What happens in Chapter 19 of The Canterbury Tales?
The Manciple's Tale retells the myth of Phoebus Apollo and his white crow. Here, Phoebus is portrayed as a virtuous and handsome knight who keeps a white crow in a cage—a bird gifted with a beautiful song and the ability to speak like a human. He also has a wife whom he loves fiercely. While Phoebus is away, his wife takes a lover, notably a man "of little reputation." The crow witnesses this betrayal and, upon Phoebus's return, straightforwardly reports, "I saw him do his work with thee." Consumed by rage, Phoebus kills his wife immediately. However, grief and remorse wash over him right after. He then turns on the crow, blaming it for delivering the devastating news, strips it of its white feathers, takes away its song, and casts it out—cursing all crows to be black for eternity. The Manciple concludes with a lengthy moral inspired by his mother's advice: keep quiet, for speaking only leads to sorrow. The tale finishes not with the myth itself but with this relentless, almost humorous insistence on silence.
Analysis
Chaucer assigns this tale to the Manciple, a provisioner who thrives by knowing when to speak and when to remain silent—and that choice is quietly devastating. The story operates on two levels at once: a myth explaining why crows are black, and a blunt warning about the risks of speaking the truth. Chaucer cleverly strips away the heroism from the myth's protagonist. Phoebus is introduced with extravagant praise ("the flour of bachilrie") only to devolve into jealousy and impulsive murder; this elevation makes his downfall even more grotesque. The crow, on the other hand, is punished not for lying but for telling the truth, flipping the usual moral lessons of fables. This creates the tale's sharpest irony: the Manciple spends over a hundred lines advising silence, yet the story he shares is itself an act of speech, and quite an indiscreet one considering the Cook's earlier embarrassment in the prologue. Chaucer layers the meta-textual humor carefully—the storyteller advocating silence cannot help but keep talking. The repetition of the mother’s proverbs (“My sone, thenk on the crowe”) approaches absurdity, signaling Chaucer's distance from the moral being presented. The transformation of the crow from white to black serves as a motif for how knowledge corrupts innocence—or, more precisely, how the reckless sharing of knowledge does. Positioned late in the sequence, the tale's exhausted, self-cancelling wisdom feels like a fitting penultimate note before the Parson's serious prose concludes the journey.
Key quotes from Chapter 19
“Keepeth wel thy tonge, and thenk upon the crowe.”
The Manciple closes the tale by repeating his mother's central maxim, reducing the entire mythological narrative to this single, blunt imperative.
“I saugh hym doon al his lecherye / Right under thyn owene nose, openly.”
The crow delivers its damning report to Phoebus in brutally direct terms, the very plainness of the speech making it both irrefutable and catastrophic.
“The flour of bachilrie, / As wel in fredom as in chivalrie.”
Chaucer introduces Phoebus with extravagant courtly praise, establishing an idealized image that the tale will systematically dismantle through jealousy and violence.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit a message.
Create an accountSign in