Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · Matthew's sister, who raises Anne at Green Gables

Marilla Cuthbert

in Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery

Marilla Cuthbert is the no-nonsense, sharp-tongued head of Green Gables who, along with her brother Matthew, ends up taking in the orphan Anne Shirley by chance and ultimately decides to keep her. Tall, thin, and angular, Marilla has a "rigid conscience" and limited life experience, which leads her to be wary of imagination, spontaneity, and open expressions of emotion. She maintains her home and garden with almost obsessive neatness, attends church regularly adorned with her cherished amethyst brooch, and manages Anne with strict rules, quick corrections, and a brisk demeanor that often conceals her genuine warmth. However, glimpses of that warmth appear often: she feels "secretly vastly pleased" by Anne's spontaneous kiss, admires Anne's nose in silence, and feels a "qualm of conscience" at the thought of handing Anne over to the stern Mrs. Blewett. As her relationship with Anne develops, Marilla begins to soften, and by the later chapters, her health starts to decline—she comes back from town one evening clearly downcast after a visit to the oculist. Marilla's journey is about a woman whose long-suppressed sense of humor and emotion is gradually awakened by the very child she nearly rejected.

About this character

Role
Matthew's sister, who raises Anne at Green Gables
Form
Novel
Author
L. M. Montgomery
First published
1908

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Marilla Cuthbert?

Marilla Cuthbert is introduced in Chapter I as "a tall, thin woman, with angles and without curves." Her dark hair is "twisted up in a hard little knot," with wire hairpins "stuck aggressively through it." The narrator notes that "she looked like a woman of narrow experience and rigid conscience, which she was; but there was a saving something about her mouth which, if it had been ever so slightly developed, might have been considered indicative of a sense of humor." She keeps Green Gables impeccably clean, is "always slightly distrustful of sunshine," and sees the world as something "meant to be taken seriously." Her most cherished possession is an amethyst brooch inherited from her mother—an unusual sentimental attachment for an otherwise unsentimental woman.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Marilla Cuthbert's arc and motivation?

Marilla's initial motivation is purely practical: Matthew's aging heart and the challenge of finding farm help lead her to consider adopting a boy. When a girl shows up instead, her first instinct is to send her back. Marilla decides to keep Anne partly because of Matthew's silent insistence and partly due to her conscience—she can't bring herself to hand Anne over to the "sharp-faced" Mrs. Blewett. From this point, her journey is one of gradual, reluctant opening. She constantly corrects Anne, withholds praise, and resists imagination ("I couldn't," she says grimly when Anne suggests picturing her as an aunt), yet she bakes a picnic basket, defends Anne's meals during the punishment in Chapter X, and feels "startling sweetness" at Anne's first spontaneous kiss in Chapter XIII. By Chapter XXXVIII, her physical decline has started, adding vulnerability to a character previously marked by rigid self-sufficiency.

03·Key moments

What are Marilla Cuthbert's key moments?

  • Chapter I: Marilla calmly shares the adoption plan with Mrs. Lynde, reflecting her practical reasoning and her tendency to defer to Matthew on matters he feels strongly about.
  • Chapter III: Confronted with a sobbing Anne, Marilla reveals "a reluctant smile, rather rusty from long disuse"—the first crack in her sternness.
  • Chapter VI: Marilla experiences "a qualm of conscience" about sending Anne to Mrs. Blewett, a moment that nudges her toward keeping the child.
  • Chapter VIII: She tells Anne she can stay, framing it cautiously ("if you will try to be a good little girl"), and is left puzzled by Anne's tears of joy.
  • Chapter XIII: Anne's impulsive kiss brings "that sudden sensation of startling sweetness" to Marilla, who responds brusquely to hide her pleasure.
  • Chapter XIV: The amethyst brooch incident highlights Marilla's strict sense of justice—she is "determining to be just" even while believing Anne is lying.
  • Chapter XXXVIII: Marilla comes back from the oculist and sits at the kitchen table with her head on her hand, limp and dejected in a way Anne has never seen, signaling a shift in the novel's emotional center of gravity.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Marilla Cuthbert's most important relationships?

Marilla and Matthew function as a complementary pair: his quiet persistence balances her vocal authority, and she consistently submits when he "sets his mind" on something, viewing it as her "duty." With Anne, Marilla is the primary shaping influence—establishing rules, administering punishments, teaching prayers and household skills—but Anne's unyielding affection influences her in return. Marilla's friendship with Mrs. Lynde is described as existing "in spite of—or perhaps because of—their dissimilarity," serving partly as a social check on Marilla's isolation at Green Gables.

05·Connected characters

How is Marilla Cuthbert connected to the other characters?

Matthew Cuthbert

Marilla's brother and co-keeper of Green Gables; she defers to his quiet but persistent wishes, including the decision to keep Anne, while also checking his tendency to indulge the child.

Anne Shirley

The orphan Marilla reluctantly agrees to keep; their relationship is the novel's central bond, with Marilla acting as disciplinarian and moral guide while Anne's affection gradually softens Marilla's rigid exterior.

Mrs. Rachel Lynde

Marilla's nearest neighbor and long-standing friend, whose dissimilarity from Marilla paradoxically sustains their friendship; in Chapter I Marilla tells Mrs. Lynde about the plan to adopt a boy, though the Spencers had already been asked to bring one.

Diana Barry

Anne's best friend, whose visits and play Marilla monitors and regulates, granting or withholding time as a matter of household discipline.

The evidence06

06·Key quotes

What are Marilla Cuthbert’s key quotes?

“I love you as dear as if you were my own flesh and blood and you’ve been my joy and comfort ever since you came to Green Gables.”

Marilla · to Anne · Chapter XXXVII

Why it matters

Marilla speaks these words in Chapter XXXVII on the night of Matthew's death, coming to comfort Anne in the darkness. Throughout most of the novel, Marilla struggles to express her love openly — the narrator mentions in Chapter XXX that this is a lesson she has never quite mastered. In this moment of grief, her usual reserve fades away, and she tells Anne directly: "I love you as dear as if you were my own flesh and blood and you've been my joy and comfort ever since you came to Green Gables." This declaration holds even more weight because it has taken so long to be expressed. It confirms what the reader has long suspected and provides Anne — who grew up feeling unloved — with the clearest possible assurance that she is, and always has been, truly wanted.

Study07–08

07·Questions

Questions readers ask about Marilla Cuthbert

Why does Marilla decide to keep Anne instead of sending her back?

Marilla feels uneasy about the idea of sending Anne to Mrs. Blewett, known for being a tough employer. This concern, along with Matthew's gentle but strong desire to keep Anne, influences her choice. In Chapter VIII, she tells Anne, "Matthew and I have decided to keep you—that is, if you will try to be a good little girl."

What does Marilla's amethyst brooch represent?

The brooch is referred to as Marilla's "most treasured possession." It's an old-fashioned oval piece that holds a braid of her mother's hair, surrounded by amethysts, which her seafaring uncle passed down through her mother. She wears it to church every Sunday without fail, treating its absence like forgetting her Bible. This brooch is one of the few items in the novel that links Marilla to her emotions and her family.

How does Marilla handle discipline?

Marilla enforces rules consistently and without apology. She keeps Anne in her room until she apologizes to Mrs. Lynde, brings her meals instead of letting her go hungry, and assigns extra patchwork to help her focus. She expects Anne to obey promptly and corrects her speech, habits, and religious knowledge. Still, she is fair: before accusing Anne of losing the brooch, she searches her room thoroughly.

Does Marilla ever show affection for Anne?

She does, but usually in an indirect way. When Anne kisses her cheek in Chapter XIII, Marilla experiences "that sudden sensation of startling sweetness" and feels "secretly vastly pleased," but she responds brusquely to mask her emotions. Deep down, she thinks Anne's nose is "a remarkable pretty one" but won't admit it. Marilla's care often shows through her actions—like baking the picnic basket and making sure Anne eats during punishment—rather than through words.

What is Marilla's relationship with Mrs. Rachel Lynde?

The novel portrays "something that for lack of any other name might be called friendship" between them, existing "in spite of—or perhaps because of—their dissimilarity." Marilla expects Mrs. Lynde to be curious about Matthew's errand in Chapter I and feels a bit relieved when she departs, but it’s clear that the two women have been confidantes for a long time.

Why won't Marilla let Anne call her 'Aunt Marilla'?

Marilla tells Anne directly in Chapter VIII, "I'm not your aunt and I don’t believe in calling people names that don’t belong to them." When Anne suggests they could just imagine it, Marilla responds, "I couldn’t." This exchange highlights her unwillingness to mix reality with imagination, a key characteristic that the novel contrasts with Anne's fondness for fantasy.

What is happening to Marilla by the later chapters?

In Chapter XXXVIII Marilla returns from a visit to an oculist and is found sitting "limply inert" with a dejected air that Anne has never seen in her before. The oculist warns that unless she gives up reading, sewing and any work that strains her eyes, she will be blind within six months.

08·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Rigidity and feeling

    How does Montgomery use small physical details—the rusty smile, the startling sweetness of a kiss, the dejected posture in Chapter XXXVIII—to illustrate Marilla's emotional thaw without her ever declaring it openly?

  • Discipline as care

    Marilla's strictness (timed returns, patchwork squares, dishcloth scalding) can be seen as an unconventional form of nurturing; explore how the novel presents rule-giving as a language of love.

  • Imagination vs. practicality

    Marilla's flat refusal to envision things "different from what they really are" creates a lasting contrast with Anne; consider what the novel suggests each perspective costs and gains.

  • The brooch episode as moral test

    Chapter XIV presents a conflict between Marilla's commitment to truth and her willingness to convict based on circumstantial evidence—what does this reveal about the limits of her "rigid conscience"?

  • Female self-sufficiency and its costs

    Marilla has managed Green Gables with Matthew in a household clearly lacking children or conventional domestic warmth; examine what Anne's arrival reveals about the emotional cost of that self-sufficiency.

Anne of Green Gables

Continue

Full study guide →