Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis

Maeve Rojas

in One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus

Maeve Rojas is Bronwyn's younger sister and a recurring supporting character in One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus. While she isn't one of the four main suspects, Maeve serves as an emotional anchor and an amateur investigator, helping to unravel the mystery as it unfolds. A cancer survivor—her leukemia is mentioned early on as a significant part of her life that has made her both sharp and fiercely loyal—Maeve tackles the turmoil surrounding Simon's death with an analytical approach that rivals Bronwyn's academic prowess.

Maeve is known for her dry humor, emotional intelligence, and her refusal to accept simple explanations. She is quick to express doubt about the official story of Simon's death and encourages Bronwyn and the other Bayview Four to dig deeper instead of just going along with what the authorities say. In important moments, she offers essential support to Bronwyn during the investigation, helping her sister navigate feelings of guilt, fear, and her growing attraction to Nate.

Her journey shifts from a worried younger sister to a vital ally. She forges a significant bond with Janae Norman—Simon’s closest friend—which adds a tender subplot to the novel and gives Maeve her own emotional stakes beyond her sister’s troubles. By the end of the book, Maeve has transformed from a background character into a key player whose instincts and bravery have genuinely influenced the outcome, showing that courage and insight can come from unexpected places.

About this character

Form
Novel
Author
Karen M. McManus
First published
2017

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Maeve Rojas?

Maeve Rojas is Bronwyn's younger sister and one of the most quietly formidable figures in One of Us Is Lying. She operates largely outside the central murder investigation yet shapes its emotional and intellectual core from the margins. A leukemia survivor, Maeve carries the particular gravity of someone who has already faced mortality before finishing high school. This background is established early in the novel and colours everything about her — her refusal to waste time on polite fictions, her fierce loyalty to the people she loves, and her instinct to push through fear rather than wait for it to pass. Where Bronwyn is driven by academic perfectionism, Maeve is driven by something rawer: her hard-won clarity about what truly matters.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Maeve Rojas's arc and motivation?

Maeve begins the novel as a worried younger sister watching Bronwyn get pulled into a police investigation she cannot control. Her initial motivation is straightforwardly protective — she wants Bronwyn safe and exonerated. As the story develops, Maeve moves beyond that passive, supportive role. Her analytical mind, sharpened by years of medical uncertainty and close observation of the adults around her, leads her to doubt the official account of Simon Kelleher's death almost immediately. She pushes Bronwyn and the Bayview Four to interrogate their understanding rather than simply cooperating with a narrative that is being constructed for them. This shift — from anxious bystander to active investigator — defines her arc. By the novel's final act, Maeve has transitioned from the background into genuine involvement in uncovering the truth, and her emotional life has expanded through her connection with Janae Norman to include stakes that are hers, not borrowed from her sister's story.

03·Key moments

What are Maeve Rojas's key moments?

One of Maeve's most important roles comes in the chapters where she challenges Bronwyn's instinct to comply and remain silent. When Bronwyn wavers between trusting the system and trusting the other suspects, Maeve consistently steers her toward courage rather than caution. Her early scepticism about Simon's death — her refusal to accept that a boy simply collapsed from an allergic reaction in a room full of suspects — plants seeds that propel the investigation forward.

Her budding relationship with Janae represents the novel's most significant moment of Maeve claiming her own story. The two girls find each other while grief and suspicion make almost every other connection unstable, and their scenes together carry a tenderness that contrasts with the thriller's mounting tension. This subplot is handled simply, reflecting Maeve's character perfectly: she doesn't announce herself; she quietly shows up.

Her role in helping Bronwyn process her feelings for Nate — reading the situation clearly and encouraging her sister to look past Nate's reputation — demonstrates her emotional intelligence in real time, grounding the romance subplot in something credible and warm.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Maeve Rojas's most important relationships?

Bronwyn is Maeve's emotional centre of gravity. Their sisterly dynamic is warm and teasing but also deeply serious when the situation demands it. Maeve never flatters Bronwyn or tells her what she wants to hear; she tells her what she needs to hear, a more demanding form of love. This makes her the most reliable voice for Bronwyn throughout the ordeal.

Janae Norman brings Maeve an emotional arc that is entirely her own. The connection is unexpected — Janae was Simon's closest friend, placing her in an ambiguous position for much of the novel — and that complexity enhances the relationship beyond a straightforward romance. Both characters find in each other a person willing to see past surface appearances and easy judgments.

Nate, Addy, and Cooper receive Maeve's support collectively; she serves as an informal ally to the Bayview Four circle, and her ability to see past Nate's reputation specifically reflects her broader refusal to let reputation substitute for character.

Luis Rojas, her father, anchors the domestic dimension of the crisis, contextualizing why Maeve's protectiveness of Bronwyn is so urgent and deeply embedded within the family.

05·Connected characters

How is Maeve Rojas connected to the other characters?

Bronwyn Rojas

Maeve's older sister and closest confidante. Maeve provides unwavering emotional support throughout Bronwyn's ordeal as a suspect, frequently encouraging her to trust her instincts and fight back. Their sisterly bond — warm, teasing, and deeply protective — is one of the novel's most consistent sources of comfort and grounding.

Janae Norman

Maeve develops a tender, budding romantic connection with Janae, Simon's best friend. Their relationship is one of the novel's quieter but more meaningful subplots, as both girls find unexpected understanding in each other amid grief and suspicion. It gives Maeve her own emotional arc independent of her sister's story.

Nate Macaulay

Maeve is an early and enthusiastic supporter of Bronwyn's feelings for Nate, offering sisterly encouragement and perspective. She sees past his bad-boy reputation and helps Bronwyn do the same, indirectly strengthening one of the novel's central relationships.

Simon Kelleher

Though Maeve never interacts with Simon directly in the narrative, his death is the catalyst for her investigative involvement. Her skepticism about the official story drives her to question his motives and legacy, and her connection to Janae deepens her indirect relationship to Simon's memory.

Addy Prentiss

Maeve interacts with Addy as part of the broader Bayview Four circle. She is supportive of Addy's growth and transformation throughout the novel, recognizing in her a resilience that others overlook.

Cooper Clay

Maeve's relationship with Cooper is peripheral but collegial, as she supports all four suspects in her role as an informal ally and investigative sounding board for Bronwyn.

Luis Rojas

Maeve's father, whose presence in the family home underscores the domestic stakes of Bronwyn's situation. The Rojas family dynamic, including Maeve's relationship with Luis, contextualizes her fierce protectiveness of her sister.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Maeve Rojas

How is Maeve Rojas related to Bronwyn in One of Us Is Lying?

Maeve is Bronwyn Rojas's younger sister. Their bond serves as one of the novel's most consistent emotional anchors — warm and teasing on the surface but deeply serious when Bronwyn's situation demands it. Rather than offering empty comfort, Maeve tells Bronwyn what she needs to hear, establishing herself as the most reliable voice in Bronwyn's corner throughout the murder investigation.

What is Maeve Rojas's health background in the novel?

Maeve is a leukemia survivor, and her cancer history defines a significant part of her character. Having faced mortality before finishing high school, she possesses a hard-won clarity about what truly matters — shaping her refusal to accept comfortable fictions, her fierce loyalty, and her instinct to push through fear rather than wait for it to pass.

What is Maeve Rojas's role in solving Simon's murder?

Maeve acts as an amateur investigator and emotional anchor for the Bayview Four. She doubts the official account of Simon Kelleher's death almost immediately, urging Bronwyn and the others to interrogate the narrative constructed for them instead of simply cooperating. Her scepticism plants early seeds that propel the investigation forward, and by the novel's final act she transitions from anxious bystander to genuine participant in uncovering the truth.

Who does Maeve Rojas develop a romantic connection with?

Maeve develops a tender, budding romance with Janae Norman, Simon's closest friend. This connection is unexpected due to Janae's ambiguous position in the story, but both girls find in each other someone willing to see past surface appearances. This subplot gives Maeve an emotional arc that is entirely her own, independent of her sister's ordeal, and represents one of the novel's quieter but more meaningful threads.

Why does Maeve Rojas encourage Bronwyn to trust Nate Macaulay?

Maeve looks beyond Nate's bad-boy reputation and understands that reputation does not equate to character — a perspective shaped by her broader refusal to accept easy judgments about people. She becomes an early, enthusiastic supporter of Bronwyn's feelings for Nate, offering sisterly encouragement and perspective that helps Bronwyn look beyond what others assume about him, indirectly strengthening one of the novel's central relationships.

Does Maeve Rojas have any famous or memorable quotes in One of Us Is Lying?

No specific lines are documented for Maeve in the novel's material. However, her consistent rhetorical stance is significant: she challenges simple explanations, advocates for courage over caution, and refuses to let polite fictions go unchallenged. Her voice is less defined by a single memorable line than by a persistent, dry-humoured insistence on confronting uncomfortable truths.

How does Maeve Rojas change from the beginning to the end of the novel?

Maeve starts as a worried younger sister motivated to keep Bronwyn safe, then becomes a key investigative ally whose instincts genuinely influence the outcome. By the final act, she shifts from the background to active involvement in uncovering the truth, and her romantic connection with Janae has given her emotional stakes that are entirely her own — marking her transition from supporting character to meaningful agent in the story.

Why is Maeve Rojas considered important despite not being one of the four main suspects?

Because she is outside the suspect group, Maeve enjoys a freedom of movement and analysis unavailable to the Bayview Four. She can question the official narrative without the same legal jeopardy, and her outsider status paradoxically makes her more central to solving the mystery. McManus uses Maeve to convey that truth-telling often requires people willing to act without official permission or recognition — making her quiet bravery one of the novel's key thematic statements.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Survival and insight: Argue that Maeve's experience with leukemia directly shapes her investigative instincts

    her willingness to confront uncomfortable truths rather than accept comfortable ones reflects a person who has already faced worst-case realities.

  • The observer as agent: Examine how McManus uses Maeve's position outside the official suspect group to grant her a freedom of movement and analysis that the Bayview Four lack

    and how that outsider status paradoxically makes her more central to solving the mystery.

  • Sisterhood as moral compass: Analyze the Bronwyn–Maeve relationship as the novel's most consistent ethical anchor, exploring how Maeve's unconditional but honest support models a version of loyalty that is both affectionate and morally demanding.

  • Queer representation in genre fiction: Discuss the Maeve–Janae subplot as an example of how YA thriller writing can incorporate LGBTQ+ romance without reducing it to spectacle, using the relationship's quietness as evidence.

  • Secondary characters and structural meaning: Build a thesis on McManus's deliberate choice to give Maeve significant agency despite her non-suspect status, and what that indicates about the novel's assertion that truth-telling requires people willing to act without official permission or recognition.

One of Us Is Lying

Continue

Full study guide →