Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · wealthy widow, mother of Lise

Madame Hohlakov

in The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky

Madame Hohlakov is a wealthy widow around thirty-three years old, noted for being "still young and attractive" and always dressed with style. She owns estates in several provinces and a house in town, making her one of the most notable social figures in the story’s provincial backdrop. Her first appearance is at the hermitage, where she seeks Father Zossima's blessing for her daughter Lise, who is partially paralyzed. After this, she becomes a comic yet important character, with her impulsive generosity and rapid speech often intersecting with the plot's crises. Her most significant moment occurs when Dmitri, in desperate need of three thousand roubles, visits her. She tempts him with promises of "infinitely more," changes the topic to gold mines in Siberia, and ultimately gives him just a small silver icon—an act of unintentional cruelty that contributes to his downfall. She also sends Rakitin to the hermitage to report on happenings after Father Zossima's death, writes enthusiastic letters about miracles, and provides the written statement that Perhotin uses to confirm she gave Dmitri no money. Though she is not malicious, her character is marked by nervous excitement, social vanity, an inability to stick to one topic, and a tendency to be swayed by flattery from young men. She is absent from Dmitri's trial due to illness.

About this character

Role
wealthy widow, mother of Lise
Form
Novel
Author
Fyodor Dostoevsky
First published
1880

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Madame Hohlakov?

Madame Hohlakov is introduced in Book II as a wealthy widow around thirty-three, "still young and attractive, and always dressed with taste," with "lively black eyes." She owns properties in various provinces and clearly belongs to the town's social elite. Her defining traits include nervous energy, compulsive talkativeness, vanity about her appearance and youth, and a chaotic but genuine benevolence. While she is never villainous, her distractibility and inability to follow through can lead to unintentional harm.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Madame Hohlakov's arc and motivation?

Madame Hohlakov doesn't have a single dramatic arc; instead, she serves as a recurring character whose actions affect those around her. Initially, her motivation is maternal—she brings Lise to Father Zossima, hoping for a miraculous cure. As the story unfolds, she becomes more entangled in the town's social dramas: she sends Rakitin as a spy to the hermitage, writes excited letters about miracles, and hosts a stream of visitors (Alyosha, Dmitri, Perhotin), each with pressing concerns. Her vanity regarding young men—first Perhotin, then her suspicion that Rakitin has developed feelings for her—hints at a woman who fills the emptiness of widowhood with social activity. By Book XI, she is unwell, reclining on a couch "in a fascinating but decorous déshabillé," yet still dresses smartly and talks nonstop.

03·Key moments

What are Madame Hohlakov's key moments?

  • Book II: She and Lise wait outside the hermitage for Father Zossima, establishing her as a woman of faith who occupies a somewhat privileged, slightly separate space from ordinary pilgrims.
  • Book IV (At The Hohlakovs'): She welcomes Alyosha with breathless excitement about the miracle letter, reacts dramatically to his wounded finger, and is portrayed as a woman of genuine emotion but poor self-control.
  • Book VIII: Dmitri arrives hoping to borrow three thousand roubles. Madame Hohlakov greets him warmly, raises his expectations to "three million," delivers an elaborate speech about gold-mines in Siberia, hangs a small silver icon round his neck, and only then reveals she has no money. This scene is both comedic and tragic: her impulsive grandiosity directly contributes to Dmitri's desperation that night.
  • Book IX: Perhotin visits her late at night to confirm whether she gave Dmitri money. She admits she did not, writes a statement to that effect, and is charmed by Perhotin's demeanor—then falls into a "sound, sweet sleep" almost immediately after learning a murder may have occurred, illustrating her shallow emotional resilience.
  • Book XI (The Injured Foot): Alyosha visits, and she delivers a lengthy, digressive monologue about Rakitin, Perhotin, her swollen foot, and a newspaper paragraph she claims describes her—revealing her self-absorption and awareness of public gossip surrounding her involvement in Dmitri's night of crime.
  • Epilogue: She is among those who petitioned for Mitya to be housed separately in the hospital, showing that beneath the comedy, she retains genuine compassion.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Madame Hohlakov's most important relationships?

With Alyosha, Madame Hohlakov is at her most sympathetic: she trusts him completely with Lise, confides in him as if he were a confessor, and genuinely values his perspective. With Dmitri, she is at her most damaging: her dislike of him (stemming from her wish that Katerina Ivanovna would choose Ivan instead) doesn't stop her from raising his hopes, but her inability to give a clear "no" — or a clear "yes" — leaves him worse off than a direct refusal would have. With Rakitin, she uses him: sending him to the hermitage as an informant, and he later writes a mocking newspaper piece about her "middle-aged charms." With Perhotin, she feels flattered and charmed, and his visits seem to provide her with a new social focus during her illness.

05·Connected characters

How is Madame Hohlakov connected to the other characters?

Lise

Madame Hohlakov is Lise's mother, devoted to her daughter's recovery yet often oblivious to Lise's inner life; she relays Lise's feelings about Alyosha with fond but self-absorbed commentary.

Alexey Fyodorovitch Karamazov

Alyosha is a trusted and frequent visitor whom Madame Hohlakov treats with warm, if overwhelming, affection, confiding in him about Lise, Rakitin, and Perhotin, and acting as an intermediary between him and Katerina Ivanovna.

Dmitri Fyodorovitch Karamazov

Madame Hohlakov detests Dmitri and had long wished him to break with Katerina Ivanovna; when he comes to her in desperation for three thousand roubles, she raises his hopes extravagantly before revealing she has no money to give him, sending him away with only a religious icon.

Father Zossima

She brings Lise to Father Zossima seeking a healing, and on the day he lies dying she writes enthusiastically to Alyosha reporting a miracle of his prediction, urging that all the brotherhood be told of it.

Katerina Ivanovna

Katerina Ivanovna stays at Madame Hohlakov's house during a crisis, and Madame Hohlakov nurses her through hysterics and fever, acting as a concerned hostess.

Rakitin

Madame Hohlakov employs Rakitin as an informal informant at the hermitage after Father Zossima's death, and he appears to have cultivated her company, though she later suspects he fell in love with her and eventually distances herself from him.

Pyotr Alexandrovitch Miüsov

Both are named among the four witnesses missing from Dmitri's trial in Book XII, Madame Hohlakov through illness.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Madame Hohlakov

Why does Madame Hohlakov refuse to lend Dmitri the three thousand roubles?

She first leads him to think she will give him "infinitely more than three thousand," but she then says she has no money and adds that even if she had, she would not lend it to him. She's so focused on her plan to send him to the gold mines in Siberia that she never really addresses his actual request. When he finally asks her directly, she responds with "serene amazement" that she doesn't have three thousand roubles. Instead, she gives him a small silver icon.

What is Madame Hohlakov's relationship to Lise?

She is Lise's mother. She brings Lise, who has been partially paralyzed for six months, to Father Zossima in hopes of finding a cure. While she is devoted, she often gets lost in her own thoughts, sharing Lise's feelings about Alyosha with a mix of affection and long-winded stories, and Lise is frequently described as laughing at her mother.

Why does she send Rakitin to the hermitage after Father Zossima's death?

Unable to enter the hermitage herself, she sends Rakitin to keep an eye on things and update her by letter "every half-hour or so" about what's happening. The narrator calls her "weak-minded" in this situation and points out that Rakitin had a talent for playing whatever role benefited him the most.

What role does she play in the investigation after the murder?

Perhotin visits her late at night to check if she gave Dmitri any money. She assures him that she didn’t give him anything, writes a signed statement to confirm this, and finds Perhotin's demeanor appealing. Her written denial becomes evidence that Dmitri had no legitimate source for the money on him.

How does the newspaper portray her, and how does she react?

A paragraph in the paper Gossip refers to a "pining widow" who, without being named, offered a criminal three thousand roubles to run away with her to the gold-mines. Madame Hohlakov claims this is about her and is upset by the term "middle-aged charms," blaming Rakitin for it and saying she forgives him.

Is she present at Dmitri's trial?

No. She is among the witnesses listed as absent due to illness, along with Maximov, while Miüsov is in Paris and Smerdyakov is absent because he has passed away.

What does her treatment of Perhotin reveal about her character?

She is soon captivated by his youth, good looks, and courteous demeanor, dubbing him a future diplomat and intending to advocate for his advancement. The narrator remarks that after he departed following his late-night visit — just as she learned about a potential murder — she drifted into "a sound, sweet sleep," implying that social vanity and the joy of receiving compliments can overshadow even significant worries.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Comic relief and structural function: Examine how Madame Hohlakov's scenes provide tonal relief while also advancing the plot—her refusal to lend money to Dmitri is both farcical and catastrophic.

  • The failure of good intentions: Madame Hohlakov never acts maliciously, yet her actions (raising Dmitri's hopes, sending Rakitin, falling asleep after hearing about a possible murder) consistently worsen situations; what does this suggest about Dostoevsky's perspective on well-meaning but self-absorbed charity?

  • Vanity and faith: She seeks Father Zossima's blessing and reports miracles with genuine enthusiasm, yet is equally focused on her appearance, admirers, and public image; how does Dostoevsky balance sincere faith with social vanity in her character?

  • Women and money: Madame Hohlakov is one of the few financially independent women in the novel, yet her wealth ultimately helps no one; explore what the gold-mines episode reveals about the disconnect between wealth and effective action.

  • The newspaper paragraph: The *Gossip* article reduces her to "middle-aged charms" and a comedic subplot; discuss how public narratives distort individual characters in the novel, using Madame Hohlakov as a case study.

The Brothers Karamazov

Continue

Full study guide →