Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · the pawnbroker's sister, also murdered by Raskolnikov

Lizaveta

in Crime and Punishment by Fyodor Dostoevsky

Lizaveta Ivanovna is the younger half-sister of the pawnbroker Alyona Ivanovna and becomes the second, unintended victim of Raskolnikov's double murder. She's described as a woman around thirty-five: tall, clumsy, timid, submissive, and "almost idiotic." Lizaveta works tirelessly for her sister—cooking, washing, sewing, and cleaning—handing over every penny she earns and never daring to take on work without her sister's approval. The old woman mistreats her, keeps her "in complete bondage like a small child," and has even drafted a will that leaves Lizaveta with nothing. Outside their home, she is known as an honest seller of second-hand clothes and goods, always ensuring fair prices. She shares a quiet friendship with Sonia, reading the Gospels together, and the two exchanged keepsakes: Lizaveta gave Sonia her copper cross and Sonia gave her a little ikon.

From Raskolnikov's perspective, her death is purely accidental: he intended to find Alyona alone, and only learns that Lizaveta will be out by overhearing a chance conversation in the Hay Market, which ultimately determines the timing of the crime. She unexpectedly returns during the murder, sees her sister's body, and is killed before she can scream. She doesn't try to defend herself; instead, she extends her empty hand "as though motioning him away." This powerless gesture lingers in Raskolnikov's mind, and her memory—connected to Sonia's gentleness—becomes one of the moral burdens he cannot escape.

About this character

Role
the pawnbroker's sister, also murdered by Raskolnikov
Form
Novel
Author
Fyodor Dostoevsky
First published
1866

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Lizaveta?

Lizaveta embodies pure victimhood and involuntary innocence. Every detail the novel provides—her submissive nature, her honesty, her friendship with Sonia, and their shared reading of Scripture—paints her as someone completely devoid of malice. The student's tavern speech in Part I lists her exploitation almost as a curiosity, yet it also establishes that she is known and trusted beyond her sister’s household. In essence, she is the person Raskolnikov's theory never anticipated.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Lizaveta's arc and motivation?

Lizaveta doesn’t have a traditional character arc; she is acted upon rather than taking action herself. Her role is both structural and moral: her chance absence from the flat triggers Raskolnikov's "experiment," turning it into a fixed plan, and her unexpected return transforms a single premeditated murder into two. Her motivation, where it can be understood, is simple endurance—she obeys her sister, performs her tasks honestly, and finds quiet companionship with Sonia.

03·Key moments

What are Lizaveta's key moments?

  • Part I (the Hay Market): Raskolnikov overhears Lizaveta agreeing to visit a huckster's family the next evening at seven. This accidental knowledge becomes what he later sees as the predestined turning-point of his fate, since it shows him that Alyona will be alone.
  • Part I (the murder scene): Lizaveta returns to the flat with a bundle, sees her sister's body, and stands "white as a sheet." She doesn’t scream, run, or raise her hand to protect herself—she merely extends her empty left hand "as though motioning him away." The axe falls, and she dies instantly.
  • Part III (Raskolnikov's delirium): In a state of feverish half-consciousness, Raskolnikov associates Lizaveta with Sonia—"Poor Lizaveta! Why did she come in?... Lizaveta! Sonia! Poor gentle things, with gentle eyes"—showing that her memory is already intertwined with his guilt and longing for redemption.
  • Part IV (Sonia's room): Raskolnikov discovers that Lizaveta was Sonia's friend and the source of the New Testament Sonia keeps. Sonia wears the copper cross Lizaveta gave her, and places her own cypress cross around Raskolnikov's neck when he decides to confess.
  • Part V (the confession to Sonia): As Raskolnikov gazes at Sonia's terrified face, he sees "the face of Lizaveta"—the same childlike terror, the same outstretched hand. This visual echo merges the two women and makes Lizaveta's death inseparable from his confession.
  • Epilogue: At trial, "the murder of Lizaveta served indeed to confirm" the theory of an abnormal mental state—the court notes that a man who commits two murders and forgets to close the door cannot be acting rationally.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Lizaveta's most important relationships?

Lizaveta's relationship with Alyona Ivanovna is one of total domination: she works without pay, is beaten, and is disinherited. The huckster's wife's comment—"she is not your own sister either—nothing but a step-sister"—emphasizes that even their blood bond is weakened. Her relationship with Sonia serves as the novel's quiet counterpoint to that exploitation: two marginalized women who read Scripture together and trade a cross for an ikon, forming a community of the gentle and the suffering. Her relationship with Raskolnikov is entirely one-sided while she is alive, but after her death, she becomes one of the two faces (alongside Sonia's) through which his conscience expresses itself.

05·Connected characters

How is Lizaveta connected to the other characters?

Alyona Ivanovna

Lizaveta is Alyona Ivanovna's younger half-sister, kept in complete subjection, made to work without pay, beaten, and excluded from the old woman's will.

Raskolnikov

Raskolnikov kills Lizaveta as an unplanned second victim; her memory and the expression on her face at the moment of death haunt him throughout the novel and become bound up with his guilt.

Sonia

Lizaveta and Sonia were quiet friends who read the Gospels together and talked; Lizaveta gave Sonia a copper cross, which Sonia keeps to wear herself when she puts her own cypress cross on Raskolnikov as he goes to confess.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Lizaveta

Who is Lizaveta and what is her relationship to the pawnbroker?

Lizaveta Ivanovna is the younger half-sister of Alyona Ivanovna, the pawnbroker. She lives under Alyona's strict control, forced to work tirelessly without seeing any of her earnings, often beaten, and ultimately left with nothing in the old woman's will.

Why does Raskolnikov kill Lizaveta if she was not part of his plan?

Raskolnikov's plan relied on Lizaveta not being in the flat. However, she unexpectedly comes back while he is still there after killing Alyona, and he ends up killing her as well to keep her from alerting anyone. The novel calls this his second, quite unexpected murder, after which fear gains more and more mastery over him.

How does Lizaveta's absence from the flat become known to Raskolnikov?

By pure chance, Raskolnikov hears Lizaveta in the Hay Market saying she plans to visit a huckster's family the next evening at seven o'clock. This reveals to him that Alyona will be alone at that time, and he sees this chance encounter as a crucial turning point in his life.

How does Lizaveta die — does she try to resist?

She doesn’t try to escape or fight back. Pale as a ghost and unable to scream, she slowly stretches out her empty left hand, almost as if to gesture him away. She doesn’t even lift her hand to shield her face, and the axe takes her down with one swift strike.

What connection did Lizaveta have with Sonia?

Lizaveta and Sonia were close friends who often met up, read the Gospels together, and shared conversations. Lizaveta had given Sonia a copper cross, which Sonia keeps for herself when she gives Raskolnikov her own cypress cross as he goes to confess.

Why does Raskolnikov see Lizaveta's face in Sonia's face?

At that moment he confesses to Sonia, her look of helpless, childlike terror perfectly reflects what he recalls of Lizaveta's face when he raised the axe — the same outstretched hand, the same shrinking away. This visual echo reveals how Lizaveta's death is intertwined with his guilt and his longing for forgiveness.

What role does Lizaveta's murder play at Raskolnikov's trial?

The court observes that a man who commits two murders and then forgets to close the door behind him cannot be said to be acting with full rational control. It was stated that "the murder of Lizaveta served indeed to confirm" the idea that Raskolnikov was in an abnormal mental state, which played a role in leading to a more lenient sentence.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • The unintended victim as moral crux: Lizaveta's death reveals the fundamental flaw in Raskolnikov's utilitarian calculus—his theory accounted for one "louse," but not for the innocent bystander his plan inevitably created.

  • Passivity and innocence: Lizaveta's inability to scream or defend herself is portrayed through the lens of childlike helplessness; consider how Dostoevsky uses this image to heighten Raskolnikov's guilt and the reader’s moral judgment.

  • The cross as symbol: Trace the copper cross from Lizaveta to Sonia, and Sonia's cypress cross to Raskolnikov; argue how these objects connect Lizaveta's death to the theme of redemptive suffering.

  • Chance and fate: The Hay Market encounter is framed as both accidental and "predestined"; analyze how Lizaveta's role as an unwitting informant and victim illustrates the novel's tension between free will and inevitability.

  • Lizaveta and Sonia as doubles: Both women are exploited, both are linked to the Gospels, and Raskolnikov sees Lizaveta's face in Sonia's at the moment of confession; reflect on what this doubling suggests about the novel's perspective on female suffering and spiritual witness.

Crime and Punishment

Continue

Full study guide →