Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · Anne's academic rival and eventual friend

Gilbert Blythe

in Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery

Gilbert Blythe is Anne Shirley's main academic rival, but by the end of the novel, he becomes her friend. He shows up at Avonlea school as a tall boy with curly hair, "roguish hazel eyes, and a mouth twisted into a teasing smile," already a top student. A careless moment — tugging on Anne's braid and calling her "Carrots" — sparks a feud that lasts five years and influences both of their school experiences. During this time, Gilbert pursues the rivalry in a lighthearted manner, often attempting to reconcile while Anne rebuffs all his attempts. He earns the Queen's Academy medal but chooses to forfeit the sought-after teaching position in Avonlea so Anne can remain home with Marilla — a selfless act that finally softens Anne's pride. When she stops him on the road to express her gratitude, they shake hands and agree to be "the best of friends," putting an end to their long-standing quarrel and acknowledging the warmth that has built up over five years. Gilbert is defined by his determination, generosity, and an easy-going nature that contrasts with Anne's intensity; he is smart enough to keep up with her academically, yet gracious enough to step back when her needs outweigh his own ambitions.

About this character

Role
Anne's academic rival and eventual friend
Form
Novel
Author
L. M. Montgomery
First published
1908

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Gilbert Blythe?

Gilbert Blythe enters the story as a confident and well-liked schoolboy who is "used to being head of his class." He stands out physically — tall, with curly brown hair and hazel eyes — and is socially comfortable, teasing girls and joking with his classmates. However, he also shows genuine remorse: when he realizes he has hurt Anne, he quickly apologizes at the porch door and continues to seek her forgiveness for years. His ambition is sincere — the rest of the Queen's class tacitly acknowledges that he and Anne lead it — but it never turns into jealousy. He heartily congratulates Anne when she surpasses him and eventually withdraws his own application for the Avonlea school to give her the opportunity.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Gilbert Blythe's arc and motivation?

Gilbert's journey is one of patient, mostly unreciprocated goodwill. He starts as the boy who carelessly hurts Anne's pride and then spends the rest of the novel trying to mend that wound. His motivation evolves from a simple desire to be liked to a genuine wish for the intellectual companionship that Anne could provide. By the time of the Queen’s exams, he has stopped seeking her friendship and chooses to ignore her as she has ignored him — yet he still acts in her best interest when it counts. His final act, giving up the Avonlea position and opting for White Sands at a personal financial loss, resolves the plot and solidifies his character as someone who prioritizes others over his own benefit.

03·Key moments

What are Gilbert Blythe's key moments?

  • Chapter XV — "Carrots!": Gilbert pins Ruby Gillis's braid to her seat and later tries to make Anne look at him; when she ignores him, he grabs her braid and whispers "Carrots!" Anne retaliates by smashing her slate over his head. He tells Mr. Phillips that it was his fault because he teased her, but the teacher pays no heed. His immediate apology at the porch goes ignored.
  • Chapter XVII — The strawberry apple: Gilbert leaves a big strawberry apple on Anne's desk; she drops it as if it were a red-hot coal and leaves it untouched, signaling that even small peace offerings will not be accepted.
  • Chapter XXVIII — The pond rescue: Gilbert rows under the bridge, finds Anne clinging to a pile, and brings her to shore. He renews his plea for friendship; Anne coldly refuses. He springs into his skiff with an angry color in his cheeks and declares he will never ask again — and he keeps his word.
  • Chapter XXXII — The pass list: Anne and Gilbert tie for first place on the Entrance list, their names appearing together at the top of two hundred.
  • Chapter XXXVI — The medal: Gilbert wins the Queen's medal; Anne wins the Avery scholarship. The hall erupts with "Hurrah for Blythe, Medalist!"
  • Chapter XXXVIII — The school and the reconciliation: Gilbert withdraws his application for the Avonlea school for Anne's sake and signs with White Sands at his own cost. Anne stops him on the road, thanks him, and they shake hands, agreeing to be "the best of friends."

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Gilbert Blythe's most important relationships?

Gilbert's relationship with Anne drives his role in the novel. Every significant action he takes is aimed at or influenced by her: the initial insult, the years of rivalry, the repeated attempts to reconcile, and the ultimate sacrifice. Anne's refusal to forgive him is portrayed as a flaw in her character — the narrator speaks of her unpraiseworthy tenacity for holding grudges — while Gilbert's persistence is consistently seen as commendable. By the time Anne realizes she has forgiven and forgotten without knowing it, Gilbert has already stopped asking, making the reconciliation dependent entirely on his generous act rather than any softening word from him. His brief connection with Ruby Gillis at Queen's mainly highlights what he and Anne miss: Ruby tells Jane Andrews that she does not understand half the things Gilbert says, while Anne thinks she and Gilbert might have had many merry and interesting conversations. Marilla's mention that she and Gilbert's father John were once close friends adds a subtle generational layer to the relationship between Gilbert and Anne.

05·Connected characters

How is Gilbert Blythe connected to the other characters?

Anne Shirley

Anne is Gilbert's academic rival and the girl he persistently tries to befriend; his teasing insult about her hair starts a five-year feud that ends only when his self-sacrifice on her behalf moves her to forgive him and the two become close friends at last.

Ruby Gillis

At Queen's Academy, Gilbert nearly always walks with Ruby Gillis and carries her satchel, though Anne privately doubts she is the sort of person with whom he could discuss books and ambitions.

Marilla Cuthbert

Marilla remembers Gilbert's father John Blythe as an old friend and possible beau, and she speaks warmly of Gilbert himself, noting how tall and manly he has grown.

Josie Pye

Gilbert drives Josie Pye to the White Sands Hotel concert, where she sits beside him with a triumphant and taunting expression while Anne recites.

Mr. Phillips

When Mr. Phillips punishes Anne for striking Gilbert, it is Gilbert who speaks up to say the fault was his — a gesture the teacher ignores.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Gilbert Blythe

What does Gilbert do that starts the feud with Anne?

In Chapter XV, he picks up the end of Anne's long red braid, holds it out at arm's length, and whispers, "Carrots! Carrots!" Anne jumps up, calls him "mean" and "hateful," and brings her slate crashing down on his head. Later that afternoon, he apologizes at the porch door, but Anne brushes past him in silence.

Does Gilbert ever try to make peace before the final chapter?

Yes, several times. He apologizes right after the slate incident in Chapter XV, leaves a strawberry apple on Anne's desk in Chapter XVII, and directly asks for friendship after saving her from the pond in Chapter XXVIII. Anne turns him down each time.

How does Gilbert rescue Anne in Chapter XXVIII?

While rowing beneath a bridge in Harmon Andrews's dory, he notices Anne clinging to a pile after the flat she was drifting in started to leak. He maneuvers closer, she climbs down into the dory, and he rows her to the landing.

Who wins the Queen's Academy medal?

Gilbert wins the medal. When Anne and her friends arrive at Queen's for the announcements in Chapter XXXVI, they see boys carrying Gilbert on their shoulders, cheering, "Hurrah for Blythe, Medalist!"

Why does Gilbert give up the Avonlea school?

As Mrs. Lynde explains in Chapter XXXVIII, when Gilbert learned that Anne had applied for the Avonlea position, he immediately withdrew his application and recommended that the trustees accept hers. He understood that Anne needed to be at home with Marilla. Instead, he signed a contract to teach at White Sands, which would cost him personally since he has to support himself through college.

What does Marilla reveal about Gilbert's family?

In Chapter XXXVII, Marilla shares with Anne that Gilbert's father, John Blythe, was a close friend from her youth—people even referred to him as her beau—and seeing Gilbert in church brought back those memories for her.

How is the rivalry between Anne and Gilbert described at Queen's?

In Chapter XXXV, the novel mentions that the medal contest had "practically narrowed down to three — Gilbert Blythe, Anne Shirley, and Lewis Wilson." It also notes that Anne's rivalry with Gilbert was "as intense as it had ever been in Avonlea school, although... the bitterness had gone out of it" — she now wanted to win for the pride of a hard-earned victory rather than just to beat him.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Gilbert as a foil to Anne: how his good nature and generosity highlight her pride and stubbornness.

  • The role of academic rivalry: how the competition between Anne and Gilbert fuels her ambition and shapes the novel's middle section.

  • Self-sacrifice as a resolution of conflict: what Gilbert's withdrawal of his school application reveals about Montgomery's values and the moral framework of the novel.

  • Gender and friendship: Anne's observation that "masculine friendship might also be a good thing to round out one's conceptions of companionship"

    what this suggests about the novel's approach to cross-gender relationships.

  • The delayed reconciliation: why Montgomery waits until the final chapter for the handshake, and how that timing influences the reader's experience of both characters.

Anne of Green Gables

Continue

Full study guide →