What happens in Book V, Chapter XXXIX of A Farewell to Arms?
By mid-January, the narrator has grown a beard, and winter has fully enveloped the Swiss landscape. He and Catherine enjoy long walks on snow-packed roads leading to the Bains de l'Alliaz, pausing on logs to rest since Catherine tires easily during her pregnancy. At a dim, smoky inn nestled among the trees, woodcutters gather, and the couple sips hot spiced red wine known as glühwein. On their way home, they spot foxes twice, and the narrator shares how a fox curls its tail around itself to sleep. They chat lightly about chamois hunters with gold earrings, fantasize about having tails like foxes, and remark on how they rarely see anyone in this remote area. As they sit on logs to take a break, Catherine inquires whether their upcoming baby will create distance between them; the narrator reassures her it won’t. She asks about money, and he tells her they have plenty because the last sight draft was honored; she then asks about his family, whom he has not written to, contacting them only through the draft. He says their quarrels wore out his feelings for his family, and when she says she would probably like them, he changes the subject. As they walk home in the dark on squeaky snow, Catherine shares her intention not to cut her hair until after their baby—whom she calls "young Catherine"—is born, after which she plans to cut it short and become "a fine new and different girl." The chapter concludes with the narrator saying he loves her enough already and asking whether she wants to ruin him; Catherine says she does, and he answers that he wants that too.
Analysis
The chapter primarily relies on two styles: vivid, sensory descriptions of the landscape and intimate, playful dialogue. The opening paragraphs immerse us in a Swiss winter through detailed observations — packed snow, hay sleds, frost on horses' muzzles, and breath forming "plumes of frost in the air" — crafting a world that feels isolated and self-contained. This sense of enclosure is both thematic and visual: the couple has distanced themselves from war, family, and society into a secluded place "where nothing makes any difference."
The ensuing dialogue is intentionally light and meandering — touching on topics like foxes, earrings, and imaginary tails — yet each brief exchange subtly reveals the pressures they face. Catherine’s remark, "She won't come between us, will she? The little brat," introduces the unborn child as a potential threat to their seclusion, while the narrator’s flat response, "No. We won't let her," treats the baby as an intruder to resist rather than embrace. The discussion about his family mirrors this pattern: affection eroded by conflict, with communication reduced to financial transactions.
The beard serves as a recurring motif that unifies the chapter. It first appears as a sign of time passing, re-emerges in the initial dialogue (connecting the narrator to the chamois-hunting woodcutters), and comes back near the end when Catherine links it to her plan to cut her hair after the baby arrives. Both actions — growing and cutting — symbolize self-reinvention, and Catherine’s dream of becoming "a fine new and different girl" provides the emotional peak of the chapter. The closing exchange — "I want to ruin you" / "that's what I want too" — concludes with a note of intentional mutual surrender that is both tender and slightly foreboding.
Key quotes from Book V, Chapter XXXIX
“We live in a country where nothing makes any difference. Isn’t it grand how we never see any one?”
Catherine speaks to the narrator while they sit on logs resting during their walk home from the Bains de l'Alliaz.
“I’ll be a fine new and different girl for you. We’ll go together and get it cut, or I’ll go alone and come and surprise you.”
Catherine describes her plan to cut her hair after the baby is born, speaking to the narrator on the dark road home.
““Hell,” I said, “I love you enough now. What do you want to do? Ruin me?” “Yes. I want to ruin you.””
The narrator and Catherine exchange the chapter's closing words as they walk home through the cold night.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign inVocabulary in Book V, Chapter XXXIX
- hobnailed
- Boots with short metal nails hammered into the soles to give a firm grip on rocky or slippery mountain terrain.