What happens in Chapter 16 of Anne of Green Gables?
In Chapter 16, Anne takes care of Green Gables while Marilla visits Mrs. Barry. Taking advantage of the moment, Anne invites her best friend Diana over for tea. Wanting to impress, Anne serves what she thinks is raspberry cordial from the pantry, pouring Diana three big glasses. Diana drinks it eagerly, but soon becomes oddly flushed and unsteady, eventually staggering home. The next day, an angry Mrs. Barry shows up at Green Gables to accuse Anne of intentionally getting Diana drunk; the "cordial" was actually Marilla's three-year-old homemade currant wine. Mrs. Barry forbids Diana from seeing Anne again. Anne is heartbroken, crying uncontrollably over losing her first true friend. Marilla, after tasting the wine herself, privately acknowledges that it is indeed strong and that Anne was innocent in her actions, but Mrs. Barry remains unmoved. The chapter ends with Anne's heartbreak clearly evident: her kindred spirit, Diana, is now off-limits to her.
Analysis
Montgomery crafts this chapter as a comedy of errors that unexpectedly shifts into true emotional depth — a deft tonal change she handles with remarkable skill. The mix-up with the cordial is pure farce: Anne's lack of knowledge about alcohol, her pride in being a good hostess, and Marilla's unmarked pantry create a chain of events that feels both absurd and unavoidable. However, Montgomery skillfully balances the humor with the emotional gravity of the situation. When Mrs. Barry delivers her judgment, the tone shifts dramatically; Anne's sorrow is portrayed without irony or condescension.
This chapter also highlights one of the novel's key themes: Anne's imagination as both a blessing and a burden. Her desire to recreate the "proper" tea she has only read about pushes her to grab the most impressive-looking bottle — her imagination outpacing her practical understanding. Montgomery presents this not as foolishness but as a consequence of a childhood lacking stable domestic foundations.
Marilla's discreet recognition that the wine is strong — something she keeps from Mrs. Barry — is a subtle yet important storytelling choice. It reflects Marilla's deepening, unspoken loyalty to Anne while maintaining the humor in adult stubbornness. The chapter also hints at the ongoing conflict between Anne's romantic ideals and a community that is quick to judge. Diana's absence at the end of the chapter feels like a tangible loss, as Montgomery has illustrated their friendship so vividly in earlier sections that its sudden absence carries significant emotional weight.
Key quotes from Chapter 16
“Marilla, it's a perfectly appalling tragedy. Diana and I are parted forever. Her mother says I got Diana drunk Saturday and she'll never, never let Diana play with me again.”
Anne delivers the catastrophic news to Marilla the morning after Diana's visit, her flair for dramatic language colliding with a situation that is, for once, genuinely serious.
“I do think it is so unkind and unjust of Mrs. Barry to blame me when I honestly didn't know it was wine.”
Anne protests her innocence to Marilla, articulating the novel's persistent theme of a child held accountable for the gaps in her own upbringing.
“I never thought I'd have a bosom friend and now I've lost her.”
Anne mourns Diana's forced absence, the line distilling her lifelong hunger for belonging into a single, unadorned sentence.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign in