What happens in Chapter 16 of Anne of Green Gables?
On a golden October Saturday, Anne brings in armfuls of autumn boughs, and Marilla, on her way to a meeting of the Aid Society in Carmody, gives Anne the go-ahead to invite Diana Barry over for tea. Anne is overjoyed at the chance to host and is permitted to open the cherry preserves and raspberry cordial, but not the cherished rosebud tea set. The two girls spend the afternoon in the orchard munching on apples and swapping school gossip until Diana mentions Gilbert Blythe, prompting Anne to quickly steer the conversation elsewhere. Anne then serves what she thinks is raspberry cordial from the sitting-room pantry. Diana drinks three large tumblers, feels dizzy and unwell, and insists on going home before tea — much to Anne's distress. Two days later, on Monday, Marilla uncovers the truth: Anne had accidentally poured Marilla's three-year-old homemade currant wine, which was stored on the pantry shelf, instead of the actual cordial that was in the cellar. Mrs. Barry, a strict woman who disapproves of wine, is furious and forbids Diana from seeing Anne. Marilla attempts to reason with Mrs. Barry but has no success. Anne then goes to plead her case, speaking passionately, but Mrs. Barry coldly dismisses her. Anne returns to Green Gables feeling heartbroken, declaring that even God struggles with someone as stubborn as Mrs. Barry. That night, Marilla shares a laugh over the story with Matthew, but when she finds Anne asleep in tears, she tenderly kisses the child's cheek.
Analysis
The chapter revolves around a comic irony of misidentification — Anne serves currant wine under the impression that it’s raspberry cordial — but this humor is tempered by real emotional depth. Montgomery divides the chapter into three distinct parts: the cheerful, hopeful preparation for tea; the disastrous afternoon itself; and the somber aftermath filled with accusations and failed attempts at reconciliation. The autumn backdrop introduced in the first paragraph — birches "golden as sunshine," maples "royal crimson," and cherry trees in "dark red and bronzy green" — reflects the chapter's emotional journey: vibrant beauty giving way to a chill. The pale moon illuminating Anne's lonely walk to the Barrys' doorstep highlights this shift in tone.
The narrative perspective remains closely aligned with Anne, allowing the reader to experience her genuine confusion. Her lengthy, meandering story about a mouse in the pudding sauce serves as a brilliant touch of comic characterization; it illustrates how Anne's imagination often distracts her from practical responsibilities, delaying the reader's realization of Diana's deteriorating condition and making Diana's sudden unsteady rise all the more striking.
Additionally, the chapter explores the theme of Anne's theatrical language clashing with a world that misunderstands it. Her passionate appeal to Mrs. Barry — referencing orphanhood, deep friendship, and "a dark cloud of woe" — only frustrates the woman, who suspects mockery. Anne's parting comment, that even God Himself struggles with "such an obstinate person as Mrs. Barry," is both irreverent and poignant. Marilla's final action — laughing at the story before kissing the sleeping child — encapsulates the novel's signature blend of dry humor and gentle warmth.
Key quotes from Chapter 16
“I do not believe that God Himself can do very much with such an obstinate person as Mrs. Barry.”
Anne says this to Marilla after returning from her failed plea at the Barrys' door.
“My heart is broken. The stars in their courses fight against me, Marilla. Diana and I are parted forever.”
Anne laments to Marilla after learning that Mrs. Barry has forbidden Diana from playing with her.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign in