Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis

Janae Norman

in One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus

Janae Norman is Simon Kelleher's closest — and, as we find out, only true — friend at Bayview High. She’s a quiet, fiercely loyal outsider, and her grief and guilt shape her journey throughout the novel. When Simon dies in detention, Janae's devastation stands in stark contrast to the rest of the school's performative mourning; she knew the real Simon, ran his gossip app About That, and kept his secrets even after he was gone. Her story evolves from a deep protectiveness of Simon's memory to a painful confrontation with who he really was.

Janae is defined by her fierce loyalty, social reticence, and a tendency for self-deception rooted in love. At first, she deflects suspicion and misleads the investigation by deleting app data to protect Simon's legacy. As Bronwyn and the other "Bayview Four" dig deeper, Janae is gradually compelled to face the reality that Simon may have orchestrated his own death as part of a revenge scheme — and that she unknowingly played a role in it. The moment she decides to confide in Bronwyn marks the emotional turning point of the novel: Janae's grief transforms from simple mourning into something more complex and tinged with betrayal.

She is not a villain but rather a foil, illustrating what blind loyalty to Simon feels like from the inside. By the end, her readiness to tell the truth, even if it tarnishes Simon's reputation, signifies her growth from a grieving accomplice to a truthful witness, providing the Bayview Four with the final piece needed to expose Jake Riordan.

About this character

Form
Novel
Author
Karen M. McManus
First published
2017

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Janae Norman?

Janae Norman occupies a unique and quietly devastating position in One of Us Is Lying: she is the only person at Bayview High who genuinely loved Simon Kelleher. While the rest of the school performs grief in the weeks following Simon's death in detention — lighting candles, posting tributes, wearing his face on memorial T-shirts — Janae's mourning is raw and unperformed. She is a social outsider by choice as much as circumstance, defined less by what she wants from the world than by what she is willing to give to one person. That person was Simon. She ran his gossip app, About That, on his behalf; she kept his confidences; and when he died, her first instinct was not to seek justice but to protect what remained of him. This protectiveness — fierce, myopic, and ultimately self-deceiving — is the engine of her entire character.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Janae Norman's arc and motivation?

Janae begins the novel in a posture of pure defense. Her central motivation is preservation: of Simon's memory, of their friendship's meaning, and, by extension, of her own identity, which was so tightly wound around his. When she deletes data from the About That app shortly after Simon's death, she is not covering up a crime she committed — she is refusing to let strangers pick through what she considers sacred. This act of deletion, however, makes her complicit in obstructing the investigation and places her in the novel's moral grey zone.

Her arc is a slow, agonizing unwinding of that defensiveness. As the Bayview Four's investigation gains momentum and the evidence begins to suggest that Simon orchestrated his own death as an elaborate revenge plot, Janae is forced to confront an unbearable possibility: the person she protected was not entirely the person she knew. The emotional turning point arrives when she chooses to confide in Bronwyn. This decision is not easy or triumphant — it is the act of someone who has exhausted every other option and has finally chosen truth over loyalty. By the novel's close, Janae has moved from grieving accomplice to truthful witness, providing the information that confirms Jake Riordan's guilt and brings the central mystery to resolution.

03·Key moments

What are Janae Norman's key moments?

  • Deleting the app data: One of Janae's earliest defining actions, this scene establishes her willingness to break rules for Simon's sake and immediately marks her as a figure of suspicion whose motives are, paradoxically, rooted in love rather than self-interest.
  • Her hostility toward Bronwyn: In multiple interactions, Janae is evasive, cold, and openly antagonistic toward Bronwyn and the other Bayview Four, framing them as threats rather than victims. This behaviour illuminates the tunnel-vision her loyalty creates.
  • The confession to Bronwyn: The pivot of her arc. When Janae finally shares Simon's secrets — including details about the revenge scheme — she surrenders the last fortress she had built around his memory. The conversation transforms Bronwyn from adversary to confidante and gives the investigation the crucial missing context.
  • The revelation of Simon's plan: Learning (and accepting) that Simon may have used her unknowingly is the novel's most brutal moment for Janae. Her grief does not disappear; it becomes more complicated, edged with betrayal and a disorienting reassessment of everything she thought their friendship meant.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Janae Norman's most important relationships?

Simon Kelleher is the defining relationship of Janae's life within the novel's timeline. She loved him completely and without much reciprocal examination — she accepted his cruelty toward others as irrelevant to who he was with her. The posthumous revelation that his scheme manipulated her loyalty without her knowledge reframes their entire friendship as something more asymmetrical than she understood. Her grief, by the end, contains a new and terrible ingredient: the question of whether she ever really knew him.

Bronwyn Rojas functions as Janae's mirror and eventual confessor. Their relationship moves from mutual hostility to fragile trust, and the shift is significant because Bronwyn represents everything Janae initially resents — an outsider demanding access to Simon's story. Choosing to trust Bronwyn is, symbolically, Janae choosing reality over myth.

Jake Riordan is largely an off-screen presence in Janae's emotional life, but her testimony is what exposes him. There is a quiet irony here: Janae, who spent the novel trying to protect Simon, ultimately delivers the blow that vindicates his supposed victims and condemns his actual killer.

Cooper Clay and Addy Prentiss represent, for Janae, the human cost of Simon's plans. Cooper was to be outed; Addy was to be humiliated. Janae's disillusionment is partly driven by recognising that Simon's reach would have destroyed real people she had no particular reason to hate.

05·Connected characters

How is Janae Norman connected to the other characters?

Simon Kelleher

Simon was Janae's best and essentially only friend. She maintained About That on his behalf, covered for him after his death, and only slowly accepts that his revenge scheme used her loyalty against her will — a betrayal that redefines her grief by the novel's end.

Bronwyn Rojas

Janae is initially hostile and evasive toward Bronwyn, viewing her as a threat to Simon's memory. Their relationship pivots when Janae finally shares Simon's secrets with Bronwyn, making Bronwyn the recipient of the truth that breaks the case open.

Jake Riordan

Janae's testimony and the information she withheld are ultimately what expose Jake as the true murderer. She has no direct alliance with Jake; he is the antagonist whose guilt her evidence helps confirm.

Addy Prentiss

Addy was one of Simon's intended targets and Jake's girlfriend — two facts that make her a figure Janae regards with complicated feelings. Janae's eventual honesty indirectly frees Addy from Jake's control.

Nate Macaulay

Nate is among the Bayview Four whom Janae initially views with suspicion as a suspect. Her distrust of him reflects her broader guardedness toward anyone she perceives as threatening Simon's legacy.

Cooper Clay

Cooper is another of the four suspects Janae watches warily. Simon had planned to out Cooper's secret, underscoring the destructive reach of Simon's schemes and deepening Janae's eventual disillusionment.

Maeve Rojas

Maeve's investigative energy alongside Bronwyn helps pressure Janae toward disclosure. Maeve represents the outside perspective that refuses to let Simon's narrative go unchallenged.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Janae Norman

Who is Janae Norman's best friend in One of Us Is Lying?

Simon Kelleher is Janae's best and only true friend at Bayview High. She ran his gossip app, About That, on his behalf, kept his secrets, and was so defined by their friendship that protecting his memory after his death became her entire purpose. By the novel's end, she is forced to accept that Simon's revenge scheme exploited her loyalty without her knowledge, reframing the friendship as far more asymmetrical than she had understood.

Why does Janae Norman delete the About That app data after Simon dies?

Janae deletes the data to protect Simon's memory, not to conceal a crime she committed. She views the app's contents as something sacred between her and Simon and refuses to let strangers pick through it. The act is rooted in love rather than self-interest, but it places her in a moral grey zone by making her complicit in obstructing the investigation into his death.

Does Janae Norman have a famous quote in One of Us Is Lying?

No specific lines of dialogue are attributed to Janae in the recorded material for this study guide. Her impact on the novel is conveyed primarily through her actions — deleting the app data, her hostility toward Bronwyn, and her eventual confession — rather than through a single memorable quotation.

How does Janae Norman's relationship with Bronwyn Rojas change over the course of the novel?

Janae begins as openly hostile and evasive toward Bronwyn, treating her as a threat to Simon's memory. The relationship pivots at the novel's emotional turning point, when Janae chooses to confide in Bronwyn and share Simon's secrets, including details about his revenge scheme. That decision transforms Bronwyn from adversary to confidante, and gives the Bayview Four the crucial context needed to expose Jake Riordan.

What role does Janae Norman play in exposing Jake Riordan?

Janae provides the testimony and withheld information that ultimately confirm Jake as Simon's true killer. There is a quiet irony in this outcome: Janae spent most of the novel trying to shield Simon's reputation, yet the truth she finally chooses to tell is exactly what vindicates Simon's supposed victims and condemns the actual murderer.

Is Janae Norman a villain in One of Us Is Lying?

Janae is not a villain; she is better understood as a foil who illustrates what blind loyalty to Simon looks like from the inside. She obstructs justice but without any intent to harm; her motivation is grief and devotion rather than malice. McManus uses her to distinguish moral complicity from legal guilt, and her arc ends in courageous honesty rather than further wrongdoing.

How does Janae Norman feel when she learns Simon may have used her unknowingly?

Learning that Simon's scheme manipulated her loyalty without her knowledge is the novel's most brutal moment for Janae. Her grief does not disappear but becomes more complicated, edged with betrayal and a disorienting reassessment of everything she believed their friendship meant — including the unsettling question of whether she ever truly knew him.

What is Janae Norman's motivation throughout One of Us Is Lying?

Janae's central motivation is preservation: of Simon's memory, of the meaning of their friendship, and of her own identity, which was tightly wound around his. This protectiveness is fierce but ultimately self-deceiving, because it requires her to ignore Simon's cruelty toward others and to obstruct an investigation into his death. Her growth lies in finally choosing truth over that protective loyalty.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Loyalty as self-deception

    Argue that Janae's protectiveness of Simon is not purely altruistic but also a way of avoiding examination of her own isolation. What does Simon's friendship give Janae that makes scrutiny of him feel existentially threatening?

  • The ethics of posthumous truth

    McManus uses Janae to ask whether the dead are owed protection from disclosure. Build a thesis around how the novel ultimately answers this question through Janae's decision to speak.

  • Foil to the Bayview Four

    Janae is also a social outsider, but her exclusion differs qualitatively from Bronwyn's, Cooper's, Addy's, and Nate's. Analyse how her outsider status is rooted in chosen allegiance rather than circumstance, and what that distinction reveals about identity at Bayview High.

  • Complicity without guilt

    Janae obstructs justice without intending harm. Examine how McManus distinguishes moral complicity from legal guilt, using Janae as the novel's central case study.

  • Grief as distortion

    Track how Janae's mourning actively warps her perception of events, other characters, and Simon himself. What does the novel suggest about the reliability of grief-driven narration and loyalty?

One of Us Is Lying

Continue

Full study guide →