What happens in Chapter 17 of Number the Stars?
Chapter 17, "All This Long Time," acts as the novel's poignant conclusion. The war in Europe is over—it’s 1945, two years after that terrifying night of escape—and Annemarie Johansen reflects on all that has been lost and what still remains. She discovers that her sister Lise wasn’t the victim of a random accident, as she had been led to believe, but was actually killed by German soldiers after being found out as a member of the Resistance. This revelation changes everything Annemarie thought she knew about her family's history. She retrieves the Star of David necklace belonging to Ellen Rosen, which she has kept hidden since that fateful night, and decides to wear it until Ellen returns to Copenhagen. The chapter ends with Annemarie's father telling her that the Danish Jews are coming home, and as she steps outside with the necklace fastened around her neck, she prepares to wait.
Analysis
Lowry shapes this final chapter as a moment of reflection—the title, inspired by a line about lasting love, hints that the novel's emotional impact has been building toward this point of truth. The news of Lise's death is shared with typical restraint: there’s no over-the-top drama, just a simple factual correction that quietly resonates in the reader's heart. This is Lowry's most intentional choice—holding back the truth until the reader, like Annemarie, has truly felt the weight of the sadness.
The Star of David necklace, a recurring symbol since Ellen placed it in Annemarie's hand, completes its journey here. Annemarie's decision to wear it signifies not appropriation but solidarity and promise—it's a tangible expression of the novel's core message that courage isn't about the absence of fear but about acting in spite of it. Lowry emphasizes this through Papa's retelling of the fairy tale logic that has shaped the story: ordinary people accomplishing extraordinary deeds in everyday circumstances.
The tone shifts from tension to a more subdued sense of hope—grief intertwined with anticipation. The writing slows down, sentences become shorter, and the domestic details (the apartment, the necklace clasp, the doorstep) anchor the abstract emotional resolution in something tangible. Lowry relies on imagery rather than statements, allowing the necklace to carry the thematic weight that a less skilled writer might have placed in dialogue.
Key quotes from Chapter 17
“So now I will tell you about my friend Ellen, who was one of those people.”
Annemarie's father explains that Lise and her Resistance comrades were exactly the kind of ordinary, brave people the novel has been quietly celebrating all along.
“When Ellen comes back, I will give it to her. And I will tell her that I have kept it safe for her, all this long time.”
Annemarie holds Ellen's Star of David necklace and makes her private vow, the novel's emotional and thematic resolution condensed into a single act of faithful waiting.
“She reached up and touched the little pendant at her throat: the Star of David that had once been Ellen's.”
The closing image of the novel, in which Annemarie steps outside wearing the necklace, completing the symbolic transfer of courage and solidarity between the two friends.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit a message.
Create an accountSign in