Year 10-11 / Grades 9-10
Anne of Green Gables — a five-lesson scheme of work
This sequence guides students through Montgomery's novel by closely examining key moments that reflect Anne's emotional and social growth. Students start by analyzing how the author creates character voice in the chapters where Anne arrives, then look at the different approaches Marilla and Matthew take in raising her. The lessons in the middle focus on Anne's errors and how she deals with humiliation, highlighting the novel's blend of humor and real emotional depth. The sequence culminates in a comparative analytical essay where students identify a recurring pattern throughout the novel and discuss how Montgomery uses it to develop the theme. By the end, students are equipped to craft a well-reasoned argument about character development, backed by specific textual evidence.
Objectives
- Analyse how Montgomery uses dialogue and free indirect discourse to construct Anne's distinctive voice and establish reader sympathy
- Identify and evaluate contrasting parenting philosophies in Marilla and Matthew, supporting claims with embedded quotations
- Trace a recurring pattern of mistakes, punishment, and reconciliation across the novel, explaining how repetition deepens characterization
- Write an analytical paragraph that integrates quotations fluently and explains their significance to a larger argument
- Construct a comparative essay that tracks one element—ambition, imagination, friendship, or forgiveness—across multiple chapters and argues how it shapes theme
The sequence
Lesson 1: Anne's voice and the construction of sympathy
50 min · ch. 2, 3- Do now
Write down three details from Chapter II that tell us what Anne cares about most. Use the narrator's descriptions and Anne's own words.
- Teacher input
The teacher models close reading of Anne's monologue in Chapter II about her red hair: "I cannot imagine that red hair away. I do my best. I think to myself, 'Now my hair is a glorious black, black as the raven's wing.' But all the time I know it is just plain red and it breaks my heart." The teacher demonstrates annotating for tone, showing how the shift from imagination to reality builds pathos, and explains how Montgomery uses Anne's own vocabulary—glorious, breaks my heart—to establish her as both theatrical and genuinely vulnerable. The teacher contrasts this with the narrator's observation of Matthew in the same chapter: he feels he is "going to assist at murdering something" when he realizes Anne will be sent away. Students see how free indirect discourse lets us access Matthew's feelings without his speaking them aloud.
- Independent task
Students write one analytical paragraph responding to the question: How does Montgomery establish Anne as a sympathetic character in Chapters II and III? They must select one quotation from Anne's dialogue and one from the narrator's commentary, embed both with correct punctuation, and explain how each builds the reader's emotional investment. The paragraph should follow a claim-evidence-explanation structure and use formal academic tone.
- Exit ticket
Which moment in Chapter III—Anne's outburst that nobody ever wanted her, or the final line about the lonely child crying herself to sleep—creates stronger sympathy for Anne? Explain your choice in two sentences.
Lesson 2: Marilla and Matthew as contrasting caregivers
50 min · ch. 7, 10, 12- Do now
Reread the prayer scene at the end of Chapter VII. List what Marilla wants Anne to do, and what Anne actually does. What does the gap between those two things reveal?
- Teacher input
The teacher models analytical comparison using two passages. First, Marilla's response to Anne's unorthodox prayer in Chapter VII: after planning to teach the standard bedtime prayer, Marilla realizes it is not the right sort of prayer for Anne. The teacher shows how to unpack the significance of this moment—Marilla adapts her rigid plan when faced with Anne's individuality. Then the teacher examines Matthew's sudden remark to Marilla in Chapter III: "We might be some good to her." The teacher demonstrates how to link these moments thematically, arguing that Marilla disciplines while Matthew nurtures, and both roles are necessary. Students practice identifying which adult Anne turns to in different situations across these chapters.
- Independent task
Students create a two-column comparison chart tracking Marilla and Matthew's different approaches to raising Anne. For each adult, they find three quotations from Chapters VII, X, and XII that reveal their philosophy, then write a summary sentence explaining whose approach they believe Anne needs most at this stage of her development. Underneath, they write one paragraph explaining a moment where Marilla or Matthew changes their usual approach and why that change matters to Anne's growth.
- Exit ticket
At the end of Chapter XII, Marilla admits to Matthew she is glad they kept Anne. Does this admission reveal that Marilla is changing, or that we are finally seeing what she felt all along? Justify your answer.
Lesson 3: Comedy and consequence in Anne's mistakes
55 min · ch. 9, 14, 16- Do now
List three mistakes Anne makes between Chapters IX and XVI. For each one, note whether Anne is punished, and if so, how. Look for a pattern.
- Teacher input
The teacher models analysis of the liniment-cake incident in Chapter XXI, focusing on the moment Marilla discovers the mistake: "Mercy on us, Anne, you've flavored that cake with Anodyne Liniment." The teacher demonstrates how to analyze Montgomery's comic timing—the buildup of Anne's pride, the horror of discovery, Anne's mortification—and then shifts to examine Mrs. Allan's response. The teacher shows students how to track two effects at once: the scene is funny (we laugh at the absurdity) but also tender (Mrs. Allan comforts Anne). Students practice identifying the tonal shift at the end of the scene, when Anne, comforted by Mrs. Allan, tells Marilla that "tomorrow is a new day with no mistakes in it yet." The teacher links this to Anne's earlier mistakes with Mrs. Lynde and the brooch, showing how Montgomery uses a repeated structure—transgression, punishment, reconciliation—to build Anne's moral education without breaking our sympathy.
- Independent task
Students write two paragraphs analyzing one of Anne's mistakes: the confrontation with Mrs. Lynde in Chapter IX, the false confession about the brooch in Chapter XIV, or the currant-wine incident in Chapter XVI. The first paragraph explains what Anne does wrong and why, using embedded quotations. The second paragraph evaluates the adult response (from Mrs. Lynde, Marilla, or Mrs. Barry) and argues whether the punishment fits the offense. Students must explain what Anne learns—or fails to learn—from the consequence.
- Exit ticket
In Chapter XVI, Anne declares that even God struggles with such an obstinate person as Mrs. Barry. Is this line primarily comic, or does it reveal something serious about Anne's understanding of justice and forgiveness?
Lesson 4: Rivalry, pride, and the refusal to forgive
50 min · ch. 15, 28, 30- Do now
Reread the slate-cracking incident in Chapter XV and the bridge-pile scene in Chapter XXVIII. Write down the exact words Anne uses to reject Gilbert in each chapter. What stays the same?
- Teacher input
The teacher models close reading of the Lake of Shining Waters rescue in Chapter XXVIII, focusing on the moment Gilbert apologizes and Anne's cold refusal: "No," she said coldly, "I shall never be friends with you, Gilbert Blythe; and I don't want to be!" The teacher demonstrates how to connect this to the earlier moment in Chapter XV when Anne declares the iron has entered her soul. Students see that Anne's refusal is not a single impulsive act but a sustained choice. The teacher then introduces the passage from Chapter XXX where the narrator reveals Anne's hidden feelings: "Deep down in her wayward, feminine little heart she knew that she did care, and that if she had that chance of the Lake of Shining Waters again she would answer very differently." The teacher models how to analyze free indirect discourse here—we access Anne's private self-knowledge, something she will not admit aloud for years. Students discuss why Anne cannot forgive, even when she wants to.
- Independent task
Students write an analytical paragraph answering the question: Why does Anne refuse to forgive Gilbert for so long, even after her anger fades? They must integrate at least two quotations—one from Anne's dialogue and one from the narrator's insight in Chapter XXX—and explain what Anne's stubbornness reveals about her pride and her fear of appearing weak. They should consider whether Anne's refusal makes her more or less sympathetic as a character, and whether Montgomery presents it as a flaw or a strength.
- Exit ticket
The narrator describes Anne's heart as wayward and feminine in Chapter XXX. Do you think Montgomery intends those words as criticism or affection? What evidence supports your reading?
Lesson 5: From ambition to acceptance—Anne's final transformation
55 min · ch. 34, 36, 37, 38- Do now
List everything Anne gives up in Chapter XXXVIII. For each sacrifice, write down who or what she is choosing instead.
- Teacher input
The teacher models analysis of the final chapter, focusing on Anne's decision to refuse the Avery scholarship and stay at Green Gables. The teacher reads aloud the passage where Anne encounters Gilbert and finally speaks the words she has withheld for years: "I forgave you that day by the pond landing, although I didn't know it. What a stubborn little goose I was." The teacher demonstrates how to connect this moment of self-awareness to earlier scenes—the slate incident, the bridge rescue, the rivalry at Queen's—and argues that Anne's ability to name her own stubbornness marks her maturity. The teacher then examines the novel's closing image: Anne at her window, content because there is always the bend in the road, the image she used earlier in the chapter when she told Marilla she believes the best lies around it. Students discuss whether this ending is a defeat (she has narrowed her horizons) or a triumph (she has chosen love and duty). The teacher shows how both readings are supported by the text, and models how to construct an argument that acknowledges complexity rather than flattening it.
- Independent task
Students write a full comparative analytical essay (four to five paragraphs) responding to one of the following questions: (1) How does Anne's understanding of forgiveness change between Chapter IX and Chapter XXXVIII? (2) Track Anne's ambition across the novel—from her desire for puffed sleeves to her pursuit of the Avery scholarship—and argue what Montgomery suggests about the value and cost of ambition. (3) How does Anne's relationship with imagination shift from Chapter IV to Chapter XXXVIII, and what does that shift reveal about growing up? Students must integrate at least five quotations from across the novel, use topic sentences that make clear claims, and construct a conclusion that reflects on the novel's thematic argument rather than simply summarizing the plot. The essay should demonstrate control of formal academic style and fluent embedding of evidence.
- Exit ticket
In the final chapter, Anne whispers that God is in his heaven and all is right with the world. Do you believe her? Does the novel support that optimism, or complicate it?
Activities
Character voice audit 30 min · pairs
Students get a handout featuring five quotes from Anne's dialogue (from Chapters II, III, VIII, XV, and XXXVIII) alongside five quotes from other characters. In pairs, they determine which lines are spoken by Anne and annotate each one for unique vocabulary, sentence structure, and tone. They then choose the two quotes that best reflect Anne's voice and write a brief explanation of what makes her speech stand out. Pairs submit their annotated sheets and explanations. This activity enhances their ability to recognize narrative voice and sets the stage for analyzing how dialogue shapes character.
Mapping Anne's mistakes 40 min · groups
In groups of four, students are assigned one of Anne's key mistakes: the confrontation with Mrs. Lynde (Chapter IX), the brooch incident (Chapter XIV), the currant-wine disaster (Chapter XVI), or the hair-dye catastrophe (Chapter XXVII). Each student summarizes their assigned incident on a large sheet of paper, detailing what Anne does, her motivations, the responses from others, and the outcomes. Afterward, groups organize their sheets in chronological order and look for patterns: Does Anne learn from her mistakes? Are the consequences becoming more or less serious? Groups then present their findings to the class and submit their annotated sheets. This activity helps develop skills in tracking character growth throughout a long narrative.
Free indirect discourse detective work 35 min · individual
Students receive a handout with six passages from the novel. Three use free indirect discourse to give us access to a character's thoughts (examples from Chapters II, IV, and XXX), and three are straightforward third-person narration. Students identify which passages use free indirect discourse, underline the phrases that blend the narrator's voice with the character's inner voice, and explain how each example deepens our understanding of that character's feelings. They write a final paragraph explaining why Montgomery might choose this technique for Anne, Marilla, or Matthew. Students hand in their annotated handout and paragraph. This prepares them to analyze narrative perspective in their essays.
Tracking a motif across the novel 45 min · pairs
Pairs will each choose one motif to follow throughout the novel: imagination, forgiveness, ambition, or home. They will read the designated chapters (given by the teacher) and identify at least four instances where their chosen motif appears, documenting the chapter, a short quotation, and the significance of each moment. Next, they will organize their findings on a timeline and write a paragraph explaining how the motif evolves as Anne matures. Finally, pairs will submit their timeline and paragraph. This activity enhances skills in thematic analysis and sets students up for the comparative essay in Lesson 5.
The case for and against Anne 50 min · whole class
The class splits into two groups for a structured debate. One group argues that Anne's imagination and emotional intensity make her a better person, while the other contends that these traits lead to unnecessary suffering for both her and those around her. Each group prepares by selecting three quotations from the novel (Chapters IV, XX, XXVII, and XXXVIII are great choices) that back up their stance. The debate lasts for twenty minutes, during which each side presents opening arguments, rebuttals, and closing statements. The teacher moderates and notes the strongest pieces of evidence on the board. After the debate, students write a half-page reflection on which side they think had the stronger argument and why, including at least one quotation from the debate. They then submit their reflections. This activity helps develop argumentation skills and equips students to tackle complexity in their own essays.
Assessment
- Do-now tasks checking whether students can locate and paraphrase key moments from assigned chapters before the lesson begins
- Exit tickets assessing whether students can identify tone, explain a character's motivation, or connect a quotation to a larger pattern after teacher input
- Lesson 1 paragraph: Can the student embed two quotations correctly and explain how each builds sympathy for Anne, using formal tone and clear topic sentence?
- Lesson 2 comparison chart and paragraph: Does the student accurately track contrasting approaches from Marilla and Matthew and explain the significance of one key shift?
- Lesson 3 two-paragraph analysis: Can the student explain both what Anne does wrong and evaluate the fairness of the adult response, integrating quotations fluently?
- Lesson 4 paragraph on forgiveness and pride: Does the student explain Anne's refusal to forgive Gilbert by connecting dialogue to narratorial insight, and address the complexity of her character?
Summative task
Write a comparative analytical essay of four to five paragraphs responding to one of the following: (1) How does Anne's understanding of forgiveness change between her confrontation with Mrs. Lynde in Chapter IX and her reconciliation with Gilbert in Chapter XXXVIII? (2) Track Anne's ambition across the novel—from her longing for puffed sleeves in Chapter XI to her refusal of the Avery scholarship in Chapter XXXVIII—and argue what Montgomery suggests about the value and cost of ambition. (3) How does Anne's relationship with imagination develop from Chapter II, where she names the Lake of Shining Waters, to Chapter XXXVIII, where she looks forward to quiet work and duty? What does that development reveal about Montgomery's attitude toward growing up? Your essay must integrate at least five quotations from across the novel, use topic sentences that make arguable claims, and demonstrate control of formal academic writing. Conclude by reflecting on what the novel as a whole suggests about your chosen theme—forgiveness, ambition, or imagination—rather than simply summarizing Anne's journey.
Marking notes
The strongest essays will go beyond just summarizing events in order. Instead, they should explore how a pattern develops or changes throughout the novel, using Anne's journey to highlight a broader theme. Mid-range essays will accurately track the chosen element but might list key moments rather than create a cohesive argument, or include quotes without fully discussing their importance. Weaker essays will focus more on retelling the plot than on analyzing it, or they will make claims that lack textual support. Look for smooth integration of quotes, clear topic sentences that outline the argument of the paragraph, and conclusions that tackle thematic complexity instead of providing easy answers. Students should recognize that Anne's final choices involve both advantages and disadvantages, and that Montgomery doesn't present a straightforward message about ambition, imagination, or forgiveness.
Standards covered
- Common Core 11 12
- RL.11-12.1 — Cite strong and thorough textual evidence to support analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text, including determining where the text leaves matters uncertain
- RL.11-12.2 — Determine two or more themes or central ideas of a text and analyze their development over the course of the text, including how they interact and build on one another to produce a complex account
- RL.11-12.3 — Analyze the impact of the author's choices regarding how to develop and relate elements of a story or drama (e.g., where a story is set, how the action is ordered, how the characters are introduced and developed)
- W.11-12.2 — Write informative/explanatory texts to examine and convey complex ideas, concepts, and information clearly and accurately through the effective selection, organization, and analysis of content
- W.11-12.9 — Draw evidence from literary or informational texts to support analysis, reflection, and research
- AP Literature
- Identify and describe what specific textual details reveal about a character, that character's perspective, and that character's motives
- Develop a thesis statement that conveys a defensible claim about an interpretation of literature and that may establish a line of reasoning
- Develop commentary that explains the significance or relevance of specific textual evidence in relation to a claim
- Select and use relevant and sufficient evidence to both develop and support a line of reasoning
- Explain the function of character development, including contrasts and foils, in advancing plot or developing theme
- AQA
- AO1 — Read, understand and respond to texts; maintain a critical style and develop an informed personal response; use textual references, including quotations, to support and illustrate interpretations
- AO2 — Analyse the language, form and structure used by a writer to create meanings and effects, using relevant subject terminology where appropriate
- AO3 — Show understanding of the relationships between texts and the contexts in which they were written
- Edexcel
- AO1 — Articulate informed, personal and creative responses to literary texts, using associated concepts and terminology, and coherent, accurate written expression
- AO2 — Analyse ways in which meanings are shaped in literary texts
- AO4 — Explore connections across literary texts
Storgy generator
Plan it for your class instead
Choose the curriculum, the year group, how many lessons you have, and what the sequence should be about. Grounded in Storgy's analysis of Anne of Green Gables.
Teacher tools for
Anne of Green Gables
Discussion Questions
Thematic and close-reading prompts, ready to ask.
Essay Prompts
Exam-style essay questions with assessment-objective focus.
Quiz Questions
Multiple-choice comprehension checks, ready to hand out.
Ask about this work
Put a question to the reader behind the guide. It cites the chapter it answers from.
Full study guide
Summaries, characters, themes, and key quotes.