What happens in Introduction of Common Sense?
Thomas Paine begins Common Sense (1776) not by listing grievances but by laying out a fundamental argument about the essence of government. He clearly differentiates between society and government: society is a positive force arising from human needs and cooperation, while government is, at most, a necessary evil—an institution created to restrain human vices. Paine illustrates this idea with a thought experiment involving a small group of settlers in a remote area who, starting from a state of natural freedom, gradually establish rules and elect representatives, only to see those representatives stray from their constituents' interests. From this scenario, Paine derives a key principle: regular elections are the only dependable safeguard against the abuse of power. He then shifts his focus to the English constitution, rejecting its praised balance of the king, lords, and commons as mere fiction. He contends that the commons cannot effectively check the crown since the crown appoints the lords and influences elections. This introduction sets the stage for Paine's argument: he is not seeking reform but actively challenging the very legitimacy of monarchical rule before his colonial audience can voice any objections.
Analysis
Paine begins with a rhetorical approach before diving into philosophical arguments. By distinguishing "society" from "government" in his opening lines, he diminishes the government's organic dignity—it isn't the pinnacle of civilization but rather its safety net. The subsequent pastoral thought experiment serves as an excellent example of accessible political theory: Paine reinterprets Lockean social-contract concepts into a relatable scene for colonial readers, all while avoiding Locke's complex jargon. His writing style reflects this straightforwardness. Sentences are short, direct, and build upon one another; subordinate clauses are uncommon. This choice is intentional— the pamphlet rejects the complex syntax that suggests elite authorship, embodying its democratic message in its very structure.
The theme of necessity runs through the chapter like a fault line. Government is essential; kings are not. This distinction will play a significant role in the following pages, and Paine introduces it subtly, almost as a definition rather than an assertion. His analysis of the English constitution brings in another theme: theatrical appearance versus structural reality. The constitution may appear balanced, but Paine reveals the mechanisms hidden behind the scenes. The tone shifts noticeably when he discusses monarchy—the initially measured and almost instructional tone gives way to an unmistakable contempt, a change that lets readers know they are being drawn into an argument, rather than just being informed about one.
Key quotes from Introduction
“Society is produced by our wants, and government by our wickedness; the former promotes our happiness positively by uniting our affections, the latter negatively by restraining our vices.”
Paine's opening definitional salvo, establishing the society/government binary that structures the entire pamphlet.
“Government, even in its best state, is but a necessary evil; in its worst state, an intolerable one.”
The sentence that crystallizes Paine's foundational premise and would become one of the most quoted lines in American political writing.
“The more simple any thing is, the less liable it is to be disordered, and the easier repaired when disordered.”
Paine's justification for preferring plain republican government over the complex, interlocking machinery of the English constitution.