Skip to content
Storgy

Moby-DickNovel by Herman Melville

Chapter 56: Of the Less Erroneous Pictures of Whales, and the True Pictures of Whaling Scenes.

56 of 136 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Chapter 56 of Moby-Dick?

The narrator reviews various published images of whales and whaling scenes, offering critical ratings. Among the four known outlines of the Sperm Whale—created by Colnett, Huggins, Frederick Cuvier, and Beale—Beale's stands out as the best overall, particularly his frontispiece depicting boats attacking Sperm Whales, which is commended for being "admirably correct and life-like." Scoresby's outlines of the Right Whale are criticized for being drawn at too small a scale, and his having only one picture of whaling scenes is called a "sad deficiency." The narrator highlights two large engravings by a painter named Garnery as the finest whaling illustrations available. The first shows a Sperm Whale surfacing beneath a boat, splintering its planks, with crew members scattered in the water and the ship looming in the background. The second features a Right Whale swimming alongside a boat, with a becalmed ship and a dead whale visible in the contrasting background. The narrator praises the French for their skill in capturing dynamic scenes, contrasting them with English and American artists who settle for mechanical outlines. Scoresby is lightly mocked for filling his book with engravings of tools and enlarged snow crystals instead of lively whaling scenes. Lastly, two engravings by "H. Durand" are mentioned: one depicts a peaceful Pacific noon with a French whaler at anchor, while the other captures a lively cutting-in scene with a Right Whale next to a ship and a boat in pursuit.

Analysis

This chapter takes readers on a tour of artistic achievements, beginning with lesser works and culminating in a detailed ekphrasis—a verbal depiction of visual art. The narrator speaks with the authority of a knowledgeable critic, succinctly ranking artists with statements like, "by great odds, Beale's is the best," before pausing to delve into rich descriptions of Garnery's two engravings. The differences between the two scenes by Garnery serve as a lesson in pictorial composition: the first bursts with chaotic action—a shattered boat, an oarsman in mid-leap, and a disarrayed crew—while the second contrasts this turmoil with "the glassy level of a sea becalmed" in the background, featuring a dead whale likened to "a conquered fortress, with the flag of capture lazily hanging." This structural juxtaposition reinforces the chapter's main point that exceptional whaling art needs to balance dynamism with tranquility.

The narrator’s tone transitions from a dry listing of facts to genuine excitement when discussing Garnery, then shifts to a humorous critique of Scoresby, who is ridiculed for his "ninety-six fac-similes of magnified Arctic snow crystals" and the imagined requirement for "a sworn affidavit taken before a Greenland Justice of the Peace." The chapter also introduces a theme of national character by contrasting the picturesque nature of French art with the more mechanical literalism found in English and American works. The comparison of the English and American draughtsmen's vacant whale profiles to "sketching the profile of a pyramid" effectively sums up this critique. Throughout, the narrator's self-deprecating remark—"for the life of me, I could not draw so good a one"—adds a relatable touch to the critical voice.

Key quotes from Chapter 56

  • “by far the finest, though in some details not the most correct, presentations of whales and whaling scenes to be anywhere found, are two large French engravings, well executed, and taken from paintings by one Garnery.”

    The narrator introduces Garnery's engravings as the pinnacle of whaling art, surpassing all other published pictures.

  • “the successive armed kings and Emperors dash by, like a charge of crowned centaurs?”

    The narrator compares the battle paintings at Versailles to Garnery's sea pieces, praising French painters for capturing action.

  • “with the microscopic diligence of a Leuwenhoeck submits to the inspection of a shivering world ninety-six fac-similes of magnified Arctic snow crystals.”

    The narrator satirises Scoresby's book for filling space with scientific minutiae rather than living whaling scenes.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01Which artist does the narrator judge to have produced the best published outlines of the Sperm Whale?
  2. 02What specific fault does the narrator find with Scoresby's Right Whale outline pictures?
  3. 03In Garnery's first engraving, where exactly is the oarsman standing at the moment depicted?
  4. 04How does the narrator characterise the background of Garnery's second engraving, contrasting it with the foreground?
  5. 05What does the narrator say the English and American whale draughtsmen are chiefly content to present?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in