Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis

John Hiddle (Sal's Father)

in Walk Two Moons by Sharon Creech

John Hiddle is Sal's father, who is quietly grieving and whose choices shape the novel's core displacement and emotional journey. A farmer at heart, John uproots thirteen-year-old Sal from their cherished Bybanks, Kentucky farm after the death of his wife, Sugar, moving them to Euclid, Ohio—a decision Sal resents deeply throughout the story. His struggle to openly process Sugar's death reflects Sal's own suppressed grief; he copes by keeping busy—repainting the trim, tending to their new house, and, controversially, befriending neighbor Margaret Cadaver. Sal sees this friendship as a betrayal of her mother's memory, and tension between father and daughter simmers in nearly every scene they share.

John is depicted as gentle and well-meaning but emotionally constrained—he struggles to express his pain to Sal, just as she finds it hard to share hers with him. A key moment reveals that Margaret was present when Sugar died in the bus accident, and John's connection to her is his way of holding onto his wife's final moments, not replacing her. This insight shifts his narrative from seeming abandonment to quiet, broken loyalty.

By the end of the novel, after Sal's road trip with her grandparents and the heartbreaking confirmation of Sugar's death, John drives to Idaho to bring Sal home. His arrival marks a tentative reconciliation—two people who have been running from the same grief finally turning to face it together. He expresses love through action rather than words, highlighting the painful gap between his intentions and Sal's understanding of them.

About this character

Form
Novel
Author
Sharon Creech
First published
1994

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is John Hiddle (Sal's Father)?

John Hiddle is a Kentucky farmer displaced by grief, most fully himself when his hands are in soil and his family is around him on the Bybanks farm. Sharon Creech introduces him through Sal's memories rather than direct action: we first meet him as an absence, the father who packed up their lives after Sugar's death and drove them to a trim Ohio suburb that smells nothing like home. He is soft-spoken and physically gentle—the kind of man who paints window trim and tends a new garden because he does not know what else to do with sorrow. Though he occupies relatively few scenes on the page, every major current in the novel runs back to him: the move, the friendship with Margaret Cadaver, Sal's cross-country road trip, and the final reckoning in Idaho.

02·Arc & motivation

What is John Hiddle (Sal's Father)'s arc and motivation?

John's arc is a slow emergence from paralysis. Sugar's death in the Lewiston, Idaho bus accident does not break him loudly; it hollows him out quietly, and the move to Euclid is his attempt to outrun a farmhouse saturated with her absence. His core motivation is survival—both his own and Sal's—though he struggles to explain this to his daughter. He keeps busy rather than speaking: repainting the trim, planting bulbs, hosting Margaret for dinner. Each domestic act substitutes for the conversation he cannot start. His arc resolves when he drives to Idaho to retrieve Sal after the truth about Sugar's death is confirmed, an action that replaces months of emotional silence with one decisive, love-driven gesture. He moves from avoidance to presence, from managing grief alone to sharing its weight with his daughter.

03·Key moments

What are John Hiddle (Sal's Father)'s key moments?

  • The decision to leave Bybanks: Never dramatised in real time, the move is recounted through Sal's bitterness. Its significance is enormous because John never fully explains it to Sal, establishing the novel's central pattern of good intentions left unspoken.
  • Margaret Cadaver's dinners: John's easy companionship with Margaret, which Sal watches with barely concealed fury, is the novel's most sustained site of misunderstanding. He laughs, passes dishes, seems almost like his old self—behaviour Sal interprets as replacing Sugar.
  • The revelation about Margaret: When Sal learns that Margaret witnessed Sugar's final moments, John's behaviour is recontextualised entirely. He never told Sal because he could not find the words, a silence that costs him his daughter's trust for most of the narrative.
  • The drive to Idaho: John's arrival at Coeur d'Alene after Sal's ordeal is the closest thing to an open declaration of love he manages in the novel. He comes not with explanations but with presence, mirroring the way Sugar expressed love—through touch and action rather than language.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are John Hiddle (Sal's Father)'s most important relationships?

With Sal: Their relationship is the novel's emotional spine. John loves Sal fiercely but communicates through behaviour—the preserved farm chores he assigns her, the way he lets her grandparents take her on the road trip—rather than words. The gap between his love and Sal's ability to perceive it generates the novel's central dramatic irony.

With Sugar: Sugar is the negative space around which John's every post-death decision is shaped. The move, the bond with Margaret, even his relative silence about Idaho—all are consequences of a love he cannot survive losing. Sal's memories of her parents together paint a marriage of deep ease and physicality, making his grief immense.

With Margaret Cadaver: This is the relationship Creech uses to test both John's character and the reader's sympathy. John clings to Margaret because she is the last person who saw Sugar alive, a choice that is both understandable and devastating in its effect on Sal. His possible intention to remarry, which Sal hints at, suggests he is further along in processing grief than his daughter yet the manner in which he pursues this—without transparency to Sal—repeats his fundamental flaw.

With Gram and Gramps: John's willingness to send Sal cross-country with her elderly grandparents reflects his trust in family and, perhaps, an awareness that they can give Sal access to Sugar's memory in ways he cannot. He remains in Euclid, settling and grieving in parallel.

05·Connected characters

How is John Hiddle (Sal's Father) connected to the other characters?

Salamanca Tree Hiddle

John is Sal's father and the emotional anchor of her world. His decision to leave Bybanks and his friendship with Margaret create the central conflict between them, yet his drive to Idaho at the novel's close signals their shared grief finally becoming a bridge rather than a wall.

Chanhassen (Sugar) Hiddle

Sugar is John's late wife and the love of his life. Her death from the bus accident in Lewiston, Idaho hollows him out; every major choice he makes in the novel—the move to Euclid, the bond with Margaret—is a direct consequence of his inability to survive her absence.

Margaret Cadaver

Margaret was present at the scene of Sugar's fatal accident, making her John's living link to his wife's last moments. His close friendship with her, including plans to remarry hinted at by Sal, is misread by Sal as betrayal but is ultimately revealed as grief-driven connection.

Gram (Grandma Hiddle)

Gram is John's mother-in-law. She and Gramps undertake the cross-country drive partly to give John time to settle in Euclid and partly out of their own need to reach Sugar's grave, reflecting the family's collective mourning that John quietly participates in from a distance.

Gramps (Grandpa Hiddle)

Gramps is John's father-in-law. Like Gram, Gramps represents the extended family network that surrounds John's grief; John trusts them enough to allow Sal to make the long road trip with them, revealing his faith in family even amid his own emotional withdrawal.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about John Hiddle (Sal's Father)

Why does John Hiddle move Sal away from their Bybanks, Kentucky farm?

John moves Sal to Euclid, Ohio to escape a farmhouse filled with memories of Sugar after her death in a bus accident in Lewiston, Idaho. His core motivation is survival—both for himself and Sal—though he never fully explains this to her. Because he keeps the reason to himself, the move feels to Sal like abandonment rather than the grief-driven attempt at a fresh start that it is.

Why does John Hiddle spend so much time with neighbor Margaret Cadaver?

John befriends Margaret because she was present at the scene of Sugar's fatal bus accident, serving as a living link to his wife's last moments. Sal interprets the friendship as John replacing her mother, but once the truth about Margaret's connection to Sugar is revealed, his behavior is understood as grief-driven loyalty rather than betrayal. This becomes one of the novel's central dramatic ironies.

What is John Hiddle's relationship with Sal like throughout the novel?

John and Sal share the novel's central father-daughter bond, but it is strained by a painful gap between his deep love and his inability to express it in words. He communicates through action—assigning Sal farm chores, allowing her grandparents to take her on the road trip—while Sal desires direct conversation about Sugar. This mismatch generates the dramatic irony that drives much of the story.

Does John Hiddle have a famous or memorable quote in the novel?

No direct quotes from John Hiddle appear in the novel's attributed material. His characterisation relies almost entirely on silence and action rather than spoken language, which highlights the point Creech makes about him: he expresses love through gesture—repainting trim, planting bulbs, driving to Idaho—rather than words.

How does John Hiddle's story end — what happens to him by the close of the novel?

After Sal's road trip with her grandparents confirms the heartbreaking truth of Sugar's death, John drives all the way to Idaho to bring Sal home. His arrival at Coeur d'Alene serves as the novel's closest thing to an open declaration of love from him, replacing months of emotional silence with one decisive, presence-driven gesture. It signifies a tentative reconciliation—two people finally facing their shared grief together.

How does John Hiddle cope with Sugar's death throughout the novel?

John copes by staying busy rather than speaking openly about his grief. He repaints window trim, plants bulbs, tends the new house, and hosts Margaret for dinner—domestic acts that take the place of conversations he cannot start. Creech presents him as emotionally constrained, quietly hollowed out rather than loudly broken, mirroring Sal's own suppressed grief while making communication between them nearly impossible.

Why does John Hiddle let Sal go on a cross-country road trip with Gram and Gramps?

John trusts Gram and Gramps—Sugar's parents—enough to allow the journey, reflecting his faith in family even amid his emotional withdrawal. He remains in Euclid settling and grieving, yet he seems aware that Sal's grandparents can provide her access to Sugar's memory in ways he cannot. This decision suggests he understands, on some level, that Sal needs to process her mother's death on her own terms.

Is John Hiddle a bad father in Walk Two Moons?

John is not malicious, but Creech frames his silence as genuinely damaging—his failure to explain the move, the bond with Margaret, or the truth about Idaho costs him Sal's trust for most of the novel. He is gentle and well-meaning, and his drive to Idaho ultimately redeems him in Sal's eyes; however, the novel leaves open the question of whether one decisive act of presence fully makes up for months of unexplained emotional withdrawal.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Argue that John's silence is as destructive as any deliberate act of harm

    How does Creech use his failure to communicate to demonstrate that love without expression can feel indistinguishable from abandonment?

  • Examine the function of physical labour in John's characterisation

    How do acts like repainting trim and planting bulbs serve as both character revelation and thematic commentary on how men in the novel process loss?

  • Analyse the friendship with Margaret Cadaver as a study in dramatic irony

    How does Creech structure the reader's gradual revaluation of John's motives, and what does this reveal about the dangers of grief-driven misreading?

  • Compare John's grief to Gram's and Gramps's

    All three adults are mourning Sugar, yet express it differently. What does the contrast suggest about generational or gendered patterns of mourning in the novel?

  • Consider John's drive to Idaho as the novel's moral resolution

    To what extent does one act of decisive presence redeem months of emotional withdrawal, and does Creech fully endorse this redemption or leave it ambiguous?

Walk Two Moons

Continue

Full study guide →