Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · relatively decent master Douglass works for after leaving Covey

Mr. Freeland

in Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass by Frederick Douglass

Mr. William Freeland is the slaveholder with whom Douglass begins living on January 1, 1834, after enduring a year under the harsh Mr. Covey. Douglass characterizes Freeland as "what would be called an educated southern gentleman," who, unlike Covey, shows "some regard for honor, some reverence for justice, and some respect for humanity." Freeland provides his workers with adequate food, allows them enough time to eat, limits their working hours to sunrise and sunset, and supplies good tools — conditions Douglass describes as "heavenly, compared with what I experienced at the hands of Mr. Edward Covey." Freeland does not pretend to be religious, which Douglass sees as a genuine benefit, especially when contrasted with the hypocritical piety of neighboring masters. He personally owns only two slaves, Henry Harris and John Harris, while hiring the rest of his workforce, including Douglass and Sandy Jenkins. Douglass regards him as "the best master I ever had, till I became my own master," yet even this relative kindness does not quell Douglass's growing desire for freedom. By early 1835, Freeland has hired Douglass for another year, but Douglass is already organizing his fellow slaves for an escape attempt. When the plan is uncovered and the conspirators are arrested, Freeland comes to the door to call Douglass to the waiting constables and later goes to Easton jail to collect the other enslaved men — leaving Douglass behind.

About this character

Role
relatively decent master Douglass works for after leaving Covey
Form
Non-fiction
Author
Frederick Douglass
First published
1845

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Mr. Freeland?

Mr. William Freeland is a slaveholder living about three miles from St. Michael's. Douglass describes him as "an educated southern gentleman" who, while having "many of the faults peculiar to slaveholders, such as being very passionate and fretful," is "exceedingly free from those degrading vices to which Mr. Covey was constantly addicted." He owns Henry Harris and John Harris outright and hires additional workers, including Douglass, Sandy Jenkins, and Handy Caldwell. Importantly, he does not profess any religious beliefs — a characteristic Douglass views as a moral advantage, given his harsh criticism of religious slaveholders.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Mr. Freeland's arc and motivation?

Freeland serves more as a benchmark for comparing the cruelty of slavery than as a fully developed character. He is introduced in Chapter X specifically to contrast with Covey: whereas Covey is a "well-trained negro-breaker," Freeland is "open and frank." His relative decency is genuine enough that Douglass spends an entire year "without receiving a single blow," yet it changes nothing about the institution itself. By the end of 1834, Freeland hires Douglass for a second year — a typical act of slaveholding commerce that unintentionally provides Douglass with the time and community he needs to plan his escape.

03·Key moments

What are Mr. Freeland's key moments?

  • Arrival and contrast (Chapter X): Douglass arrives at Freeland's on January 1, 1834, and immediately notes the differences from Covey: adequate food, time to eat, work limited to sunrise-to-sunset, and good tools. This passage establishes Freeland as the book's clearest example of a "better" master who is still a master.
  • The Sabbath school (Chapter X): While at Freeland's, Douglass runs a secret Sunday school that at one point has over forty scholars, and besides it he spends three evenings a week during the winter teaching the slaves at home. Freeland does not appear to know about or interfere with this activity, but the school's secrecy highlights that even under a relatively decent master, the pursuit of literacy remains dangerous.
  • The arrest (Chapter X): When the escape plot is revealed, Freeland puts his head in at the kitchen door and calls Douglass by name, saying some gentlemen at the door wish to see him — a moment when his outward civility aids in the capture. Just before that call, Freeland had come back from the barn with Mr. Hamilton and met the three constables, and they all walked up to the kitchen door together.
  • Release from jail (Chapter X): After the holidays, Freeland goes to Easton jail with Mr. Hamilton and frees Charles, the two Henrys, and John — but leaves Douglass behind, an action Douglass interprets as branding him the ringleader to be sold as a warning.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Mr. Freeland's most important relationships?

Douglass's relationship with Freeland is the book's most complex master-slave dynamic. Douglass acknowledges him positively — "the best master I ever had, till I became my own master" — while emphasizing that good treatment within slavery does not equate to justice. The contrast with Covey is structural: Covey's violence shattered Douglass's body; Freeland's relative kindness and the community it fostered actually strengthened Douglass's resolve to escape. However, Freeland's involvement in the arrest scene, despite his mild demeanor, illustrates that even the most tolerable master is still a part of the slave system.

05·Connected characters

How is Mr. Freeland connected to the other characters?

Frederick Douglass

Freeland is Douglass's master for the years 1834 and 1835, and Douglass names him the best master he ever had while still enslaved, though Freeland's relative decency ultimately cannot satisfy Douglass's determination to be free.

Sandy Jenkins

Sandy Jenkins is one of the hired hands Freeland employs alongside Douglass, and is present at the farm when the escape plot is uncovered.

Master Thomas Auld

Freeland hires Douglass from Master Thomas Auld, making Auld the legal owner to whom Douglass is returned after the failed escape attempt.

Mr. Covey

Douglass consistently contrasts Freeland with Covey, his previous master, portraying Freeland as open, frank, and free from Covey's cruelty and deceit.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Mr. Freeland

How does Douglass compare Mr. Freeland to Mr. Covey?

Douglass portrays Freeland as someone who has "some regard for honor, some reverence for justice, and some respect for humanity," in stark contrast to Covey, who is "totally insensible to all such sentiments." He describes Freeland as "open and frank," while labeling Covey as "a most artful deceiver." Moreover, Freeland allows his workers adequate time for meals and restricts labor to the hours between sunrise and sunset, which Douglass describes as "heavenly" when compared to Covey's treatment.

Why does Douglass consider Freeland's lack of religion an advantage?

Douglass claims that "the religion of the south is a mere covering for the most horrid crimes" and describes religious slaveholders as "the meanest and basest, the most cruel and cowardly, of all others." He sees Freeland's lack of "pretensions to, or profession of, religion" as "truly a great advantage," especially when compared to nearby ministers like Rev. Weeden and Rev. Hopkins, who mixed showy piety with harsh treatment of their slaves.

What does Douglass say was the best thing about living at Freeland's?

Douglass calls Freeland the best master he ever had until he became his own master, but he says he was also indebted to the society of his fellow slaves for the ease with which he passed that year.

What role does Freeland play when the escape plot is discovered?

Freeland approaches the kitchen door and calls out for Douglass, saying there are "some gentlemen at the door who wished to see me." This effectively hands him over to the constables, who then proceed to tie him up and arrest him along with the other conspirators.

What happens after the conspirators are jailed in Easton?

After the holidays, Freeland heads to Easton with Mr. Hamilton and brings Charles, the two Henrys, and John home from jail, leaving Douglass behind. Douglass sees this as a sign that he will be sold as punishment for his role in the escape attempt.

How many slaves did Freeland own himself?

Freeland owned just two slaves, Henry Harris and John Harris. He hired the rest of his workforce, which included Douglass, Sandy Jenkins, and Handy Caldwell.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • The good master as ideological problem: How does Douglass use Freeland to argue that relative decency within slavery does not defend the institution but instead highlights its range of cruelties?

  • Religion and hypocrisy: Douglass praises Freeland's lack of religious profession and then contrasts this with the Rev. Weeden and Rev. Hopkins. What does this juxtaposition suggest about the relationship between Christianity and slaveholding?

  • Community and resistance: Freeland's farm is where Douglass forms deep connections with fellow slaves and organizes resistance. How does the relative stability Freeland provides paradoxically facilitate the escape plot?

  • The arrest scene as structural irony: Freeland's polite call to the kitchen door leads directly to Douglass's capture. How does Douglass use Freeland's behavior in this moment to demonstrate that civility and complicity are not opposites?

  • Naming and wordplay: Douglass mentions that he "began to want to live upon free land as well as with Freeland." What does this pun reveal about Douglass's evolving understanding of freedom?

Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass

Continue

Full study guide →