Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · the poor women the proposal calls breeders

the mothers

in A Modest Proposal by Jonathan Swift

In A Modest Proposal, the mothers referred to are the impoverished Irish women the Proposer labels as "breeders" — essentially, the biological and economic backbone of his plan. They first appear as a stark social reality: beggars filling the streets and roads, with ragged children in tow, unable to work because their time is consumed by begging for food. The Proposer estimates that about 170,000 of these women are actively having children among the poor, and it is the number of infants they produce each year that his proposal aims to exploit. Instead of being seen as individuals with their own voices, the mothers are depicted as mere units of productivity — evaluated based on how many children they lose, how effectively they nurse their infants before selling them, and how soon they are fit for work again after a child is sold. The proposal offers them an eight shilling "neat profit" for each child sold and relief from the costs of raising children after the first year. The Proposer also asserts that his plan will foster mothers' "care and tenderness" for their children and protect them from being abused by their husbands during pregnancy. These promises, framed in terms of economic gain and domestic improvement, form the satirical heart of the mothers' depiction: while their suffering is genuine, the text’s ironic tone transforms that suffering into a mere entry in a financial ledger.

About this character

Role
the poor women the proposal calls breeders
Form
Non-fiction
Author
Jonathan Swift
First published
1729

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is the mothers?

The mothers are impoverished Irish women depicted at the beginning of the text, begging on the streets and roads, "followed by three, four, or six children, all in rags." They cannot work for "their honest livelihood" because begging for their children's survival takes up all their time. The proposer adds a darker note, saying that women murdering their bastard children is all too frequent among them, and suggesting this practice is driven more by the expense than by the shame. From the very start, these mothers are characterized by economic hardship rather than moral failings.

02·Arc & motivation

What is the mothers's arc and motivation?

The mothers lack any personal development arc; they represent a social issue that the Proposer aims to address. Their motivation, as portrayed in the text, revolves around sheer survival — securing enough food and scraps through begging to keep their infants alive during the first year. The proposal promises to change their situation: instead of being a burden, each child turns into a source of eight shillings' profit, and the mother is "fit for work till she produces another child." The satirical undertone reveals that their "improvement" is merely about being exploited more effectively.

03·Key moments

What are the mothers's key moments?

  • Opening passage: The mothers are depicted as the most visible representation of Irish poverty — beggars accompanied by children, forced into "stroling to beg" instead of engaging in honest labor. This depiction lays the emotional foundation upon which the satire is built.
  • The arithmetic of breeders: The proposer counts 170,000 breeders among the poor after setting aside the thirty thousand couples able to maintain their own children, then subtracts fifty thousand for women who miscarry or whose children die within the year. The clinical language — "breeders," "dam," "dropt" — reduces the mothers to the status of livestock.
  • Nursing instructions: Mothers of the hundred thousand children to be sold are instructed "to let them suck plentifully in the last month, so as to render them plump, and fat for a good table." The nurturing instinct of mothers is redirected towards fattening a commodity.
  • The eight-shillings profit: The Proposer asserts that "the mother will have eight shillings neat profit, and be fit for work till she produces another child" — framing reproductive recovery as an economic advantage.
  • Increased care and tenderness: Among the supposed benefits of the proposal is that it "would encrease the care and tenderness of mothers towards their children" and that husbands would no longer beat or kick pregnant wives "for fear of a miscarriage." This passage reveals the violence that ordinary mothers face, even as it disguises that reality in the proposer's optimistic calculations.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are the mothers's most important relationships?

The most significant relationship for the mothers is with their children, whom they nurse and beg for, yet the proposal turns them into salable assets. The Proposer maintains a relationship with the mothers based on detached calculation: he never addresses them directly, refers to them in the third person, and evaluates their worth through fertility rates and nursing capabilities. Their relationship with landlords is indirect but revealing — the proposal notes that selling children could help tenants "pay their landlord's rent," positioning the mothers' and their children's bodies as resources for settling debts owed to those above them.

05·Connected characters

How is the mothers connected to the other characters?

the children of the poor

The mothers carry, nurse, and beg on behalf of their children; under the proposal, they are directed to suckle infants plentifully in the final month so as to fatten them for sale, and they receive eight shillings for each child sold.

the proposer

The Proposer regards the mothers primarily as breeders whose output can be quantified and sold; he calculates their numbers, prescribes their nursing behaviour, and frames their financial gain as a chief advantage of his scheme.

the landlords

The poorer tenants — among whom the mothers live — already have their corn and cattle seized by landlords; the proposal suggests the sale of children could help pay landlords' rent, making the mothers' reproductive labour indirectly tributary to landlord income.

the Irish poor

The mothers are the female subset of the Irish poor, sharing their destitution and their inability to find honest work or maintain their children.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about the mothers

How does the Proposer describe the mothers at the start of the text?

He describes them as women begging on the streets, roads, and in front of cabins, "followed by three, four, or six children, all in rags," who have to spend all their time begging for their infants instead of working for an honest livelihood.

What does the Proposer mean by calling the mothers 'breeders'?

He uses the term to categorize poor wives as a quantifiable group based on their reproductive output, counting about 170,000 breeders once the couples able to maintain their own children are set aside.

What financial benefit does the proposal offer the mothers?

The Proposer mentions that a mother will earn eight shillings as "neat profit" from selling each child's carcass for ten shillings, and she will no longer have to cover the child's maintenance costs after the first year.

What role do the mothers play in preparing children for sale?

The proposer advises mothers to let the children suck plentifully in the last month so as to render them plump and fat for a good table, guiding their nursing to increase the child's size as a food resource.

Does the proposal claim to improve the mothers' lives in any other way?

Yes — the Proposer claims that the scheme would enhance "the care and tenderness of mothers towards their children" and that husbands would refrain from beating or kicking their pregnant wives out of concern for causing a miscarriage.

What does the text reveal about violence against mothers?

In discussing the benefits of the proposal, the Proposer points out that men often beat or kick their wives during pregnancy, which is "too frequent a practice." The proposal aims to put an end to this behavior, as a pregnant wife symbolizes future profit.

Why does the Proposer reject the suggestion of also selling young girls aged twelve to fourteen?

He argues it would be "a loss to the publick, because they soon would become breeders themselves" — prioritizing young females mainly for their potential to reproduce instead of seeing them as food.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • The language of livestock

    Analyze how the proposer's terminology — "breeders," "dam," "dropt," "plump" — systematically dehumanizes the mothers, and what Swift's satire suggests about how English economic discourse viewed the Irish poor.

  • Suffering as spectacle vs. suffering as statistic

    The initial image of mothers begging in rags evokes pity; the subsequent calculations reduce them to mere numbers. Explore how Swift employs this transition to critique the coldness of projector-style reasoning.

  • The proposal's "benefits" to women

    The text claims to offer mothers profit, protection from domestic violence, and greater tenderness from husbands. Investigate how these promised improvements ironically catalog the actual conditions — poverty, violence, neglect — that the proposal fails to address.

  • Complicity and victimhood

    The mothers are both victims of colonial poverty and, within the framework of the proposal, complicit in the commodification of their children. Discuss how Swift uses this ambiguity to implicate the entire social structure.

A Modest Proposal

Continue

Full study guide →