Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · orphan girl adopted by the Cuthberts of Green Gables

Anne Shirley

in Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery

Anne Shirley is the orphan girl at the heart of the novel, taken in by the Cuthbert siblings of Green Gables after a mix-up left Matthew and Marilla expecting a boy. She arrives at eleven years old, with red hair, a thin frame, and a remarkable imagination paired with an endless gift for conversation. Having spent her childhood in an asylum and in the homes of strangers, she's never known a real family, a close friend, or a place she could truly call home — until Green Gables offers her all three.

Anne's most defining traits include her romantic imagination, her strong sense of personal dignity, her joy in the natural world, and her tendency to express her feelings in extremes. She gives names to every lane and pool she encounters, laments every slight as a "lifelong sorrow," and embraces every joy as something almost too wonderful to handle. Beneath this intensity lies a genuine longing to be good and to be loved, leading her to be quick to apologize even if she’s slow to comply.

Her journey transitions from the anxious uncertainty of a child who has never belonged to the growing confidence of a girl who finally has a home, a best friend, a rival, and a spot at the front of her class. Each incident — the brooch affair, the slate-smashing, the raspberry cordial mishap — tests and reveals her character, showcasing both her impulsiveness and her underlying honesty and warmth.

About this character

Role
orphan girl adopted by the Cuthberts of Green Gables
Form
Novel
Author
L. M. Montgomery
First published
1908

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Anne Shirley?

Anne Shirley arrives at Green Gables as a child she has imagined and named herself: she would rather be called Cordelia, asks for her name to be spelled with an E, and renames the places she passes on her very first drive from the station. She is "smart and obedient, willing to work and quick to learn," but her "most serious shortcoming" is her tendency to daydream in the middle of tasks (Chapter VIII). With no family, stable home, or friend before Green Gables, she approaches every experience — whether it’s a blooming cherry tree or an invitation to tea — with an intensity that surprises the more composed adults around her.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Anne Shirley's arc and motivation?

Anne's strongest desire is for belonging: she wants to feel wanted, have a name that matters, and be loved rather than just tolerated. When Marilla tells her she can stay, Anne cries without knowing why — "I'm so happy" — and immediately vows to try to be good (Chapter VIII). Over the novel's early chapters her journey moves from the fear of being sent back to the asylum through tests of her temper and honesty, to the early joys of school, friendship, and a place she can call her own. Each setback (like the brooch incident and the slate incident) serves as a moment of self-discovery: while she is passionate and proud, she is also honest and capable of true remorse.

03·Key moments

What are Anne Shirley's key moments?

  • Chapter III: Anne hesitantly reveals her real name and asks to be called Anne spelled with an E, highlighting her need to define her own identity, even in small ways.
  • Chapter VIII: When Marilla tells Anne she can stay, Anne cries with joy she can't fully articulate, showing how much she depends on this outcome.
  • Chapter X: After her outburst at Mrs. Lynde, Anne is confined to her room and admits to Matthew that her anger has faded, leaving "a dreadful sort of goneness" — revealing her ability for true contrition beneath her pride.
  • Chapter XIV: The brooch incident tests Anne's honesty under pressure; she first insists she never took the brooch out of Marilla's room, then invents a false confession so that she can go to the picnic.
  • Chapter XV: When Gilbert Blythe calls her "carrots," Anne smashes her slate over his head and vows never to forgive him — a moment that encapsulates her fierce dignity and sets the stage for their ongoing rivalry.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Anne Shirley's most important relationships?

Anne's relationship with Marilla forms the emotional core of the novel. Marilla is "crisp and curt" because she struggles to communicate with the child, yet she is secretly touched by Anne's impulsive kisses and surprised by her growing interest in Anne’s chatter. Anne longs to call Marilla "Aunt Marilla," believing it would make her "feel as if I really belonged to you" (Chapter VIII) — a desire Marilla resists but can’t fully ignore.

Matthew provides Anne with something different: unconditional, wordless joy. He listens to everything without scolding, and when Anne is confined to the east gable, it's Matthew who tiptoes upstairs to coax her toward reconciliation — not because he thinks she was wrong, but simply because he misses her.

Diana Barry is Anne's first chosen friend, and Anne approaches this relationship with overwhelming hope: "What if she shouldn't like me! It would be the most tragical disappointment of my life" (Chapter XII). Diana becomes the audience for Anne's imagination and her companion on walks to school.

Gilbert Blythe appears as a clear antagonist. His teasing is careless; Anne's reaction is absolute. The imbalance — he apologizes right away, while she refuses to forgive him — shows just how much is at stake for Anne, whose sense of self is tied up in her red hair in a way Gilbert cannot grasp.

05·Connected characters

How is Anne Shirley connected to the other characters?

Marilla Cuthbert

Marilla is Anne's guardian and the primary authority in her daily life; their relationship is a constant negotiation between Marilla's crisp practicality and Anne's overflowing emotion, with genuine affection growing beneath the friction.

Matthew Cuthbert

Matthew is Anne's quiet champion at Green Gables, listening to her with wordless delight and gently nudging her toward reconciliation when Marilla's discipline feels immovable.

Diana Barry

Diana is Anne's 'bosom friend' and the first true companion of her life; Anne adores her completely and furnishes most of the imagination in their friendship.

Gilbert Blythe

Gilbert provokes Anne's most passionate resentment by calling her 'carrots' and pulling her braid; she vows never to forgive him, setting up a rivalry that defines her school life.

Mrs. Rachel Lynde

Mrs. Lynde's blunt remarks about Anne's appearance trigger Anne's first explosive outburst at Green Gables, and Mrs. Lynde's reports to Marilla continue to shape how Anne is judged in Avonlea.

Mr. Phillips

Mr. Phillips humiliates Anne publicly — misspelling her name on the blackboard and making her stand before the class — deepening her wounded pride and her resentment of injustice.

Josie Pye

Josie Pye is a classmate whose malicious smiles Anne notices even in her worst moments of humiliation, marking her as an unsympathetic presence in Anne's school world.

Charlie Sloane

Charlie admires Anne and tells his mother she is the smartest girl in school, but Anne finds his 'goggle eyes' repellent and dreads having her name linked with his.

The evidence06

06·Key quotes

What are Anne Shirley’s key quotes?

“You don’t want me because I’m not a boy! I might have expected it. Nobody ever did want me.”

Anne · to Marilla · Chapter III

Why it matters

Anne expresses this in Chapter III when she catches Marilla's disappointment at finding a girl instead of the expected boy. This line reveals a core wound from Anne's early life: she's felt unwanted for so long that she instantly assumes rejection is unavoidable. Her cry — "Nobody ever did want me" — isn't just self-pity; it's a factual reflection from years of being shuffled between homes that never truly accepted her. This moment is crucial because it’s the first time readers witness the depth of Anne's loneliness, and it subtly begins to soften both Matthew and Marilla's attitudes toward her. It also sets up the emotional stakes of the novel: Anne's journey is not just about finding a home, but about realizing that she is truly loved.

“There is no use in loving things if you have to be torn from them, is there? And it’s so hard to keep from loving things, isn’t it?”

Anne · Chapter IV

Why it matters

Anne expresses this in Chapter IV as she stands at the threshold of Green Gables, holding herself back from exploring the property she knows she might have to leave soon. Her two linked questions — about the pain of loving things you have to let go and the difficulty of preventing yourself from loving them — capture her emotional state in a single breath. She has already named the cherry tree "Snow Queen" that morning, and moments later she names the geranium "Bonny," aware that her attachment is growing whether she wants it to or not. This passage reveals that Anne's imagination and ability to love are far from naive: she knows loss well, having been uprooted many times, yet she can't resist reaching for beauty. It stands out as one of the novel's most thoughtfully philosophical moments.

“I’d go out into a great big field all alone or into the deep, deep woods, and I’d look up into the sky--up--up--up--into that lovely blue sky that looks as if there was no end to its blueness. And then I’d just feel a prayer.”

Anne · to Marilla · Chapter VII

Why it matters

Anne shares her thoughts in Chapter VII when Marilla insists she should say prayers. She tells Marilla that she’s never prayed in the traditional way, but describes her own instinctive form of worship: wandering alone in a vast field or deep woods, gazing up at the endless blue sky, and simply feeling a prayer. This passage is significant for several reasons. It illustrates that Anne has a genuine, though unconventional, spiritual life—one that springs from her love for nature rather than from organized religion. It also highlights how her years of neglect left her without formal religious guidance, while her imagination found a way to fill that void. Marilla, who had planned to teach Anne the usual childhood prayer, decides it does not suit this girl and tells her to pray in her own words instead.

““Marilla, isn’t it nice to think that tomorrow is a new day with no mistakes in it yet?””

Anne · to Marilla · Chapter XXI

Why it matters

Anne says this in Chapter XXI after the embarrassing realization that she has mistakenly used anodyne liniment instead of vanilla to flavor her layer cake, which she baked for the Allans' tea. Instead of wallowing in embarrassment, Anne takes solace in the idea that tomorrow brings a clean slate, free from mistakes. This line is one of the most quoted in the novel because it captures Anne's essential trait: an unwavering optimism that acknowledges challenges yet chooses to look beyond them. It also reflects her growing maturity—she can fully recognize her mistake and still decide to move forward. Mrs. Allan has already come upstairs to console her and the guests have gone home, and Anne's reaction shows that she's already starting to regain her usual spirit.

““I’ve had a splendid time,” she concluded happily, “and I feel that it marks an epoch in my life. But the best of it all was the coming home.””

Anne · Chapter XXIX

Why it matters

Anne shares this sentiment at the end of Chapter XXIX, reflecting on her trip with Diana to Charlottetown for the Exhibition at Miss Josephine Barry's home. The visit has been filled with wonders — the Exhibition grounds, a concert, ice cream at eleven o'clock — yet Anne states that "the best of it all was the coming home." This line signals a significant change from the child who once arrived at Green Gables with nowhere to go back to. Green Gables has transformed from a place she merely hopes to stay in to a place she truly yearns to return to. Her comment also subtly resolves the anxiety expressed in the novel's early chapters: Anne has found a place where she belongs, and she is aware of it.

“I’m not a bit changed--not really. I’m only just pruned down and branched out.”

Anne · to Marilla · Chapter XXXIV

Why it matters

Anne expresses this in Chapter XXXIV as she gets ready to leave for Queen's Academy, reacting to Marilla's tearful feeling that the child she once knew has changed. Anne asserts that she is not changed at all, not really. She tells Marilla she is "only just pruned down and branched out." This metaphor comes from the natural world that Anne has always cherished, illustrating the novel’s view on growth: true development doesn’t erase who you were, but rather shapes and expands upon it. For Marilla, who mourns the loss of the small, chatty girl who first arrived at Green Gables, Anne's words provide genuine comfort. For the reader, they affirm that Anne's core self — her warmth, imagination, and capacity for love — has endured through years of education and discipline.

“I don’t know what lies around the bend, but I’m going to believe that the best does.”

Anne · Chapter XXXVIII

Why it matters

Anne says this to Marilla in Chapter XXXVIII, the final chapter of the novel, as she explains her decision to give up the Avery scholarship, stay home, care for Marilla, and teach. Facing a future that is quieter and more limited than she once imagined, she tells Marilla that her road now has a bend in it. Instead of giving in to despair, she embraces hope: "I don't know what lies around the bend, but I'm going to believe that the best does." The bend in the road serves as the novel's closing metaphor for Anne's life philosophy—she may not see what lies ahead, but she naturally leans towards possibility instead of fear. It's a fitting conclusion for a character known for her unwavering hope.

Study07–08

07·Questions

Questions readers ask about Anne Shirley

Why does Anne insist on spelling her name with an E?

Anne explains that "A-n-n looks dreadful, but A-n-n-e looks so much more distinguished" (Chapter III). For her, how it's spelled reflects her identity and dignity — a subtle but strong statement of who she is.

Why does Anne smash her slate over Gilbert Blythe's head?

In Chapter XV, Gilbert holds out the end of her braid and calls her carrots in a piercing whisper in the middle of class. Anne, who feels very self-conscious about her red hair, jumps up in anger and brings the slate crashing down on his head. Later, she expresses that he has "hurt my feelings excruciatingly."

How does Anne react when she is told she can stay at Green Gables?

She suddenly starts crying, not quite sure why, exclaiming, "I'm so happy," and vows to do her best to be good. All morning, she had been shaking with anxiety, too scared to ask (Chapter VIII).

What happens during the amethyst brooch affair?

Anne admits she went into Marilla's room and pinned the brooch on to see how it looked, but insists she put it back on the bureau. Marilla doesn't believe her and sends her to her room to stay there until she confesses. In Chapter XIV, Anne at first sticks to her denial, but to get to the picnic she invents a false confession, and the brooch later turns up caught on Marilla's black lace shawl.

What is Anne's relationship with Diana Barry like?

Diana is Anne's first real friend and "bosom friend," and Anne looks at their friendship with a sense of eager hope. She mentions that she has to "furnish most of the imagination," but she thinks of Diana as "simply perfect in every other way" (Chapter XIII).

How does Anne get along with Marilla?

Their relationship has its share of friction; Marilla is strict and unsentimental, while Anne is emotional and talkative. Yet, genuine warmth develops beneath the surface. Marilla secretly enjoys Anne's impulsive kiss in Chapter XIII and, in Chapter IX, finds herself growing too interested in Anne's chatter before she cuts it short.

What does Anne think of her own appearance?

She feels self-conscious about her red hair and thin frame, avoids wearing pink because it doesn’t suit her coloring, and checks her elbows every morning, wishing for dimples. She’s taken aback and touched when she hears, through someone else, that she has a pretty nose (Chapter XV).

How does Anne feel about looking forward to things, even when she risks disappointment?

She tells Marilla that "looking forward to things is half the pleasure of them" and that expecting nothing would be worse than facing disappointment — a direct challenge to Mrs. Lynde's more cautious outlook (Chapter XIII).

08·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Anne's habit of naming places (Lover's Lane, Violet Vale, Willowmere, Idlewild) as a form of imaginative ownership: how does renaming the world offer a homeless child a sense of belonging and identity?

  • The tension between Anne's romantic imagination and Marilla's practical outlook: how does the novel use this contrast to explore what a child needs in order to thrive?

  • Anne's pride and her ability for remorse: trace the pattern where her temper leads to embarrassment and her honesty brings redemption (as seen in the Mrs. Lynde episode, the brooch incident, and the slate incident).

  • The significance of names and naming throughout Anne's story, from her insistence on the E in her name to "Ann Shirley has a very bad temper" on the blackboard: how does the novel explore the power of language to define and diminish a person?

  • Anne as a reader and storyteller: how does her deep engagement with books and fairy tales shape both her joys and her social challenges?

Anne of Green Gables

Continue

Full study guide →