Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · Nancy's boyfriend

Bobby Rupp

in In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

Bobby Rupp is Nancy Clutter's devoted boyfriend and the last known person to see the Clutter family alive. A seventeen-year-old basketball star from a Catholic farming family in Holcomb, Kansas, he had dated Nancy exclusively since eighth grade — an unusually steady attachment that her father, Herb Clutter, was quietly working to end on religious grounds. On the night of the murders, Bobby spent an ordinary evening watching television at the Clutter house and left at about half past ten, though Nancy's diary records that he left at eleven. In the immediate aftermath he becomes the investigators' principal suspect, a status that compounds his grief before a polygraph test clears him entirely.

Bobby's response to the murders is one of the book's most affecting portraits of private loss. He stands for an hour on the Rupp farm staring at River Valley Farm, walks miles to the barricade, insists on viewing Nancy's body, and spends weeks driving aimlessly with Susan Kidwell. On Christmas Day he goes for a run and finds himself, without having meant to, at River Valley Farm, where he comes across Nancy's horse Babe and rubs his cheek along her neck — something Nancy used to do. Capote renders him as a compact, homely-handsome, open-faced boy whose world has been permanently altered. By the book's final pages, Susan Kidwell reports that Bobby has married a woman named Colleen Whitehurst — a quiet signal that life, however changed, has continued.

About this character

Role
Nancy's boyfriend
Form
Non-fiction
Author
Truman Capote
First published
1966

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Bobby Rupp?

Bobby Rupp is a seventeen-year-old farm boy and school basketball star — "compact but slender, a finely made boy with an open, homely-handsome face" — who has grown up alongside Nancy Clutter in Holcomb, Kansas. He is described as dependable and gentlemanly, and his relationship with Nancy is the defining feature of his young life: she is, as he says himself, "the only girl I ever dated."

02·Arc & motivation

What is Bobby Rupp's arc and motivation?

Bobby begins the novel as a background presence — the boyfriend whose signet ring Nancy wears on her thumb, whose shooting-gallery Teddy bear sits on her bed, whose photographs cover her bulletin board. The murders transform him from a peripheral figure into a study in grief and suspected guilt. His arc moves from shock and public suspicion, through a period of raw mourning shared with Susan Kidwell, to a slow, painful re-entry into ordinary life. By Part IV, years later, he has married — a fact reported almost in passing at the Clutter graves, marking his passage out of the novel's world of loss.

03·Key moments

What are Bobby Rupp's key moments?

  • Part I: Bobby's last visit is reconstructed in his own words during a pre-polygraph interview. He describes calling Nancy, being told they couldn't go out because of the previous night's lateness, and coming over to watch television — "just an ordinary evening." Nancy's diary confirms: "Bobby here and we watched TV. Left at eleven."
  • Part I: The hired man Stoecklein, recalling the night of the murders, tells investigators he heard a car drive away around ten-thirty or quarter to eleven and remarked to his wife, "There goes Bob Rupp" — placing Bobby as the last person to leave the property.
  • Part I: On learning of the murders Bobby stands motionless on the Rupp farm's exposed plateau staring at River Valley Farm for nearly an hour, then walks miles toward the barricade, refusing to answer his brother Larry or ride in the car.
  • Part II: The polygraph test eliminates Bobby as a suspect.
  • Part III (Christmas Day): Running across the fields, Bobby finds himself in the Clutter orchard without intending to, wanders to the house, and then discovers Nancy's horse Babe in a livestock corral. He clutches her mane and rubs his cheek along her neck — "something Nancy used to do" — and Babe whinnies.
  • Part IV: At the Clutter graves, Susan tells Dewey that Bobby has married Colleen Whitehurst, described as "really beautiful. And very nice, too."

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Bobby Rupp's most important relationships?

Bobby's relationship with Nancy Clutter is rendered largely through objects and memory — her diary entries, the photographs on her bulletin board, the signet ring, the Teddy bear he won at the county fair — rather than through scenes the reader witnesses directly. His testimony about their last evening together is notable for its very ordinariness. His bond with Susan Kidwell is forged entirely by shared loss; before the murders he had never felt comfortable with her and was even jealous of her closeness to Nancy. His dealings with Herb Clutter carry an irony the novel quietly underlines: the father who was engineering a "gradual breaking off" is murdered on the very night Bobby makes what turns out to be his final visit. Bobby's encounters with Alvin Dewey and the investigative machinery are experienced as additional trauma layered on top of grief.

05·Connected characters

How is Bobby Rupp connected to the other characters?

Nancy Clutter

Bobby was Nancy's only boyfriend from eighth grade onward; their relationship was the central emotional fact of his adolescence, and her death leaves him in a grief he describes as a circle he cannot escape from and others cannot enter.

Herb Clutter

Mr. Clutter liked and respected Bobby but was pressing Nancy to break off the relationship because the Rupps were Catholic and the Clutters Methodist, making marriage in his view impossible.

Susan Kidwell

After the murders Bobby and Susan became near-constant companions, driving aimlessly and mourning together; the friendship gradually waned as they found they were forcing each other to remember what both wanted to forget.

Alvin Dewey

Dewey supervised Bobby's interrogations and polygraph test, and while he personally doubted Bobby's guilt, he could not immediately dismiss him as a suspect because Bobby was the only person to whom even a feeble motive could be attributed.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Bobby Rupp

Why was Bobby Rupp considered a suspect?

Bobby was the last known person to see the Clutter family alive, and investigators noted that a motive — however feeble — could be attributed to him: Herb Clutter had been pressing Nancy to end their relationship. Dewey personally doubted Bobby's guilt, but the police were not ready to dismiss him until a polygraph test cleared him entirely.

What was Bobby doing on the night of the murders?

He came over to the Clutter house to watch television after Nancy's father refused to let them go out, because they had stayed out late the night before. Nancy's diary records the visit in her final entry: "Bobby here and we watched TV. Left at eleven."

How did Bobby react when he heard about the murders?

He listened to the news without asking questions, then stood outside on the Rupp farm's plateau staring at River Valley Farm for nearly an hour. He then walked miles toward the Clutter property, refusing his brother Larry's company or offer of a car, until he reached the state troopers' barricade.

What was Bobby's relationship with Susan Kidwell after the murders?

The two became near-constant companions, driving aimlessly, sitting at drive-ins, and occasionally visiting the Clutter house from a distance. The friendship gradually waned after about a month because, as Capote writes, they were forcing each other to mourn and remember what both wanted to forget.

Why did Herb Clutter want Nancy to stop seeing Bobby?

The Rupp family were Roman Catholics and the Clutters Methodist, a difference Mr. Clutter believed made any future marriage impossible. He had already surprised the two kissing and had secured from Nancy a promise to begin a gradual breaking off.

What happens to Bobby by the end of the book?

Years after the murders, Susan Kidwell tells Alvin Dewey at the Clutter graves that Bobby has married a woman named Colleen Whitehurst, whom she describes as "really beautiful. And very nice, too."

What is the significance of the Christmas Day scene involving Bobby?

Running mindlessly on Christmas Day, Bobby finds himself in the Clutter orchard without having meant to come there, then passes a storage barn and a livestock corral before discovering Nancy's horse Babe. He clutches her mane and rubs his cheek along her neck — something Nancy used to do — and Babe whinnies. The scene externalizes a grief Bobby cannot articulate and connects him to Nancy through the landscape and animals she loved.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Bobby functions as a register of communal loss: his private grief mirrors the shock felt across Holcomb, and his gradual recovery parallels the community's slow return to ordinary life.

  • The religious difference between the Rupp and Clutter families

    the stated reason Herb Clutter wanted the relationship ended — takes on a bitter irony when murder, not faith, becomes the force that separates the couple.

  • Bobby's status as principal suspect illustrates how the investigation's desperation could victimize the innocent; his eventual clearance by polygraph raises questions about the reliability of such methods and the cost of suspicion.

  • Bobby's marriage, reported briefly in the novel's closing pages, participates in Capote's elegiac structure: life continues, but the final image of Susan at the graves, described as "just such a young woman as Nancy might have been," keeps the loss permanently present.

In Cold Blood

Continue

Full study guide →