What happens in Chapter 79 of The Count of Monte Cristo?
Morrel hurries on foot to Noirtier's house in Faubourg Saint-Honoré, with the old servant Barrois struggling to keep up. In Noirtier's study, Valentine shares her grandfather's plan: Noirtier wants to leave Villefort's house, and Valentine will live with him. When she comes of age in about ten months, she will be free to marry Morrel with Noirtier's blessing. Morrel and Valentine promise to wait for each other, and Valentine urges Morrel not to take any hasty actions that might jeopardize their happiness. After the run, Barrois, feeling overheated, accepts a glass of Noirtier's lemonade from Valentine and drinks it down. Suddenly, the doorbell rings—Valentine suspects it's Doctor d'Avrigny's Saturday visit. Barrois, staggering, collapses into convulsions. Villefort and Madame de Villefort enter. Madame de Villefort questions what Barrois has eaten, comments that lemonade was "a very bad thing for him," and steps back before any bleeding occurs. D'Avrigny arrives, examines Barrois, and becomes suspicious of the lemonade due to its bitter taste. He interrogates Noirtier and Barrois: Barrois prepared the lemonade, left it in the pantry, and Valentine brought it to the room. Despite D'Avrigny's attempts, Barrois dies. D'Avrigny tests the leftover lemonade with syrup of violets; it shifts from blue to sapphire to opal to emerald green, indicating poison. D'Avrigny concludes that Barrois has been poisoned and recalls the similar sudden deaths of the Saint-Mérans.
Analysis
The chapter begins with the lightheartedness of a romantic comedy, featuring Morrel's enthusiastic stride, Valentine's shy, lowered eyes, and Noirtier's quiet kindness. It then takes a sharp turn into medical horror when Barrois suddenly collapses. The narrative follows a single path from hope to disaster, all linked by the lemonade, which transitions from Valentine's generous offer to the cause of Barrois's demise. The triangle metaphor introduced at the chapter's beginning—Morrel and Barrois as "two parts of a triangle" connected through Noirtier—sets up a theme of relationships centered around a single point, with the lemonade serving as another connection: Noirtier and Barrois both drink from the same decanter, but only Barrois drains a full glass. Madame de Villefort's actions are depicted with care: she dodges questions about d'Avrigny, inquires about Barrois's eating habits, remarks that lemonade was "a very bad thing for him," and withdraws upstairs before he can be bled. Noirtier's paralysis adds a layer of dramatic irony—he perceives and comprehends everything but cannot express himself, communicating only through his gaze and by closing an eye. D'Avrigny's inquiry propels the chapter forward, featuring clinical questioning, the clue of the bitter taste, and the search for the decanter. The poison test reveals itself in a vivid spectrum—"blue shade" to "sapphire" to "opal" to "emerald"—making the unseen poison unmistakably tangible. D'Avrigny's mention of the Saint-Mérans expands the chapter's focus from a single death to a broader pattern.
Key quotes from Chapter 79
“hearts inflamed by obstacles to their desire grew cold in time of security; I trust we shall never find it so in our experience!”
Valentine, relaying Noirtier's plan to Morrel, voices her fear that happiness once attained might cool their love.
“People die very suddenly in your house, M. de Villefort.”
Doctor d'Avrigny says this to Villefort after Barrois dies, linking his death to those of the Saint-Mérans.
““The unfortunate Barrois has been poisoned,” said d’Avrigny, “and I will maintain this assertion before God and man.””
After the syrup-of-violets test turns the lemonade emerald green, d'Avrigny declares his conclusion to Villefort.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign in