns the title of "the sharpest-tongued young lady in attendance" and chooses to return for a second year instead of moving on to teach.

Why does Josie say she is going to Queen's?

In Chapter XXX, she says she is going only for education's sake, because she will not have to earn her own living. She contrasts this with the orphans "living on charity" who "have to hustle."

What does Marilla think of Josie Pye?

Marilla states bluntly, "Josie is a Pye, so she can't help being disagreeable," and likens the Pyes' usefulness to that of thistles. In the last chapter, Mrs. Lynde remarks with satisfaction that Josie was the last of the Pyes to go to Avonlea school.

Is there anything Josie is genuinely good at?

Yes — she has a natural, well-practised gift for walking board fences, which she shows off with easy unconcern in Chapter XXIII, earning reluctant admiration from the other girls.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Josie as social foil

    How does Josie's wealth, family name, and indifference to failure highlight Anne's precarious social and financial situation?

  • The limits of Anne's forbearance

    Anne's effort to learn to like Josie is framed as a Christian self-improvement project; its ultimate failure raises questions about the novel's moral optimism.

  • Sharp tongue as female power

    In a world where girls have limited outlets for aggression, consider how Josie's biting speech serves as a form of social authority.

  • Inadvertent catalyst

    Josie is responsible for both Anne's worst physical injury (the ridgepole dare) and her highest ambition (the Avery news) — explore what this pattern suggests about antagonists in Anne's growth.

  • The Pye family as type

    Marilla and Mrs. Lynde see "Pye" as a category of person rather than an individual; examine how the novel uses Josie to comment on inherited social character.

Anne of Green Gables

Continue

Full study guide →