Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · fellow Death Row inmate who is executed

Lowell Lee Andrews

in In Cold Blood by Truman Capote

Lowell Lee Andrews is the fifth condemned man on Death Row at Lansing, Kansas, and one of the most vividly drawn figures in the world Perry Smith and Dick Hickock inhabit while awaiting execution. An eighteen-year-old honor student at the University of Kansas when he murdered his parents and sister on the evening of November 28, 1958, during Thanksgiving week, Andrews presents a stark double portrait: outwardly he was regarded as "the nicest boy in Wolcott," a shy, overweight biology major; inwardly he harbored what psychiatrists at the Menninger Clinic diagnosed as "schizophrenia, simple type" — meaning he suffered no delusions or hallucinations, but a primary illness of separation of thinking from feeling. He shot his father seventeen times, his mother six times, and his sister once, then calmly fed the family dog and telephoned the sheriff to report a robbery. His defense team mounted a landmark legal challenge to the M'Naghten Rule, but the Reverend Dameron's testimony for the prosecution undid them, and Andrews was sentenced to hang. On Death Row he reads voraciously — fifteen to twenty books a week — and speaks with a college-trained precision that irritates Perry Smith, who resents being corrected by someone he dismisses as "just a kid." Andrews is executed on November 30, 1962, handing Hickock a stanza of Gray's "Elegy" as a farewell.

About this character

Role
fellow Death Row inmate who is executed
Form
Non-fiction
Author
Truman Capote
First published
1966

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Lowell Lee Andrews?

Lowell Lee Andrews is introduced as a Death Row celebrity — the guard presenting him to a visitor in 1960 says, "I'm sure you recognize the famous Mr. Lowell Lee Andrews." He is enormous, weak-eyed, horn-rimmed, nearly three hundred pounds, and carries the ironic local reputation of being "the nicest boy in Wolcott." The Menninger Clinic's diagnosis — "schizophrenia, simple type," meaning no delusions but a total separation of thinking from feeling — frames him as someone who "considered himself the only important, only significant person in the world" and found it "just as right to kill his mother as to kill an animal or a fly."

02·Arc & motivation

What is Lowell Lee Andrews's arc and motivation?

Andrews' arc moves from secret fantasy to methodical murder to a failed legal crusade to a composed death. His stated motivation for killing his family was inheritance of his father's land, but the deeper drive was a fantasy of becoming "an ice-hearted master criminal" — silk shirts, scarlet sports cars, a gangster identity utterly unlike the bookish, virginal student the world saw. On Death Row that fantasy persists in his talk of escaping and hiring himself out as a gunman with "a machine gun inside a violin case." He shows no remorse, saying according to statements credited to him that he didn't feel anything about it and that the time came and he was doing what he had to do.

03·Key moments

What are Lowell Lee Andrews's key moments?

In Part IV, the murders of November 28, during Thanksgiving week, are narrated in clinical detail: Andrews finishes The Brothers Karamazov, changes into his best suit, loads two weapons, and shoots each family member with methodical thoroughness — his father absorbs seventeen bullets. Afterward he feeds the dog, stages a burglary, drives forty miles to construct an alibi, and calls the sheriff. His nonchalance at the scene — "I don't care what you do with them" — shocks even the coroner.

Also in Part IV, the Reverend Dameron's courtroom testimony destroys the defense's insanity strategy. The judge upholds M'Naghten, and Andrews is condemned.

Hickock's rejoinder — "The trouble with you, Andy, you've got no respect for human life. Including your own" — Andrews simply agrees with.

His execution on November 30, 1962 (Part IV) is witnessed from their cell windows by Perry, Dick, York, and Latham. He hands Hickock the ninth stanza of Gray's "Elegy" as a farewell before he is led to the gallows.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Lowell Lee Andrews's most important relationships?

Andrews and Perry Smith occupy adjacent imaginative space but are temperamentally at war. Perry, who considers himself self-educated and learned, cannot bear being corrected by "just a kid," and Andrews' formal intelligence is described as "anathema" to him. Perry's hunger strike begins partly in the wake of these humiliations. Andrews, for his part, is described as "without malice" — he means well, which makes the dynamic more painful for Perry.

Andrews and Dick Hickock share a warmer bond. It is Dick who preserves and transmits the farewell poem, and Dick who corrects Andrews' arithmetic about the killers on the Row — a small comic reversal of the usual dynamic.

05·Connected characters

How is Lowell Lee Andrews connected to the other characters?

Perry Smith

Andrews shares Death Row with Perry; Perry resents Andrews' educated corrections of his grammar and sulks bitterly after each humiliation, though he never openly admits his antagonism.

Dick Hickock

Dick becomes genuinely friendly with Andrews, trading dark jokes and quoting his 'funny thinking' with affection; it is Hickock who preserves and shares Andrews' farewell poem.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Lowell Lee Andrews

What crime did Lowell Lee Andrews commit?

On the evening of November 28, 1958, Andrews shot and killed his sister Jennie Marie, his mother, and his father at the family home in Wolcott, Kansas. His father was shot seventeen times in total. He then staged the scene to look like a robbery and drove to Lawrence to construct an alibi before calling the sheriff.

Why did he kill his family?

The ostensible motive was to inherit his father's land, valued at approximately two hundred thousand dollars. But the deeper drive, as the narrative presents it, was a fantasy of reinventing himself as a gangster and master criminal — an identity wholly at odds with the shy, overweight biology student the world knew.

What was the psychiatric diagnosis, and did it save him?

The Menninger Clinic diagnosed Andrews with "schizophrenia, simple type" — no delusions or hallucinations, but a complete separation of thinking from feeling. His defense team hoped to use the case to replace the M'Naghten Rule with the more lenient Durham Rule, but the Reverend Dameron's testimony for the prosecution, combined with Andrews' own confession, led the judge to uphold M'Naghten and the jury to impose the death penalty.

How did the Reverend Dameron affect the outcome?

Dameron, the Andrews family's minister, was brought to the jail in the early hours after the murders and privately persuaded Andrews to confess to the detectives. He then appeared at trial as the chief prosecution witness, delivering testimony in a revivalist style that helped secure the death sentence and undermined the insanity defense.

What was Andrews like on Death Row?

He read voraciously — fifteen to twenty books a week, ranging from trash to poetry by Robert Frost, Whitman, Emily Dickinson, and Ogden Nash — and spoke with a college-trained precision. He was described as a compulsive eater who kept a scrapbook of illustrated food, and he entertained fantasies of escaping and working as a hired gunman.

Why did Perry Smith dislike Andrews?

Perry, who prided himself on being self-educated, resented Andrews constantly correcting his grammar and word usage — for example, distinguishing "disinterested" from "uninterested." Andrews meant no malice, but Perry found the corrections humiliating and responded by sulking and, eventually, refusing to speak to anyone.

What was Andrews' farewell before his execution?

He handed Dick Hickock a piece of paper bearing the ninth stanza of Gray's "Elegy Written in a Country Churchyard," ending with the line "The paths of glory lead but to the grave." He also joked with Hickock about the afterlife, said he believed in "dust unto dust," and noted with dark amusement that his family planned to bury him alongside the three people he had killed.

When was Andrews executed, and how did he face it?

Andrews was hanged on Friday, November 30, 1962. The Clutter killers, Smith and Hickock, had been granted a reprieve by a Federal judge and evaded their scheduled execution date, which had been set for October 25, 1962 — one month before Andrews kept his. Hickock, watching from his cell window with Perry, York and Latham, later described the chaplain taking off Andrews' glasses before he was led inside to the gallows.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • The double self as a structural motif

    Andrews' split between the "sweet-natured" public student and the "ice-hearted master criminal" within mirrors the novel's broader interest in hidden violence beneath respectable surfaces — compare the Clutter household's apparent tranquility.

  • The M'Naghten Rule and the limits of legal categories

    Andrews' case is presented as the ideal test of the insanity defense, yet the defense fails; his story raises the question of whether the law can ever adequately address the kind of emotionless violence Capote documents.

  • Composure in the face of death

    Andrews' calm at the gallows, his farewell poem, and his earlier remark about walking out or being "carried out in a coffin" invite analysis of how the novel treats stoicism and what it means — heroism, pathology, or both.

  • The role of religion

    The Reverend Dameron extracts Andrews' confession and then testifies against him; his intervention is the pivot on which Andrews' fate turns, raising questions about the relationship between spiritual counsel and state power.

  • Andrews as foil to Perry and Dick

    Where Perry goes on a hunger strike and Dick schemes through legal letters, Andrews reads poetry and accepts his fate with detachment; comparing the three men's responses to Death Row illuminates Capote's characterisation of guilt, feeling, and the absence of feeling.

In Cold Blood

Continue

Full study guide →