What happens in Chapter 21 of Anne of Green Gables?
The chapter begins on the last day of June as Anne arrives home from school, tearful and explaining that all the girls in her class, herself included, ended up crying at Mr. Phillips's farewell speech, even those who had claimed to dislike him. On their way home, Anne and her classmates catch a glimpse of the new minister, Mr. Allan, and his wife as they arrive in Avonlea. Later that evening, Marilla visits Mrs. Lynde under the pretense of returning quilting frames, while the narrator notes that many in Avonlea find similar excuses to satisfy their curiosity about the new couple. Anne shares her thoughts on the various candidate ministers who preached before Mr. Allan was appointed, and she describes her immediate, heartfelt admiration for Mrs. Allan, who teaches the Sunday school class with warmth and cheer. Marilla decides to invite the Allans over for tea the following Wednesday, and Anne receives permission to bake a layer cake for the occasion. After two days of careful preparation, the tea goes smoothly — even Matthew is persuaded to join in the conversation — until the layer cake is served. Unfortunately, it turns out to be flavored with anodyne liniment instead of vanilla, as Marilla had mistakenly poured leftover liniment into an old vanilla bottle. Mortified, Anne rushes to her room in tears. Mrs. Allan comes upstairs to comfort her kindly and invites her to show off her flower garden. The evening concludes on a positive note, with Anne expressing her trademark optimism: "tomorrow is a new day with no mistakes in it yet," along with the philosophical thought that there must be a limit to how many mistakes one person can make.
Analysis
The chapter revolves around a comic setup of anticipation and disaster. Montgomery spends the first two-thirds detailing Anne's earnest preparations and her strong desire to impress Mrs. Allan, making the liniment cake mishap all the more ironic. The elaborate menu Anne shares with Diana — "jellied chicken and cold tongue," "two kinds of jelly, red and yellow," "Marilla's famous yellow plum preserves" — serves not only as social comedy but also highlights how much Anne has emotionally invested in this event.
The narrative shifts between Anne's excited first-person monologues (shared through dialogue) and a gently ironic third-person narrator who observes, for example, that Marilla's visit to Mrs. Lynde stems from "an amiable weakness shared by most of the Avonlea people." This narrative wink keeps the tone light, even when Anne is truly upset.
The chapter emphasizes a recurring theme of the disconnect between intention and result. Anne tries to hold back tears at school but fails; she aims to bake a perfect cake but ends up poisoning it with liniment. However, each failure finds redemption: the farewell tears turn into a shared, even sweet, moment, and Mrs. Allan's kindness transforms the cake disaster into a genuine bonding experience.
Mrs. Allan is introduced as a "kindred spirit" — the same term Anne uses for her closest relationships — and her visit to Anne's room reflects the comfort Anne longs for. Anne's concluding thought, that "there must be a limit to the mistakes one person can make," is both silly and charming, capturing her resilient, optimistic nature.
Key quotes from Chapter 21
““Marilla, isn’t it nice to think that tomorrow is a new day with no mistakes in it yet?””
Anne says this to Marilla at the close of the chapter, after the guests have left and the liniment-cake disaster is behind her.
“There must be a limit to the mistakes one person can make, and when I get to the end of them, then I’ll be through with them. That’s a very comforting thought.”
Anne offers this philosophy to Marilla when Marilla points out that Anne is always making new mistakes.
“Mercy on us, Anne, you’ve flavored that cake with Anodyne Liniment”
Marilla says this at the tea table after smelling the bottle Anne brought from the pantry, revealing the source of the cake's horrible taste.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign in