Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · caretaker at Howards End

Miss Avery

in Howards End by E. M. Forster

Miss Avery is the elderly caretaker of Howards End, a farm woman deeply connected to the land and with a rich personal history tied to the Howard family. She first startles Margaret during her initial visit to the empty house, quickly proving to be much more than just a hired hand. Taking matters into her own hands, she unpacks the Schlegels' stored furniture and arranges it throughout Howards End as if the house is already a lived-in home — an action that confuses Margaret but also feels almost prophetic. Miss Avery firmly insists, despite Margaret's objections, that Margaret is already living there and will return, a belief that turns out to be right. She is perceptive, quirky, and possesses a sharp wit along with a "high but unostentatious nobility." Having been a friend of the first Mrs. Wilcox, she recalls the Howard family fondly. However, she harbors a long-standing resentment toward the Wilcoxes after Evie returned her expensive wedding gift with a dismissive letter. At a critical moment in the novel, after Charles has struck Leonard Bast and Leonard lies dead on the gravel, she comes out of the house carrying the sword — the same sword that had been hung on the hall wall — and she later acknowledges that Charles used only the flat of the blade. Throughout the story, she acts as a guardian spirit of Howards End, representing the continuity of the place and its older, rural England.

About this character

Role
caretaker at Howards End
Form
Novel
Author
E. M. Forster
First published
1910

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Miss Avery?

Miss Avery is a woman from the older rural England, deeply connected to the Howard family and Howards End itself. She isn't just a servant; as Margaret observes in Chapter 33, her wrinkles were "shrewd and humorous" and she looked "capable of scathing wit and also of high but unostentatious nobility." Henry Wilcox brushes her off as part of the "uneducated classes" and "just one of the crew at the farm" (Chapter 24), yet the novel consistently values her judgment over his. Eccentric—Dolly even calls her "dotty"—her quirks seem purposeful and prophetic.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Miss Avery's arc and motivation?

Miss Avery's driving force is her loyalty to the place and the memory of the first Mrs. Wilcox. She loved Ruth Wilcox and the Howard family, viewing Howards End as belonging to that tradition rather than to the Wilcoxes. When the Schlegel furniture arrives, she unpacks it with care, arranging the house as a home because she believes Margaret truly belongs there—"You are living here now" (Chapter 33). Her journey isn't about change but about a steadfast and quiet insistence: she acts, waits, and ultimately finds vindication.

03·Key moments

What are Miss Avery's key moments?

  • Chapters 23 and 24: Miss Avery surprises Margaret during her first visit to the empty house, having left the keys in the front lobby without explanation. It's later revealed that she once turned down a marriage proposal from Tom Howard, the last of the family.
  • Chapter 32: Dolly mentions that Miss Avery has been unpacking the Schlegels' belongings and arranging the furniture, which also brings to light her heated argument with Evie over a returned pendant.
  • Chapter 33: In a pivotal moment, Miss Avery has furnished the entire house—hall, parlour, dining-room, nursery—with the Schlegel belongings. She shows Margaret around, places Tibby's bassinet in what she calls "the nursery," and tells her directly, "You think that you won't come back to live here, Mrs. Wilcox, but you will." She fondly recalls the first Mrs. Wilcox and takes pleasure in mocking the Wilcox men's hay fever.
  • Chapter 40: At night, Miss Avery crosses the lawn, passing through a gap in the hedge that Mr. Wilcox had filled, following the old path he had previously covered—this small detail symbolizes the land reclaiming itself against his changes.
  • Chapter 41: In a moment of crisis, Miss Avery emerges from the house carrying the sword—the same sword she had hung on the wall—saying, "Yes, murder's enough."
  • Chapter 43: After Leonard's death, Miss Avery stays calm but murmurs tenderly that no one ever told the lad he would have a child, and Margaret takes this, with Helen's calm, as a reminder that horror is not the final word.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Miss Avery's most important relationships?

Miss Avery's most significant relationship is with the late Ruth Wilcox and, through her, with the house itself. She shares with Margaret that she "never saw much of Ruth after her grandmother died, but we stayed civil," recalling the Howard family's warmth and kindness (Chapter 33). Her relationship with Margaret is marked by wary mutual respect: Margaret initially intends to correct Miss Avery's presumptions but finds it difficult to dismiss her. Miss Avery's disdain for the Wilcoxes stems from the Evie incident and a deeper sense that they don't belong to the land as the Howards did. Her treatment of Charles—remembered laughing at his hay fever while he tried to instruct the farm lads—captures this contempt perfectly.

05·Connected characters

How is Miss Avery connected to the other characters?

Mrs. Wilcox

Miss Avery was an old friend of the first Mrs. Wilcox and remembers her with clear affection, speaking of her family's civility and hospitality. She arranges the Schlegel furniture at Howards End partly out of love for Mrs. Wilcox's house.

Margaret Schlegel

Miss Avery acts as Margaret's unsolicited but eerily perceptive guide to Howards End, unpacking her furniture, prophesying her return, and ultimately being present at the catastrophe that seals Margaret's fate there.

Mr. Wilcox

Henry tolerates Miss Avery because she is useful, overlooking her rudeness to his daughter just as he overlooks other servants' faults for the sake of good value.

Evie Wilcox

Miss Avery gave Evie a costly enamel pendant as a wedding gift; Evie returned it with a dismissive letter, provoking Miss Avery to write a furious reply and throw the pendant into the duckpond, leaving a lasting bitterness.

Charles Wilcox

Miss Avery regards Charles with sardonic amusement, recalling how his hay fever humiliated him in the hayfields, and she is in the house when he strikes Leonard Bast with the sword, coming out with it moments later.

Leonard Bast

Miss Avery is in the house when Leonard arrives and is present at his death; she murmurs tenderly, 'No one ever told the lad he'll have a child,' showing unexpected compassion for him.

Helen Schlegel

Miss Avery sends milk to Helen during her stay at Howards End and lights a fire for her and Margaret on the morning of Leonard's death, quietly serving the women without question.

The evidence06

06·Key quotes

What are Miss Avery’s key quotes?

“Yes, murder’s enough,” said Miss Avery, coming out of the house with the sword.”

Miss Avery · Chapter 41

Why it matters

Miss Avery delivers these words at the end of Chapter 41, stepping out of Howards End with the sword after Charles Wilcox has fatally struck Leonard Bast. This line serves as the novel's clearest moral judgment on the incident. Miss Avery, the elderly countrywoman who has protected Howards End and previously confused Margaret for Ruth Wilcox, speaks with the weight of someone deeply connected to the land and its history. Her use of the word "murder" cuts through the Wilcox family's efforts to label Leonard's death as heart disease, and it foreshadows the inquest's manslaughter verdict that ultimately leads to Charles's downfall.

Study07–08

07·Questions

Questions readers ask about Miss Avery

Why does Miss Avery unpack and arrange all the Schlegel furniture?

The novel doesn't provide a clear reason, but Miss Avery tells Margaret, "You are living here now," and refers to the house as part of the legacy of the first Mrs. Wilcox, whom she cherished. Margaret later tells Helen that Miss Avery "loved Mrs. Wilcox, and would rather furnish her house with our things than think of it empty" (Chapter 37).

What is the history between Miss Avery and the Howard family?

Dolly shares that Miss Avery was friends with the grandmother of the first Mrs. Wilcox back when Howards End was just a farm, and she turned down a marriage proposal from Tom Howard, the last of the family (Chapter 24). Miss Avery herself remembers being "civil" to Ruth Wilcox after the grandmother passed away and fondly recalls the hospitality of the Howard family (Chapter 33).

What happened between Miss Avery and Evie Wilcox?

Miss Avery gifted Evie an expensive enamel pendant (valued at over five pounds, purchased from a Bond Street shop) for her wedding. However, Evie, influenced by the Wilcox men who claimed it would be socially unacceptable to accept a gift from a farm woman, sent it back along with what she thought would be a lighthearted letter. In response, Miss Avery wrote back angrily and ultimately tossed the pendant into the duckpond (Chapter 32).

Is Miss Avery presented as mad or merely eccentric?

The novel challenges the notion of madness. When Margaret examines her closely, she notes "no maundering old woman" but rather someone with "shrewd and humorous" wrinkles, who "looked capable of scathing wit and also of high but unostentatious nobility" (Chapter 33). Although Dolly calls her dotty and her niece calls her eccentric, the narrative consistently supports her insights.

What is the significance of Miss Avery bringing out the sword in Chapter 41?

When Charles has struck Leonard Bast and Leonard lies dead on the gravel, she steps out of the house holding the sword—the very one that had hung on the wall in the hall—declaring, "Yes, murder's enough." Later, she admits that Charles only used the flat of the blade (Chapter 42). Her appearance with the sword during this act of violence connects her to the crisis in a way that the novel hints at but doesn't fully explain.

How does Miss Avery treat Margaret compared with the Wilcoxes?

She shows respect and warmth toward Margaret, always calling her "Mrs. Wilcox" and insisting that she has a rightful place at Howards End. In contrast, she is sardonic with the Wilcoxes: she makes fun of Charles's hay fever, suggests that the Wilcox men "breed like rabbits," and her lingering resentment over Evie's letter influences her view of the entire family.

What does Miss Avery's track through the hedge in Chapter 40 suggest?

The narrative points out that an old gap Mr. Wilcox had previously filled has come back, and Miss Avery's path through the dew follows the trail he had turfed when he worked on the garden. Her movement literally retraces what he removed, connecting her to the earlier history of the place in contrast to his changes.

08·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Miss Avery as prophetic figure

    How does her insistence that Margaret is "living here now" at Howards End serve as prophecy, and what does the novel suggest about the connection between place and destiny?

  • The sword as symbol

    Miss Avery hangs the sword on the wall and later carries it out during a moment of violence; what does her relationship with this object reveal about her role in the novel's moral framework?

  • Old England versus new

    Miss Avery represents a rural continuity that the Wilcoxes have displaced; how does the novel use her character to critique Wilcox values?

  • Female eccentricity and social dismissal

    Both Henry and Dolly regard Miss Avery as an eccentric old maid; how does the novel challenge their dismissal and to what effect?

  • The gap in the hedge

    The reappearance of the old path through the hedge in Chapter 40 connects directly to Miss Avery's movements; how does Forster use landscape details to align her with the deeper history of the place?

Howards End

Continue

Full study guide →