Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · town constable who gives evidence at Petty Sessions

Constable Stubberd

in The Mayor of Casterbridge by Thomas Hardy

Constable Stubberd is one of Casterbridge's two town constables, a minor but vividly comedic character who shows up in three brief scenes. In Chapter XXVIII, he provides evidence at Petty Sessions in front of Henchard and another magistrate, accusing a woman of being a disorderly female and causing a nuisance. His testimony is painstakingly slow—he’s memorized it and pauses at every comma to let the clerk catch up—leading Henchard to eventually lose patience with his roundabout way of speaking. In Chapter XXXIX, during the skimmington ride, Stubberd and his colleague are found hiding in an alley, too scared of the crowd to intervene. Pushed into action by the burgess Mr. Grower, he steps into Corn Street only to discover the procession has disappeared. He represents gentle satire: well-intentioned, procedural, and naturally hesitant to embrace danger. His role is functional rather than central, shedding light on both the operations of Casterbridge's petty authority and its limitations when confronted with public disorder.

About this character

Role
town constable who gives evidence at Petty Sessions
Form
Novel
Author
Thomas Hardy
First published
1886

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Constable Stubberd?

Constable Stubberd is one of the two town constables in Casterbridge. In Chapter XXXIX, he is described as one of a pair of "shrivelled men," hinting at his age and lack of physical presence. He serves a minor civic role—attending Petty Sessions to provide evidence and nominally tasked with maintaining order in the streets.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Constable Stubberd's arc and motivation?

Stubberd does not have a personal arc. He functions mainly to highlight the comical inadequacies of Casterbridge's official order. In Chapter XXVIII, his sole motivation is to fulfill his duty by delivering his sworn testimony accurately; by Chapter XXXIX, his focus shifts to self-preservation, which he justifies as concern for the community.

03·Key moments

What are Constable Stubberd's key moments?

Chapter XXVII: Henchard stands outside Lucetta's door and gives Stubberd a routine instruction about a hay wagon blocking the road, inquiring if there's a case the next day. Stubberd confirms there is one, establishing his role before the courtroom scene.

Chapter XXVIII: Stubberd is sworn in and delivers his evidence against the furmity-woman with painstaking care, pausing after each phrase to watch the clerk's pen. He has "got his evidence by heart," making the pauses inconsequential to him. The furmity-woman objects to his testimony at every turn, prompting Henchard to exclaim, "Say the words out like a man, and don't be so modest, Stubberd." The scene is comically absurd, with Stubberd casting a "suppressed gaze of victorious rectitude" at the woman when the bench rules in his favor on a point of admissibility.

Chapter XXXIX: During the skimmington ride, Stubberd and his colleague are caught "hiding up an alley" by burgess Mr. Grower. Stubberd protests that confronting the crowd would tempt it to commit _felo de se_ upon the two constables, and that they would not be the cause of a fellow-creature's death on any account. Grower organizes a pincer movement; Stubberd advances with him along Corn Street, but the procession has dispersed, and the participants are found innocently drinking in a tavern. When Stubberd attempts to identify one man, he is met with a calm denial.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Constable Stubberd's most important relationships?

Stubberd's most consistent interaction is with Henchard in his role as magistrate. Henchard's impatience with Stubberd's evasive language ("them cust dees and bees") contrasts sharply with Stubberd's meticulous adherence to procedure, portraying Henchard as a man of blunt force ill-suited for formal processes. With the furmity-woman, Stubberd holds nominal authority while she challenges his evidence on legal points; the bench must keep "a sharp look-out upon their procedure" because she has appeared in court more frequently than the magistrates themselves.

05·Connected characters

How is Constable Stubberd connected to the other characters?

Michael Henchard

Henchard, sitting as magistrate, hears Stubberd's evidence and grows impatient with his slow, over-careful delivery, eventually ordering him to speak plainly.

the furmity-woman

Stubberd brings the charge against the furmity-woman at Petty Sessions and gives sworn testimony about her disorderly conduct, which she repeatedly and shrewdly contests.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Constable Stubberd

What is Constable Stubberd's role in the courtroom scene?

In Chapter XXVIII, Stubberd takes the role of the arresting officer and sworn witness against the furmity-woman, accusing her of being a "disorderly female and nuisance." He presents his evidence piece by piece, pausing for the clerk's pen to catch up after each statement, having memorized the entire testimony.

Why does Henchard lose patience with Stubberd?

Henchard becomes annoyed with Stubberd's unwillingness to repeat the woman's exact insults, telling him to say the words out like a man and stop being so modest, or else leave it alone.

What does Stubberd do during the skimmington ride?

He and the other constable take cover in an alley to escape the crowd. When Mr. Grower discovers them, Stubberd insists that facing the mob would only incite violence, potentially leading to the deaths of those involved — a burden he claims he cannot carry.

Does Stubberd succeed in identifying the skimmington participants?

No. By the time he and Grower arrive at Corn Street, the procession has already broken up. When Stubberd tries to question a man he thinks he recognizes, the man coolly denies being there.

How does the furmity-woman challenge Stubberd's testimony?

She raises legal objections to his phrasing, arguing that a precise measurement provided under oath is "not sound testimony" and that words spoken outside her hearing shouldn't be considered evidence. This forces the magistrates to consult reference books and decide on each point.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Comic deflation of authority: How does Hardy use Stubberd to satirize the disparity between the pretensions of civic order and its actual power?

  • Language and class: What does the contrast between Stubberd's overly precise courtroom speech and Henchard's blunt vernacular reveal about authority and authenticity in Casterbridge?

  • The limits of the law: In Chapter XXXIX, the constables hide instead of taking action; in Chapter XXVIII, the furmity-woman nearly outmaneuvers Stubberd on procedural grounds. How does Hardy depict official law as ineffective throughout the novel?

  • Minor characters as social texture: Though Stubberd never drives the plot, his scenes illuminate Casterbridge as a functioning community with its own institutions. What does this technique add to the novel's realism?

The Mayor of Casterbridge

Continue

Full study guide →