Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · Marilla's brother, who fetches Anne from the station and becomes her quiet champion

Matthew Cuthbert

in Anne of Green Gables by L. M. Montgomery

Matthew Cuthbert is the quiet, reclusive co-owner of Green Gables farm and Marilla's brother. Often referred to as "the shyest man alive," he feels uneasy around strangers, avoids conversation, and has never been one to share information voluntarily. When he heads to Bright River to pick up the boy the Cuthberts planned to adopt, he unexpectedly finds Anne Shirley instead. Rather than correct the mix-up at the station, he takes her home, leaving Marilla to address the situation, and on the drive he finds himself enjoying her endless chatter. From that initial ride, he becomes Anne's unwavering, silent supporter: he stands by her against Mrs. Lynde, sneaks upstairs to check on her during her tough times, brings her chocolate from Carmody, listens to her stories in the barn, and continually tells Marilla to let Anne attend the concert. His support comes not through debate but through steadfast, quiet persistence — an opinion expressed once and held forever. He is also a gentle confidant, urging Anne not to give up all of her romance but to keep a little of it. Marilla recognizes his "infatuation" with Anne with a mix of exasperation and affection, while Anne, in turn, gauges her successes and setbacks partly based on how Matthew will feel about them.

About this character

Role
Marilla's brother, who fetches Anne from the station and becomes her quiet champion
Form
Novel
Author
L. M. Montgomery
First published
1908

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Matthew Cuthbert?

Matthew Cuthbert is a sixty-year-old farmer living on Prince Edward Island, often described as "the shyest man alive." He has an awkward build, long iron-gray hair, and a full brown beard he's maintained since he was twenty. He’s uncomfortable around women and strangers, seldom ventures outside his home, and has never been one to share information freely. His father was just as reserved, and Green Gables — built at the edge of the cleared land and barely visible from the road — reflects the family's tendency to retreat. Yet, beneath this shyness lies a man with deep loyalty and quiet moral courage.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Matthew Cuthbert's arc and motivation?

Matthew's journey is one of unexpected attachment. He intends to adopt a boy but returns home with a girl, Anne, and he can't bear to let her down. From that moment on, his motivation is clear and unwavering: he wants Anne to stay, find happiness, and be treated fairly. He may not argue much — "argument was not his strong point, but holding fast to his opinion certainly was" — but he consistently reiterates his views until they prevail. His support for Anne gives him a sense of purpose and a relationship he never knew he wanted.

03·Key moments

What are Matthew Cuthbert's key moments?

In Chapter II, Matthew meets Anne at Bright River station and, unable to explain the mix-up, decides to take her home silently, letting Marilla handle the situation — a protective evasion that defines his relationship with her. In Chapter IV, Marilla realizes that he wishes to keep Anne "just as much this morning as he had the night before," and that his silent determination is "ten times more potent" than an argument. In Chapter X, while Marilla is out, he tiptoes upstairs to check on the confined child, whispering "how are you making it, Anne?" — a tender act of stealth. In Chapter XII, he produces chocolate treats from his pocket and glances at Marilla with a "deprecatory look," a small gesture that brings joy to Anne. In Chapter XIX, he states "I think you ought to let Anne go" three times over two days, showcasing his quiet but unwavering support. In Chapter XXVIII, he places a hand on Anne's shoulder and whispers, "Don't give up all your romance, Anne … keep a little of it" — his most intimate and revealing moment. In Chapter XXXVI, when Anne loses the medal, her first thought is that "Matthew would be sorry — he had been so sure she would win," highlighting how his faith in her has become part of her self-worth.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Matthew Cuthbert's most important relationships?

With Marilla, Matthew shares a lifetime of comfortable silence and possesses a fundamentally different temperament. She manages the household and Anne's upbringing; he accepts this division but speaks up when it's about Anne. Their relationship is marked by mutual exasperation and a deep, unspoken understanding. With Anne, Matthew develops a bond that complements their personalities: her chatter fills his quiet, while his unwavering admiration fuels her imagination. He’s the only adult who never corrects or disciplines her, who listens to her stories, praises her recitations, and sneaks her treats. In return, Anne reads him her stories, discusses ministers and politics, and measures her self-worth partly by his confidence in her.

05·Connected characters

How is Matthew Cuthbert connected to the other characters?

Marilla Cuthbert

Matthew's sister and fellow keeper of Green Gables; they share the decision to keep Anne, though Marilla holds authority over the child's upbringing and frequently has to fend off Matthew's quiet partisanship on Anne's behalf.

Anne Shirley

Matthew is Anne's first friend at Green Gables and her most unconditional admirer; he brings her small gifts, defends her to Marilla, listens to her stories, and encourages her imagination, while Anne measures her successes and sorrows in part by how he will receive them.

Mrs. Rachel Lynde

A near neighbour whose sharp eye first notices Matthew's unusual outing; after Anne's outburst, Matthew tells Marilla she is a 'meddlesome old gossip' who deserved her calling down.

The evidence06

06·Key quotes

What are Matthew Cuthbert’s key quotes?

“We might be some good to her,” said Matthew suddenly and unexpectedly.”

Matthew · Chapter III

Why it matters

Matthew speaks these words in Chapter III during a late-night conversation when Marilla insists that Anne must be sent back to the asylum. The narrator says Matthew speaks "suddenly and unexpectedly," highlighting how unusual it is for the shy, quiet Matthew to assert himself. However, the simplicity of the phrase — "We might be some good to her" — hits the mark perfectly: it shifts the focus from what Anne can do for the Cuthberts to what they can do for her. This small change in perspective becomes the foundation for everything that follows. Matthew's instinct to prioritize Anne's well-being over their own convenience makes him the first person in her life to truly consider her needs, and it marks the moment when the possibility of her staying at Green Gables becomes real.

“Well now, I’d rather have you than a dozen boys, Anne,” said Matthew patting her hand.”

Matthew · to Anne · Chapter XXXVI

Why it matters

Matthew expresses this in Chapter XXXVI, the evening after Anne comes home from Queen's with the Avery scholarship. He gently pats her hand and tells her he would "rather have you than a dozen boys." This statement is significant because it resonates with the novel's beginning: the Cuthberts initially wanted a boy to assist on the farm, and Anne’s arrival was seen as an error. Matthew's words serve as a quiet, conclusive acknowledgment of that error — it turned out to be the best thing that ever happened to them. The narrator calls this the last night before sorrow touched Anne's life, adding a layer of bittersweet tenderness to Matthew's words: they are some of the last he shares with her.

““My girl--my girl that I’m proud of.””

Matthew · Chapter XXXVII

Why it matters

Matthew speaks these words in Chapter XXXVI, at the gate on the evening before his death, after reminding Anne that a girl won the Avery scholarship. He dies the next day, collapsing in the porch doorway after reading of the Abbey Bank's failure. The phrase — "My girl--my girl that I'm proud of" — is directed to Anne and represents the emotional peak of their relationship. Matthew has always shown his love for Anne through small, quiet gestures rather than overt declarations: the Christmas dress, the chocolate treats, the gentle encouragement. In these words, spoken on his last evening, he articulates what Anne has longed to hear: that she is cherished, that she is loved, and that she brings him pride. Later, Anne remembers these words on the night after his death, and they finally unlock her tears.

Study07–08

07·Questions

Questions readers ask about Matthew Cuthbert

Why does Matthew bring Anne home instead of explaining the mistake at the station?

Matthew decides right then and there that he "could not tell this child with the glowing eyes that there had been a mistake." He thinks that she can't be left at Bright River anyway, so any explanations can wait until they are safely back at Green Gables, where Marilla can take care of it.

How does Matthew show his support for Anne without arguing with Marilla?

He shares his opinion plainly and repeats it without further explanation. In the concert episode, he says "I think you ought to let Anne go" three times over two days, and the novel mentions that "argument was not his strong point, but holding fast to his opinion certainly was."

What does Matthew think of Anne's abilities at school?

He tells Anne that Mr. Phillips called her "the smartest scholar in school" and mentioned she was making "rapid progress." He adds that he thinks she is "all right at anything." The narrator points out that he would have considered anyone who praised Anne to be "all right."

How does Matthew feel about Anne's imagination and storytelling?

He is an enthusiastic listener. He tells Anne her story is "fine" when Marilla dismisses it as "stuff and nonsense," invites her to recite poetry in the barn, and listens to her fairy tales so closely that he can't distinguish where the made-up ending begins and the original ends. He also whispers to her not to give up all her romance but to keep a little of it.

What is Matthew's relationship with women generally?

He feels uneasy around all women except Marilla and Mrs. Rachel Lynde, convinced that "the mysterious creatures were secretly laughing at him." He thinks approaching a strange girl is harder than facing a lion in its den, which makes his quick warmth toward Anne all the more surprising.

How does Anne's success or failure affect Matthew?

When Anne believes Gilbert's medal means she has failed, her first thought is that Matthew would be sorry, because he had been so sure she would win. This shows that his belief in her has become an internal benchmark for her.

08·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Matthew's silence as a form of moral agency: how the novel portrays reticence not as passivity but as an effective way to influence.

  • The contrast between Matthew's unconditional acceptance and Marilla's disciplinary love, examining what Anne needs from each.

  • Matthew as a foil to conventional masculinity in Avonlea: his shyness, avoidance of public life, and domestic tenderness challenge community expectations.

  • The significance of small gifts (like the chocolate sweeties and the dress with puffed sleeves) as Matthew's language of affection in a novel dominated by Anne's verbal expression.

  • How Matthew's belief in Anne shapes her ambition and her experience of failure, particularly in the Queen's medal incident.

Anne of Green Gables

Continue

Full study guide →