Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · Civil Surgeon and Aziz's superior, hostile to Indians

Major Callendar

in A Passage to India by E. M. Forster

Major Callendar is the Civil Surgeon at Chandrapore and Dr. Aziz's direct superior. Throughout the novel, he represents a figure of petty colonial authority: dismissive, contemptuous, and openly hostile toward Indians. He calls Aziz at inconvenient hours but is often absent when Aziz arrives, a pattern that Aziz sees as a form of deliberate humiliation. Callendar refuses to grant Aziz leave for the Marabar expedition until Fielding steps in, allowing it only with "contemptuous snarling permission." During the crisis after the caves incident, he controls access to Miss Quested, blocks efforts to question her, and exploits the emergency to stoke English opinion, spreading sensational accusations against Aziz and calling for troops to "clear the bazaars." At the trial, he disrupts proceedings, ridicules the Indian magistrate's authority, and boasts about instilling fear in hospital patients. He takes pleasure in the disfigurement of Nureddin, laughing at the young man's injuries. After the trial falls apart, rumors circulate that he will be dismissed. Callendar embodies the casual cruelty and institutional racism of British colonial rule, and Forster uses him to illustrate how this system degrades both its victims and its enforcers.

About this character

Role
Civil Surgeon and Aziz's superior, hostile to Indians
Form
Novel
Author
E. M. Forster
First published
1924

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Major Callendar?

Major Callendar is the Civil Surgeon at Chandrapore, wielding institutional power over Aziz as his superior. His twenty years in India serve as a badge of authority, but the novel illustrates that he has learned nothing during that time: "He never realized that the educated Indians visited one another constantly, and were weaving, however painfully, a new social fabric." At the club meeting after the caves incident, his face is described as "cumbrous" and "pasty," and he seems to resent even the recovery of his patient. Callendar isn't a complex villain; rather, he represents the colonial official whose habitual cruelty is paired with a sense of self-righteousness.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Major Callendar's arc and motivation?

Callendar remains unchanged throughout the story. His primary motivation is to uphold racial hierarchy and maintain personal authority. He views Aziz's professional skills as a challenge rather than an asset, privately acknowledging that "if Aziz and not he had operated last year on Mrs. Graysford's appendix, the old lady would probably have lived," yet this knowledge "did not dispose him any better towards his subordinate." After the crisis following the caves, his behavior shifts from bureaucratic obstruction to outright incitement, but this is merely a difference in degree.

03·Key moments

What are Major Callendar's key moments?

In Part I, Chapter II, Callendar summons Aziz through a chuprassi, leaves before Aziz arrives, and sends no message; his wife then takes over Aziz's tonga. This scene sets the tone for a pattern of casual humiliation. In Part I, Chapter VI, Callendar walks away without hearing Aziz's explanation for his tardiness, while the narrator reveals his private knowledge of Aziz's surgical superiority—making his contempt seem disingenuous. In Part II, Chapter XIII, he denies Aziz leave for the Marabar expedition, citing "recent malingering," only relenting after Fielding intervenes. In Part II, Chapter XX, during a club meeting after the caves incident, he spreads the rumor that Aziz arranged for Mrs. Moore to suffocate, calls for troops, manipulates a subaltern to provoke Fielding, and suggests that Fielding has been bribed. In Part II, Chapter XXIV, at the trial, he interrupts the proceedings, demands Miss Quested be moved to the platform, and when she recants, he shouts, "I stop these proceedings on medical grounds." He also boasts about having "put the fear of God" into hospital patients and laughs at Nureddin's disfigurement. In Part II, Chapter XXV, rumors circulate that he boasted, "I have tortured that nigger," prompting a crowd to march on the hospital intending to "maltreat Major Callendar in revenge." In Part II, Chapter XXVII, Aziz predicts to Fielding that Panna Lal and Callendar will get the sack.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Major Callendar's most important relationships?

Callendar's relationship with Aziz is the clearest portrayal of colonial power at the individual level: the superior who can disrupt a subordinate's evenings, ignore explanations, deny leave, and face no consequences. Aziz's anger is palpable—"Major Callendar interrupts me night after night from where I am dining with my friends and I go at once, breaking up a most pleasant entertainment, and he is not there and not even a message"—yet he knows he "can do nothing and he knows it." With Fielding, Callendar's hostility is rooted in ideology: Fielding's refusal to conform after the caves labels him an enemy, and Callendar seizes the crisis as an opportunity to undermine him socially. His general relationship with the English community reflects a man whose outbursts are usually discounted, though at the club meeting after the caves his accusations make everyone uneasy.

05·Connected characters

How is Major Callendar connected to the other characters?

Dr. Aziz

Callendar is Aziz's superior at the hospital, and their relationship is defined by chronic humiliation: Callendar summons Aziz without explanation, dismisses his excuses without listening, denies him leave, and privately acknowledges that Aziz is the more skilled surgeon while resenting him for it.

Fielding

Callendar regards Fielding with hostility after Fielding sides with Aziz, insinuating at the club that Fielding has been bribed and setting a subaltern on him; Fielding in turn describes Callendar as someone who 'doesn't trust anyone, English or Indian.'

Ronny

Ronny holds that he must pass on to Callendar any criticism an Indian makes of the Major, expecting the same in return, and he largely defers to his authority, consulting him about Miss Quested's health and bail decisions.

Collector

The Collector and Callendar operate as allied pillars of Anglo-Indian authority; Turton publicly absolves Callendar of blame over the caves expedition and relies on his medical reports during the crisis.

Miss Quested

Callendar is Miss Quested's attending physician after the caves incident, controlling who may see her and issuing grave medical bulletins that shape the English community's response to the alleged assault.

Mahmoud Ali

Mahmoud Ali spreads the report that Callendar boasted of torturing Nureddin, and at the trial pointedly notes that Callendar does not believe Indians can fall ill.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Major Callendar

Why does Callendar summon Aziz and then not be there?

The novel offers no real justification — there is "not even a message" — and portrays the incident as a display of power simply for the sake of it. Aziz sees it as a purposeful slight: "I am just a subordinate, my time is of no value."

Does Callendar know Aziz is a skilled doctor?

Yes. The narrator notes that Callendar knew in his heart that if Aziz and not he had operated on Mrs. Graysford's appendix, the old lady would probably have lived, and that this did not dispose him any better towards his subordinate.

What does Callendar do during the crisis after the Marabar caves?

He manages who can talk to Miss Quested, prevents anyone from questioning her, releases troubling medical updates, claims at the club that Aziz orchestrated Mrs. Moore's suffocation, suggests that Fielding has accepted a bribe, and demands troops be sent in to "clear the bazaars."

How does Callendar behave at the trial?

He interrupts the proceedings and insists that Miss Quested be moved to the platform. When she recants, he shouts, "I stop these proceedings on medical grounds." He also ridicules the Indian magistrate's authority and growls at the defense barrister to "cut the cackle and let's have the verdict."

What happens to Callendar after the trial?

Aziz predicts that Panna Lal and Callendar will get the sack, and by Part II, Chapter XXXI, a Major Roberts has taken over as Civil Surgeon.

Why does the crowd march on the hospital after the trial?

A rumor circulates that Callendar claimed, "I have tortured that nigger," referring to Nureddin. The crowd, already agitated, heads toward Minto Hospital with the intent to "maltreat Major Callendar in revenge." Dr. Panna Lal steps in to prevent disaster.

What does Callendar's treatment of Nureddin reveal about him?

He gleefully describes Nureddin's disfigurement: "His beauty's gone, five upper teeth, two lower and a nostril." He adds, "I laughed; I laughed, I tell you," and wishes he could have done the same to his late assistant. Forster shows this as the culmination of his disdain for Indians.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Callendar as a representation of institutional rather than individual evil: how Forster uses him to demonstrate that colonial cruelty is less about personal malice and more about systemic power.

  • The significance of Callendar's awareness of Aziz's surgical skill: what does it reveal about the psychological toll of maintaining racial hierarchy?

  • Callendar's role in the trial scene as a case study of how colonial authority undermines formal justice.

  • The rumor of Callendar's boast ("I have tortured that nigger") and the ensuing crowd's march on the hospital: how does Forster illustrate the violence inherent in colonial medicine through this moment?

  • Compare Callendar with Turton as symbols of British authority: what does each figure suggest about the different ways colonial power is exercised?

A Passage to India

Continue

Full study guide →