Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · undersheriff's wife who befriends Perry in jail

Mrs. Meier

in In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

Josephine ("Josie") Meier is the wife of Wendle Meier, the undersheriff of Finney County, Kansas. Because the Sheriff's Residence adjoins the jail, she becomes an unlikely but central figure in Perry Smith's months of pre-trial confinement. Capote describes her as a "direct and practical woman who nevertheless seems illuminated by a mystical serenity" — tall, calm, and kindly-faced, rising at five in the morning to read the Bible and spending her days cooking, sewing, darning, and doing laundry for the prisoners. After the death verdict is returned, she hides in her kitchen to avoid facing Perry, but when she hears him weeping she goes to his cell door, takes his hand, and holds it as he says, "I'm embraced by shame." That final image — the condemned man reaching through the bars for the undersheriff's wife — is one of the book's most quietly devastating moments, and it is Mrs. Meier who witnesses and preserves it.

About this character

Role
undersheriff's wife who befriends Perry in jail
Form
Non-fiction
Author
Truman Capote
First published
1966

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Mrs. Meier?

Josephine ("Josie") Meier is the undersheriff's wife and de facto caretaker of the prisoners held in the Sheriff's Residence in Garden City, Kansas. Capote introduces her with unusual care, describing her daily routine — Bible reading at five in the morning, cooking and sewing for inmates, tending her apartment with its gemütlich melange of plump hassocks and squashy chairs and cream-colored lace window curtains — and characterising her as "a direct and practical woman who nevertheless seems illuminated by a mystical serenity." She is not a law-enforcement figure but a domestic one whose kitchen window overlooks the very square where Perry and Dick are brought in, and whose kitchen wall adjoins the cell where Perry will spend months awaiting trial.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Mrs. Meier's arc and motivation?

Mrs. Meier begins as a background figure — a capable, religious woman who manages an unusual household — and gradually becomes one of Perry's few genuine human connections. Her motivation appears to be a combination of practical Christian charity (she and her husband are described as eager to assist in "the salvation of a soul") and simple human sympathy. She tries to arrange a meeting with Father Goubeaux for Perry and is rebuffed, but she does not withdraw; instead she continues to feed him, compliment him, and talk with him through the daily rhythms of jail life. By the trial's end her arc closes on an act of pure compassion: hearing Perry cry after the verdict, she goes to his cell and holds his hand.

03·Key moments

What are Mrs. Meier's key moments?

  • Part IV (introduction): Capote establishes her character and domestic world, quoting her directly on the ladies' cell and on the crowd that gathered when Perry and Dick arrived.
  • Part IV (the cats): She explains to Perry why the stray cats circle the parked cars on Courthouse Square, hunting birds caught in engine grilles — a small exchange that nonetheless deepens his melancholy self-reflection.
  • Part IV (Sunday dinner): During the trial's weekend recess, she and Wendle arrange for Don Cullivan to dine with Perry in his cell; she donates a linen tablecloth, starched napkins, and her best china and silver, and cooks the entire feast. Perry tells Cullivan, "She's really a terrific cook, Mrs. Meier. You ought to taste her Spanish rice. I've gained fifteen pounds since I got here."
  • Part IV (after the verdict): She shuts herself in the kitchen to avoid seeing Perry after the death sentence, watches the crowd leave through her window, then hears him "crying like a child." She goes to the cell door; he reaches out his hand; she holds it as he says, "I'm embraced by shame."

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Mrs. Meier's most important relationships?

Perry Smith: The relationship is the emotional heart of Mrs. Meier's role in the book. Proximity — his cell beside her kitchen — creates an intimacy neither sought. She feeds him well, praises him, tries (and fails) to bring him religious counsel, and ultimately offers him physical comfort at his lowest moment.

Dick Hickock: She distinguishes sharply between the two men: "I never had much truck with Dick, but Perry and I got to know each other real well." Dick's cell is in the main jail, away from her domestic space, and no comparable bond forms.

05·Connected characters

How is Mrs. Meier connected to the other characters?

Perry Smith

Perry is housed in the ladies' cell beside her kitchen, and over months of confinement a genuine bond develops; she feeds him, encourages him, and ultimately holds his hand through the cell door after he hears his death sentence.

Dick Hickock

She notes that she "never had much truck with Dick," in contrast to the closeness she feels with Perry.

Lowell Lee Andrews

Mrs. Meier notes that, as far as she knows, Perry was the first man ever kept in the ladies' cell, implying her experience of male prisoners in that space was unusual.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Mrs. Meier

What is Mrs. Meier's first name and how does Capote describe her?

Her full name is Josephine, and she goes by "Josie." Capote describes her as "a direct and practical woman who nevertheless seems illuminated by a mystical serenity," tall and calm, with a square and kindly face.

Why is Perry Smith kept in the ladies' cell next to her kitchen?

Mrs. Meier explains that the sheriff wanted to keep Perry and Dick separated from each other until after their trial, and the ladies' cell — an isolated unit inside the Sheriff's Residence adjoining her kitchen — was the available option. She notes Perry was "the first man ever stayed in the ladies' cell."

What kind of relationship does she develop with Perry?

A genuine bond of mutual regard. She lends him magazines, compliments his neatly made bunk, explains small mysteries of life on Courthouse Square, and cooks elaborate meals for him. Perry tells his friend Don Cullivan that she is "a terrific cook" and credits her with the Sunday dinner spread. After the death verdict she holds his hand through the cell door as he weeps.

How does she react when Perry is sentenced to death?

She shuts herself in the kitchen to avoid seeing him when he is brought back after the verdict, and watches the crowd leave through her window. When she hears him crying — something he had never done before — she goes to his cell door, takes his hand, and holds it as he says, "I'm embraced by shame."

Does she try to give Perry any religious guidance?

Yes. Capote notes that she and her husband were eager to assist in "the salvation" of Perry's soul, and she suggested a consultation with Father Goubeaux, a local priest. Perry refused, saying, "Priests and nuns have had their chance with me. I'm still wearing the scars to prove it."

What does she say about the Clutter family?

She tells us she never met any of the Clutters personally, but says "from everything I've ever heard about them they must have been very fine people" and that "what happened to them is hard to forgive."

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Domesticity as moral witness: Mrs. Meier's kitchen

    its window overlooking the square, its wall adjoining the cell — positions the domestic sphere as a site of moral observation and human connection that official legal spaces cannot provide.

  • Compassion without absolution: She holds Perry's hand and promises Spanish rice after the verdict, yet she never excuses the crime; explore how Capote uses her to embody sympathy that coexists with clear-eyed acknowledgment of guilt.

  • Religion and its limits: She reads the Bible daily, is described as possessing "mystical serenity," and tries to arrange priestly counsel for Perry

    yet Perry's rejection of Father Goubeaux does not end her care for him; consider what this suggests about the novel's treatment of institutional versus personal faith.

  • Gender and the carceral space: As a woman managing a household that literally contains a jail cell, Mrs. Meier occupies an anomalous position; her presence humanises a space designed for punishment and control.

In Cold Blood

Continue

Full study guide →