Skip to content
Storgy

Hard TimesNovel by Charles Dickens

Chapter 36: PHILOSOPHICAL

36 of 37 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Chapter 36 of Hard Times?

Back inside the circus booth, Bitzer keeps Tom captive and calmly lays out his reasons to Mr. Gradgrind: he has gathered evidence of Tom's bank robbery, overheard Tom's confession, and followed Gradgrind to the circus. His plan is to return Tom to Coketown so Mr. Bounderby will promote him to Tom's old job. Gradgrind attempts three appeals — compassion, money, and gratitude for his education — but Bitzer turns down each one, insisting that self-interest is the only logical principle and that his schooling was a paid deal that has now ended. Sleary, having listened to all this, declares he can't help Tom escape from a known bank robbery and will only take Tom and Bitzer to the railway. Louisa and Gradgrind feel hopeless, but Sissy spots a secret signal from Sleary, who discreetly reveals his true plan: his dancing horse will delay Bitzer's carriage, a fast pony-gig driven by Childers will pick up Tom, and his trained dog will prevent Bitzer from escaping on foot. The plan unfolds flawlessly. By morning, Sleary reports that Tom is probably already on a ship, Bitzer was held back by the dog, and Childers took Tom away an hour and a half after they departed. Gradgrind offers money; Sleary only asks for small gifts for Childers, the dog, the horse, and a future booking for the circus. Sleary then privately tells Gradgrind that Merrylegs, Sissy's father's dog, returned to the circus fourteen months ago in Chester — lame and nearly blind — performed his old trick, and died, leading Sleary to believe Sissy's father was already gone. He and his colleagues decided not to inform Sissy, uncertain whether her father had abandoned her or died of a broken heart. Sleary ends with a farewell to Sissy and a parting philosophical thought: the dog's loyalty shows there is love in the world that isn't purely self-interested, and this love has a way of calculating — or not calculating — that can't quite be named.

Analysis

The chapter unfolds like a living philosophical debate: Bitzer, the ideal product of Gradgrind's Utilitarian teachings, manages to out-argue his own creator. The irony is striking—every argument Gradgrind presents (whether it's compassion, bribery, or gratitude) gets turned back on him, employing the very principles he taught. The narrator emphasizes this irony with a sarcastic comment: "It was a fundamental principle of the Gradgrind philosophy that everything was to be paid for… Every inch of the existence of mankind, from birth to death, was to be a bargain across a counter." The cold, commercial language ("cheapest market," "dearest," "compound a felony," "calculations") is entirely Bitzer's, illustrating how deeply the philosophy has influenced his way of speaking.

In contrast to this mechanical reasoning, Sleary's lisping, meandering voice presents the chapter's counter-argument. His plan to save Tom involves animals—the dancing horse, the pony, the trained dog—creatures that operate beyond mere rational calculation. The dog episode at Chester reinforces this theme: Merrylegs, nearly blind and lame, travels a great distance, performs one last trick, and dies, showcasing a loyalty that self-interest can't explain. Sleary's final speech directly addresses the theme, contrasting "Thelf-interetht" with "thomething very different," acknowledging that this other force is as difficult to define as the ways of dogs.

The tone of the chapter transitions from a tense confrontation to a somber elegy. Gradgrind's only reaction to Sleary's closing thoughts is to gaze out the window in silence—a gesture that reveals his inability to respond within his own framework. Sleary's self-deprecating exit line ("I wath tho muth of a Cackler!") lightens the atmosphere without diminishing the moral weight of his preceding words.

Key quotes from Chapter 36

  • “‘It is accessible to Reason, sir,’ returned the excellent young man. ‘And to nothing else.’”

    Bitzer's reply when Gradgrind asks whether his heart is open to any compassionate influence.

  • “I was brought up in that catechism when I was very young, sir, as you are aware.”

    Bitzer reminds Gradgrind that the doctrine of self-interest as the only social bond was taught to him at Gradgrind's own school.

  • “one, that there ith a love in the world, not all Thelf-interetht after all, but thomething very different”

    Sleary's closing philosophical reflection to Gradgrind, drawn from the story of Merrylegs's return and death.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01Why does Bitzer say he wants to return Tom to Coketown?
  2. 02How does Bitzer respond when Gradgrind appeals to gratitude for the schooling he received?
  3. 03What role does Sleary's trained dog play in the escape plan?
  4. 04What does the return and death of Merrylegs tell Sleary about Sissy's father?
  5. 05What does Sleary ask from Mr. Gradgrind as payment for his help?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in

Vocabulary in Chapter 36

2 words from this chapter, defined in the sense Hard Times uses.

unactheptable
A misspelling that represents a lisping pronunciation of 'unacceptable.' It shows the character's speech impediment in the dialogue.
athtonithing
A misspelling representing a lisping pronunciation of 'astonishing.' It conveys the circus owner Sleary's speech impediment throughout his dialogue.

All vocabulary in Hard Times →