What happens in Book V, Chapter XXXVIII of A Farewell to Arms?
The chapter begins with a poetic depiction of a couple's life in autumn, residing in a brown wooden house nestled among the pine trees overlooking a Swiss lake, cared for by their landlords, Mr. and Mrs. Guttingen. The narrator shares their daily routines: Mrs. Guttingen lights morning fires, they enjoy breakfasts in bed with views of the lake and the French mountains, stroll along the frost-hardened road or through the gentle pine forest, and spend afternoons reading books and playing card games from a copy of "Hoyle." Occasionally, they venture down to the villages of Chernex and Fontanivent, making their way to Montreux, where Catherine has her hair styled at a salon while the narrator sips dark Munich beer and reads newspapers filled with reports of war disasters. Afterward, seated at a corner table over beers, they discuss marriage; Catherine insists she won’t marry while visibly pregnant, vowing to do so once she is "thin again." She shares that she has learned marrying under American law will legitimize their child, and she expresses a desire to see the Golden Gate in San Francisco. They take the electric mountain railway, the M.O.B., back up to their chalet. Snow finally arrives three days before Christmas; they step out into the blizzard and seek refuge in a small inn by the station for some vermouths before returning for lunch. That afternoon, when Catherine asks if the narrator wants to go skiing with other men, he declines. They share deep conversations about the war, Rinaldi, past illnesses, and their longing to merge their identities. The chapter concludes with a moonlit night scene where Catherine tells the narrator she is "very, very, very happy" before they drift off to sleep.
Analysis
The chapter unfolds with a steady pastoral rhythm, where each paragraph reflects the routine of the seasons — morning fires, strolls, meals, card games, and trips to town — before the narrative takes a breath for dialogue. This gathering of domestic details fosters a feeling of protected time, emphasized by the contrasting forces of cold and warmth. Ice on pitchers, frost-hardened roads, and late-arriving snow stand in stark contrast to the roaring porcelain stove, cozy beer halls, and the warmed electric train, creating an intimacy for the couple that is literally insulated from the outside world.
The war only makes a peripheral appearance: the narrator comes across mentions of "disaster" in blacked-out newspapers and casually references Rinaldi and the priest in a brief, almost sleepy aside. His comment that "the war seemed as far away as the football games of some one else's college" captures the chapter’s tonal approach — a sense of distance achieved through domestic immersion.
Conversations about marriage are approached with Hemingway's typical indirection. Catherine's refusal is more practical and self-aware than emotional, and her research in the New York World Almanac empowers her. The discussion about hair — growing his and cutting hers — extends the chapter's theme of merging identities: "I want us to be all mixed up. I don't want you to go away… I don't live at all when I'm not with you."
The closing moonlit scene represents the chapter's most tranquil moment. The transition from the firelit warmth of the day to the cold moonlight and the shadows cast by window bars introduces a more delicate, fragile atmosphere, culminating in Catherine's declaration of happiness and the narrator's solitary wakefulness as he watches her sleep.
Key quotes from Book V, Chapter XXXVIII
“The war seemed as far away as the football games of some one else’s college.”
The narrator reflects at night on their life in the chalet, noting he follows the fighting only through newspapers.
““I want us to be all mixed up. I don’t want you to go away … I don’t live at all when I’m not with you.””
Catherine speaks to the narrator during their afternoon conversation by the stove while snow falls outside.
““I’m never that way any more. I’m grand now … I’m just very, very, very happy.””
Catherine speaks to the narrator after waking in the moonlit night, recalling how she was nearly crazy when they first met.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign in