Skip to content
Storgy

A Passage to IndiaNovel by E. M. Forster

Part II, Chapter XIX

19 of 37 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Part II, Chapter XIX of A Passage to India?

The chapter follows Fielding as he navigates a series of encounters on the day Aziz is arrested. He first sees Hamidullah outside the Superintendent's office, offering reassurance, though he feels let down by the barrister's cautious, policy-focused reaction to the crisis. They talk about bail and the choice of defense lawyer; Hamidullah pushes for Amritrao, a Calcutta barrister known for his anti-British stance, while Fielding fears this might heighten racial tensions. As a messenger rides from the Superintendent to the Magistrate, Fielding urges Hamidullah to keep things simple. They part on a more personal note, with Hamidullah directly asking if Fielding is "on our side against your own people," to which Fielding responds, "Yes. Definitely." Fielding realizes that by taking a stand he will now be labeled "anti-British" and "seditious," and he regrets taking sides, since those labels bore him and lessen his usefulness. The section concludes with a long, disorienting conversation with Professor Godbole, who has come to ask Fielding for a name suggestion for a school he plans to open in Mau. When pressed for his thoughts on Aziz's guilt or innocence, Godbole launches into a philosophical discussion: since nothing can happen in isolation, the wrongdoing in the Marabar Hills involved Aziz, the guide, Fielding, Godbole himself, his students, and even the English lady. He describes good and evil as different facets of his Lord, then suddenly shifts the topic to Marabar antiquities and shares a legend about the Tank of the Dagger. Later, Fielding visits Aziz in prison, but all Aziz says is, "You deserted me." Fielding then sits down to write a letter to Miss Quested, reflecting that she is too sensible and kind-hearted to have made a false accusation.

Analysis

The chapter unfolds as a triptych of conversations—first with Hamidullah, then Godbole, and finally a brief prison visit—each encounter complicating Fielding's urge for clear, decisive action. The narrative closely follows Fielding, with his internal thoughts shaping each interaction: Hamidullah's delays, Godbole's philosophical evasions, and Aziz's sharp accusation all deepen Fielding's sense of isolation.

Fielding's isolation serves as the chapter's central theme. McBryde's earlier warning—"If you leave the line, you leave a gap in the line"—is referenced and proven true: once Fielding aligns himself with the Indian side, he becomes acutely aware of "the profundity of the gulf that divided him from them." His choice is presented in a stark exchange of brief sentences ("Yes. Definitely."), contrasting sharply with the elaborate hedging of those around him.

The scene with Godbole shifts the chapter from practical matters to metaphysics. Godbole's assertion—that the evil action "was performed by Dr. Aziz… by the guide… by you… by me… by my students… by the lady herself"—serves as the philosophical apex of the chapter, with its rhythmic repetition of "It was performed by" embodying the universality it discusses. Fielding's frustrated paraphrase—"everything is anything and nothing something"—highlights the clash between Western empiricism and Hindu philosophy. The tale of the Tank of the Dagger, culminating in a cow, deflates the metaphysical moment with a dose of reality, a tonal shift that Forster employs to prevent Godbole from becoming merely prophetic. The temple bell jangling "harshly" and the dust enveloping the official messenger create an atmosphere of relentless, impersonal machinery that renders individual goodwill seem insignificant.

Key quotes from Part II, Chapter XIX

  • ““Good-bye, my dear Fielding, and you actually are on our side against your own people?” “Yes. Definitely.””

    Hamidullah asks Fielding directly where his loyalties lie as they part outside the Superintendent's office.

  • “absence implies presence, absence is not non-existence, and we are therefore entitled to repeat, ‘Come, come, come, come.”

    Godbole concludes his account of good and evil as different aspects of his Lord near the end of his philosophical speech to Fielding.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01Why does Hamidullah suggest hiring Amritrao rather than a local lawyer?
  2. 02What does McBryde mean by his remark, 'If you leave the line, you leave a gap in the line'?
  3. 03What is the ostensible reason Professor Godbole comes to Fielding's office?
  4. 04According to Godbole's philosophy, how does suffering differ from good and evil?
  5. 05What is Aziz's only coherent remark when Fielding visits him in prison?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in

Vocabulary in Part II, Chapter XIX

1 word from this section, defined in the sense A Passage to India uses.

propitiation
The act of appeasing or winning the favor of someone who might be hostile or offended; doing something to calm or please a potentially angry person.

All vocabulary in A Passage to India →