Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · French soldier killed by Paul in a shell-hole

Gérard Duval

in All Quiet on the Western Front by Erich Maria Remarque

Gerard Duval is a French soldier who appears only briefly in the novel, yet his presence carries enormous moral weight. In Chapter IX he falls into the shell-hole where Paul is hiding during an attack, and Paul stabs him at once, then lies trapped beside him for hours until he dies. He is a French compositor who falls into Paul's shell-hole during an attack in Chapter IX, where Paul stabs him and then lies beside him for hours while he dies. Paul sees him closely, with a small pointed beard, brown eyes and black hair, and finds photographs of a woman and a little girl in his pocket-book, so that the enemy becomes a man with a family and a trade. He functions less as a developed character than as a symbol of the anonymous human cost of war and of Paul's deepening moral crisis.

About this character

Role
French soldier killed by Paul in a shell-hole
Form
Novel
Author
Erich Maria Remarque
First published
1929

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Gérard Duval?

Gerard Duval is a French soldier whom Paul encounters in a shell-hole in Chapter IX. His pocket-book gives his trade as compositor and holds letters in French and photographs of a woman and a little girl taken against an ivy-clad wall. His significance is less individual than representative: he stands for the ordinary French working man — the blacksmith or shoemaker mentioned in Chapter IX — who, like Paul and his comrades, was given no choice about going to war.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Gérard Duval's arc and motivation?

Duval has no arc of his own: he falls into Paul's shell-hole, is stabbed, and dies there about three in the afternoon. His role is to serve as the human face of the enemy, making concrete the argument made in the soldiers' discussion in Chapter IX that French and German soldiers share the same class origins and the same powerlessness before the rulers who sent them to fight. His death at Paul's hands is the point at which the war's impersonal machinery becomes devastatingly personal.

03·Key moments

What are Gérard Duval's key moments?

In Chapter VI, the battle scenes show French soldiers being killed with spades, bayonets, and bare violence as the two sides collide. Duval meets Paul later, in Chapter IX, when Paul is alone on a night patrol and an enemy attack sweeps over the shell-hole where he lies. In Chapter IX, the question raised in the soldiers' discussion of why a French blacksmith or a French shoemaker would want to attack them reframes every French death, including Duval's, as a tragedy of class and political manipulation rather than genuine enmity.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Gérard Duval's most important relationships?

Within the story Duval meets only Paul Bäumer, though his pocket-book shows that he has a family at home. Paul kills him, and the act becomes the novel's most intimate dramatisation of the war's moral horror. In his speech to the dead man in Chapter IX, Paul says that he now sees Duval as a man like himself, a poor devil whose mother is just as anxious as Paul's, who could be his brother if they threw away their rifles and uniforms.

05·Connected characters

How is Gérard Duval connected to the other characters?

Paul Bäumer

Paul kills Duval in a shell-hole, an act that forces Paul into direct, personal confrontation with the human reality of the enemy he has been trained to destroy.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Gérard Duval

Who is Gerard Duval?

He is a French soldier killed by Paul Bäumer. He is a French compositor who falls into Paul's shell-hole during an attack in Chapter IX, and his letters and his photographs of a woman and a little girl show an ordinary man who, like the German soldiers, had no control over the decision to go to war.

Why does Paul kill Duval?

In Chapter IX Paul, lying alone in a shell-hole during an enemy attack, has resolved to stab anyone who jumps in, and when a body falls in on him he strikes out at once without thinking, out of terror rather than hatred.

What does Duval represent thematically?

In the soldiers' discussion in Chapter IX, it is argued that a French blacksmith or shoemaker has no personal motive to attack German soldiers, as the men on both sides were not asked about the war any more than the Germans were. Duval represents this viewpoint—he personifies an enemy who, in reality, is not an enemy at all.

Does the novel give Duval much individual characterisation?

Not much: Paul learns his name, his trade as a compositor and his looks, and sees photographs of a woman and a little girl, but his significance is more symbolic than personal, embodying the shared humanity of soldiers on both sides.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • How does Duval function as a symbol of the novel's argument that ordinary soldiers on both sides are victims of the same ruling-class decisions?

  • Explore the contrast between the impersonal mass violence of Chapter VI and the individual, face-to-face killing that Duval's death represents.

  • How does the question about the French blacksmith and shoemaker, raised in the soldiers' discussion in Chapter IX, recast the meaning of every enemy death shown in the novel?

  • Consider how learning Duval's name, trade and family turns an abstract enemy into a person for Paul, and how quickly that knowledge fades once he is back among his comrades.

All Quiet on the Western Front

Continue

Full study guide →