Prompt 01
Essay task
In The Screwtape Letters, C. S. Lewis employs satire through the character of Screwtape, a seasoned demon, who offers guidance to his nephew Wormwood on leading a human soul astray. Make the case that Lewis's use of a twisted moral viewpoint — where virtue is cast as the adversary and vice as the aim — serves as a more impactful means of Christian moral teaching than a direct instructive approach could achieve.
In your essay, be sure to
- Present a clear, defendable thesis that addresses Lewis's satirical technique and its rhetorical effect on the audience.
- Utilize at least three specific letters from the text as supporting evidence, analyzing how Lewis's reversed perspective highlights specific human flaws (e.g., pride, complacency, sensual distraction).
- Explore how the dramatic irony generated by Screwtape's viewpoint compels the reader to actively determine the "correct" moral lesson instead of passively receiving it.
- Address at least one counterargument: for instance, that the demonic framing may inadvertently glorify or normalize the vices it portrays, and counter this with textual evidence.
- Conclude by contemplating how Lewis's satirical approach influences the tone and lasting impact of the work's moral message.
Length
4–6 pages (approximately 1,000–1,500 words)
Evaluation Criteria
| Criterion | Weight | |---|---| | Strength and clarity of thesis | 25% | | Quality and specificity of textual evidence | 30% | | Analysis of satirical technique and rhetorical effect | 25% | | Engagement with counterargument | 10% | | Organization, style, and mechanics | 10% |