Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · Pirate ally of Pompey

Menas

in Antony and Cleopatra by William Shakespeare

Menas is a pirate captain serving Pompey, introduced in Act I as one of two "famous pirates" — along with Menecrates — who dominate the sea and intimidate the Italian coastline, providing much of the military threat to Pompey’s cause. He makes his first appearance in Act II as a clever, straightforward adviser who has a better grasp of political reality than his master. While Pompey tends toward optimism and generosity, Menas offers practical insights: he reports on Caesar and Lepidus's movements, assesses the Antony–Caesar alliance's instability, and — most notably — suggests assassinating the three world leaders while they are drunk on Pompey's ship. When Pompey declines on moral grounds, Menas vows in an aside never to follow "thy palled fortunes more," signaling a clear split between his pragmatic self-interest and his master's principles. He openly acknowledges his piratical background, engages in witty banter with Enobarbus as an equal, and exhibits a sardonic awareness that Pompey is squandering his fortunes at the very feast meant to celebrate peace. His concise yet impactful appearances serve as a vehicle for political realism and contrast with Pompey's misguided idealism.

About this character

Role
Pirate ally of Pompey
Form
Play
Author
William Shakespeare
First published
1623

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Menas?

Menas is first mentioned in Act I as one of two "famous pirates" whose naval raids on Italy bolster Pompey's rebellion. When he appears in person in Act II, he acts as Pompey's intelligence officer and strategic advisor—reporting troop movements, analyzing political alliances, and ultimately suggesting the boldest move in the play: assassinating all three triumvirs at once.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Menas's arc and motivation?

Menas starts as a loyal servant—"I have ever held my cap off to thy fortunes"—and his loyalty is based more on practicality than sentiment. He is driven by ambition and seizing opportunities: he wants Pompey to become "lord of all the world" and sees a clear route to that goal. When Pompey declines due to honor, Menas's loyalty evaporates instantly. His aside, that whoever seeks and will not take what is once offered shall never find it again, indicates that he gauges loyalty by results, not feelings. By Act III, he is mentioned only in passing, as the source of Enobarbus's report that Lepidus has been unwell since the feast.

03·Key moments

What are Menas's key moments?

Act II, Scene i: Menas challenges Pompey's complacent belief that Caesar and Lepidus are still in Rome, informing him, based on his source Silvius, that they are already on the move—a piece of intelligence that Pompey dismisses as a fantasy, highlighting the disconnect between Menas's realism and his master's wishful thinking.

Act II, Scene vi (after the treaty): Alone with Enobarbus, Menas makes an aside about how Pompey's father "would ne'er have made this treaty," immediately showing his skepticism regarding the peace. His conversation with Enobarbus—where they both acknowledge their past as pirates and soldiers with dry humor—and his sharp observation that "Pompey doth this day laugh away his fortune" establish him as the most astute political observer on stage at this moment.

Act II, Scene vii (the galley feast): Menas's proposal to Pompey is the dramatic highlight of the scene. He whispers urgently, pushes through two rejections, and ultimately lays out the plan plainly: he will cut the cable and, once they are put off, fall to the triumvirs' throats. Pompey's refusal, that his honour leads his profit and not the reverse, marks a turning point. Menas's subsequent aside signifies his departure from Pompey's service, even if not officially.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Menas's most important relationships?

Menas and Pompey: Their relationship is marked by imbalanced pragmatism. Menas serves faithfully and thinks strategically for Pompey, but Pompey’s code of honor clashes with the ruthless opportunism Menas represents. Pompey's reply, that Menas should have done the deed without speaking of it, captures the contradiction: he would have welcomed the outcome but cannot condone the act once it's suggested. For Menas, a missed opportunity is a lost opportunity forever, leading him to draw logical conclusions.

Menas and Enobarbus: Their exchange after the treaty represents a meeting of two pragmatic subordinates who see further than their leaders. Both acknowledge being "thieves" in their respective environments; they agree that the Antony–Octavia marriage is based on policy rather than love and will ultimately undermine the alliance it aims to strengthen. This scene gives Menas an intellectual equal and emphasizes that the sharpest political insights in the play often come from those outside the highest ranks.

05·Connected characters

How is Menas connected to the other characters?

Pompey

Menas is Pompey's loyal pirate captain and military asset, but their relationship fractures on the galley when Pompey refuses Menas's plan to murder the triumvirs, prompting Menas to vow privately that he will follow Pompey's fortunes no longer.

Enobarbus

Menas and Enobarbus meet as counterparts after the treaty at Misenum, exchanging sharp, mutually respectful banter about their respective reputations by sea and land, and sharing a cynical analysis of the Antony–Octavia marriage.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Menas

Who is Menas and what is his role in Pompey's forces?

Menas is introduced in Act I as one of two "famous pirates," alongside Menecrates. Together, they command the sea and carry out raids along the Italian coastline, enhancing Pompey's reputation to a level that surpasses his military might. Additionally, Menas serves as an intelligence source and strategic adviser to Pompey.

What does Menas propose on Pompey's galley, and why does Pompey refuse?

Menas urges Pompey to allow him to sever the galley's cable and eliminate the three triumvirs—Antony, Caesar, and Lepidus—while they are on board, which would position Pompey as "lord of all the world." However, Pompey declines, explaining that once the idea is voiced, it becomes dishonorable for him to approve it. He tells Menas that his honour leads his profit, not his profit his honour.

How does Menas react when Pompey refuses his plan?

In an aside, Menas resolves never to follow Pompey's "palled fortunes" again, and reflects that whoever will not take a chance once offered shall never find it again.

What does Menas think of the treaty Pompey makes with the triumvirs?

Right after the treaty is agreed, Menas remarks in an aside that Pompey's father "would ne'er have made this treaty," and he tells Enobarbus that "Pompey doth this day laugh away his fortune."

What do Menas and Enobarbus discuss after the treaty?

They discuss their reputations openly — Menas as a sea-thief and Enobarbus as a soldier — before diving into an analysis of the Antony–Octavia marriage. They both agree that it's more of a political arrangement than a love match, and they predict it will lead to conflict instead of strengthening the alliance between Antony and Caesar.

Does Menas believe the marriage of Antony and Octavia will hold the peace?

No. Menas says that "the policy of that purpose made more in the marriage than the love of the parties," and Enobarbus agrees, predicting that Antony will go back to Cleopatra and that Octavia's sighs will stir Caesar against Antony.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Honour versus opportunism: Pompey's rejection of Menas's plan highlights the play's ongoing tension between the Roman code of honor and raw political self-interest—argue whether Shakespeare portrays Pompey's scruples as admirable or counterproductive.

  • The ignored adviser: Menas exemplifies the wise counselor whose advice is disregarded; compare his role to other characters in the play whose warnings go unnoticed.

  • Realism from below: Menas and Enobarbus together suggest that subordinates often perceive political realities more clearly than leaders—explore how Shakespeare uses lower-ranking characters as a chorus of disillusioned realism.

  • Loyalty and its limits: Menas's aside on the galley is one of the play's most direct statements about loyalty being conditional on fortune; trace how this theme appears in other allegiances throughout the play.

  • The pirate as political agent: Menas is introduced as one of two "famous pirates" yet acts as a strategist and intelligence source—consider what Shakespeare accomplishes by blurring the line between outlaw and political player.

Antony and Cleopatra

Continue

Full study guide →