What does 'smite a rock' mean at the end of the poem?

It refers to the story in Exodus 17, where God instructs Moses to strike a rock with his staff, causing water to flow out miraculously to quench the thirst of the Israelites. Rossetti uses this as a metaphor: she sees herself as the rock, dry and unfeeling, and she is pleading with Christ to strike her so that tears and true emotion can finally be released.

Why does Rossetti say 'I, only I' as a line on its own?

That isolated line serves as the emotional high point of the poem. After mentioning everyone — the women, Peter, the thief, the sun, the moon — who reacted to the crucifixion with emotion, she identifies herself as the lone exception. By placing it alone on the page, it takes on the weight of a verdict, and the repetition of 'I' highlights her isolation and her self-blame.

What does the sheep and stone imagery mean?

In the Bible, sheep represent the followers of Christ — the Good Shepherd knows them, and they respond to him. A stone symbolizes the opposite: cold, unresponsive, and unfeeling. By asking, "Am I a stone and not a sheep?" Rossetti is reflecting on whether she genuinely belongs to God, as she struggles to experience the feelings that a true believer would have.

Is this poem about doubt or about grief?

It’s really about both at once. The grief is what she *cannot* feel, and that inability creates the doubt. She doesn’t doubt that the crucifixion occurred or that it matters — she questions whether her own heart can truly respond to it, which leads to a quieter and more unsettling kind of spiritual crisis.

What is the structure and rhyme scheme of the poem?

The poem consists of four stanzas, each with four lines, featuring a distinctive indented shape that visually separates the middle two lines. Each stanza follows an ABBA rhyme scheme, where the first and fourth lines rhyme, as do the second and third. This enclosed format captures the sense of feeling trapped or confined within oneself.

Who are the women and Peter that Rossetti mentions?

The women are a group of female followers — including Mary Magdalene and Mary, the mother of James — who, according to the Gospels, stood near the cross and later visited the tomb. Peter is the apostle who denied knowing Jesus three times and then, upon realizing his actions, 'wept bitterly.' Both of them illustrate how love for Christ can be expressed through tears.

Why does Rossetti call Christ 'Greater than Moses'?

Moses is recognized as the greatest prophet in the Hebrew Bible, known for leading Israel out of Egypt and receiving the Law. Referring to Christ as 'Greater than Moses' is a theological assertion that Jesus not only fulfills but also transcends the old covenant. This also evokes the image of 'smite a rock'—if Moses performed that miracle, then Christ, being greater, can undoubtedly achieve the same with her heart.

The Annotated Edition

Good Friday by Christina Rossetti

Summary, meaning, line-by-line analysis & FAQ.

Read aloud in ~1 minOpen reading mode →

In "Good Friday," Christina Rossetti finds herself at the foot of the cross, feeling ashamed for her inability to cry.

Poet: Christina Rossetti
Composed: 1866 · Victorian
Core theme: Doubt

The PoemFull text

Good Friday

Christina Rossetti, 1866

Am I a stone and not a sheep, That I can stand, O Christ, beneath Thy cross, To number drop by drop Thy blood's slow loss And yet not weep? Not so those women loved Who with exceeding grief lamented Thee; Not so fallen Peter weeping bitterly; Not so the thief was moved; Not so the Sun and Moon Which hid their faces in the starless sky, A horror of great darkness at broad noon — I, only I. Yet give not o'er, But seek Thy sheep, true Shepherd of the flock Greater than Moses, turn and look once more, And smite a rock.

§01Quick summary

What this poem is about

In "Good Friday," Christina Rossetti finds herself at the foot of the cross, feeling ashamed for her inability to cry. While even the sun, the moon, and a hardened thief show emotion, she feels nothing. She channels that shame into a prayer, asking Christ to strike her heart like Moses struck a rock to let water flow. This poem explores spiritual numbness and the deep hope that God can break through even the coldest heart.

§02Themes

Recurring themes

§03Line by line

Stanza by stanza, with notes

Am I a stone and not a sheep, / That I can stand, O Christ, beneath Thy cross,
Editor's note
Rossetti begins with a question that also reveals her inner struggle. As she stands at the crucifixion without shedding any tears, she questions if she resembles a cold stone more than one of Christ's sheep. This contrast establishes the poem's main tension: she *ought* to feel sorrow, yet she doesn't, and that lack of emotion deeply disturbs her.
Not so those women loved / Who with exceeding grief lamented Thee;
Editor's note
She names everyone who *did* respond emotionally at the crucifixion: the women at the tomb, Peter who wept bitterly after denying Christ, and even the thief crucified next to Him. Each 'Not so' feels like a small hammer blow, highlighting her own coldness in contrast to the warmth of others' grief. The repetition creates a rhythm of self-accusation that strikes directly at her.
Not so the Sun and Moon / Which hid their faces in the starless sky,
Editor's note
Even the natural world seemed to grieve — the Gospels mention darkness enveloping the land when Christ died. Rossetti incorporates this universal detail to amplify her shame: even the lifeless stars expressed more emotion than she did. The phrase 'a horror of great darkness at broad noon' resonates with the King James Bible's language, making the contrast almost unbearable.
I, only I.
Editor's note
This single, isolated line is the emotional heart of the poem. It stands alone on the page, separated from everything else, reflecting Rossetti’s own feelings of isolation in her struggle to mourn. The repetition of 'I' conveys both a sense of self-blame and a quiet desperation.
Yet give not o'er, / But seek Thy sheep, true Shepherd of the flock
Editor's note
The final stanza shifts from despair to a heartfelt plea. Rossetti implores Christ not to abandon her. She refers to him as 'true Shepherd' and 'Greater than Moses,' evoking the Old Testament moment when Moses struck the rock at Horeb to provide water for the Israelites. Her prayer is for Christ to do the same to her hardened heart — to strike it and free the tears, emotions, and faith that feel trapped within.

§04Tone & mood

How this poem feels

The tone is both penitent and raw, yet never indulgent. Rossetti writes with a clear-eyed self-accusation—she's not simply displaying guilt; she truly struggles to grasp her emotional numbness, and that confusion creates tension in the poem. By the final stanza, the tone shifts to an urgent, almost demanding prayer. It concludes not in despair but in a stubborn, desperate hope.

§05Symbols & metaphors

Symbols & metaphors

Stone: The stone symbolizes spiritual hardness and emotional numbness. Rossetti worries that she is composed of the same unfeeling substance as the rocks surrounding the cross, unable to feel the grief that faith ought to inspire. This also leads into the final image of Moses striking a rock.
Sheep: The sheep symbolizes a believer within Christ's flock — attentive, recognized, and nurtured. When Rossetti questions whether she is a sheep or a stone, she is essentially inquiring about her connection to God.
The darkened Sun and Moon: The Gospel accounts of the crucifixion describe the sun and moon hiding, symbolizing all of creation grieving for its Creator. Rossetti uses this imagery to illustrate that even the unthinking celestial bodies experienced more sorrow than she did, highlighting her deepest feelings of self-reproach.
The smitten rock: A reference to Exodus 17, where Moses strikes a rock and water flows out to save the Israelites. Here, it serves as a metaphor for Rossetti's heart: she prays that Christ will break through her stony exterior and let the tears and emotions trapped inside flow free.
Tears / weeping: Throughout the poem, weeping represents a true expression of faith and love. Peter cried, the women cried, and the thief showed emotion. For Rossetti, not being able to weep indicates a spiritual crisis — a gap between the beliefs in one's mind and the feelings in one's heart.

§06Historical context

Historical context

Christina Rossetti wrote within the Anglo-Catholic tradition of the Church of England, which placed a strong emphasis on liturgical observance and deep devotional feelings. Good Friday, marking the crucifixion of Christ, was the most solemn day of the year, and Christians were expected to approach it with true remorse and sorrow. Rossetti included this poem in her 1866 collection *The Prince's Progress and Other Poems*, although it likely originated earlier. Throughout her adult life, she faced serious health issues and produced a significant amount of devotional poetry that candidly grapples with doubt, spiritual dryness, and the disparity between faith's expectations and the realities of the heart. This poem clearly reflects the concept of *acedia* — a kind of spiritual numbness or dryness — which she addresses not as a source of shame but as something to openly bring before God.

§07FAQ

Questions readers ask

It is about Rossetti standing at the foot of the cross on Good Friday, feeling spiritually numb—unable to cry or experience grief as she thinks she ought to. She unfavorably compares herself to everyone else present at the crucifixion, even to the sun and moon, and concludes by asking Christ to shatter her hardened heart just as Moses broke open a rock.

More by Christina Rossetti

Browse all Christina Rossetti poems →

Themes in this poem

Poems about Doubt Poems about Faith Poems about Identity Poems about Sorrow

Poetry tools

Analyze another poem →Rate your own poem →Check rhyme & meter →

Best Poems About Love

Story Rater

Simple, flat pricing

Account

Site