Prompt 01
"An Arundel Tomb" by Philip Larkin
In Philip Larkin's "An Arundel Tomb," the speaker reflects on a medieval stone effigy of an earl and countess, whose hands are joined and have stood the test of time. Larkin concludes with the line, "What will survive of us is love." Write a well-developed essay arguing whether this closing line genuinely affirms the permanence of love or if it's an ironic, skeptical remark that undermines the poem's own evidence. Your analysis should focus on how Larkin employs imagery, tone, and structure to either reinforce or challenge the notion that love transcends time.
Guiding Considerations (use these to build your argument, rather than answering them directly)
- How does Larkin's depiction of the tomb's physical decay ("the stone fidelity / They hardly meant") impact the reliability of the poem's conclusion?
- What does the inclusion of the word "almost" in the final line: "Our almost-instinct almost true: / What will survive of us is love" signify?
- In what ways does the poem's transition from the medieval era to the modern day influence the speaker's (and reader's) connection to the concept of lasting love?
- How does the poem differentiate between intended meaning and received meaning as time progresses?
Requirements
- Formulate a clear, defensible thesis in your introduction.
- Back up your argument with specific textual evidence (direct quotations and paraphrase).
- Consider and counter a counterargument to bolster your position.
- Conclude by reflecting on the broader implications of Larkin's message regarding how we derive meaning from art and history.