Skip to content
Storgy

Bleak HouseNovel by Charles Dickens

Chapter XLII

42 of 67 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Chapter XLII of Bleak House?

Mr. Tulkinghorn returns to his chambers in Lincoln's Inn Fields from Chesney Wold on a hot London evening, thinking about his aged port-wine. On his doorstep, he finds Mr. Snagsby, the stationer, waiting anxiously. Snagsby explains that Mademoiselle Hortense — the French maid he refers to as the "foreign female" who appeared the night Bucket and he brought the sweeping-boy — has been haunting his shop and hovering in his own court. She scared Guster into fits, insisted she would keep coming back until admitted to Tulkinghorn, and her constant presence risks stirring up jealousy in Snagsby's wife. Tulkinghorn dismisses Snagsby with a promise to deal with the nuisance and tells him to send Hortense to him if she comes again. Tulkinghorn heads upstairs, muttering that he will be "short with this jade." Almost immediately, Hortense herself arrives. She accuses Tulkinghorn of using her — enticing her to come in her own dress, the one she believes her Lady wore that night, to meet the boy — and treating her poorly, paying her only two sovereigns, which she throws on the floor. She demands to be given a good position or employed to pursue and disgrace Lady Dedlock. Tulkinghorn responds with a chilly threat: if she visits him or Snagsby again uninvited, he will turn her over to the police, who will carry her through the streets strapped to a board and have her imprisoned. Hortense leaves defiantly, and Tulkinghorn goes down to his cellar, retrieves his cobweb-covered bottle, and settles in to enjoy his wine beneath the pointing Roman figure on the ceiling.

Analysis

The chapter centers on a single setting—Tulkinghorn's dreary chambers and their entrance—along with two consecutive confrontations that together expose the lawyer's tactics and weaknesses. Dickens starts with a vivid simile likening Tulkinghorn to "a dingy London bird," smoke-stained and worn, existing among people but not engaging with them, aged without the warmth of youth. This image of dryness reappears in the "oven made by the hot pavements" and in his craving for fifty-year-old port-wine, establishing dryness as a central theme for his character.

The chapter has a three-part structure: the atmospheric arrival, the comic yet pathetic interaction with Snagsby, and the tense encounter with Hortense. The Snagsby scene offers comic relief through his anxious rambling, his hat shielding his face, and his repeated cough "of general application," while also hinting that Hortense is already lurking nearby. The confrontation with Hortense escalates quickly, depicted through vivid physical details—her "feline" demeanor, the coins thrown forcefully to the floor, her nearly foaming rage—contrasting with Tulkinghorn's measured key-tapping and nose-blowing. The cellar-key serves a dual purpose: it provides literal access to wine while symbolizing the looming threat of prison keys. Power shifts subtly; Tulkinghorn is startled and retreats at Hortense's sudden behavior, marking the only moment in the chapter where he loses his composure. The Roman figure on the ceiling, seen twice—first in the dark and then as Tulkinghorn drinks—frames the chapter with an image of relentless, unavoidable pointing, reflecting Hortense's persistent pressure on the lawyer.

Key quotes from Chapter XLII

  • “dwelling among mankind but not consorting with them, aged without experience of genial youth”

    The narrator's extended simile describing Tulkinghorn as he saunters home through Lincoln's Inn Fields.

  • “These women were created to give trouble the whole earth over. The mistress not being enough to deal with, here’s the maid now!”

    Tulkinghorn mutters this to himself after dismissing Snagsby and before discovering Hortense at his door.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01Why does Mr. Snagsby come to wait on Mr. Tulkinghorn's doorstep?
  2. 02What does Mademoiselle Hortense do with the two sovereigns Tulkinghorn says he paid her?
  3. 03What does Mademoiselle Hortense demand from Tulkinghorn during their confrontation?
  4. 04What specific threat does Tulkinghorn use to try to deter Hortense from returning?
  5. 05What is Tulkinghorn doing at the very end of the chapter after Hortense has left?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in

Vocabulary in Chapter XLII

1 word from this chapter, defined in the sense Bleak House uses.

impenetrabilities
The quality of being impossible to penetrate, understand, or get through; a complete resistance to being read, questioned, or figured out.

All vocabulary in Bleak House →