Skip to content
Storgy

The Mayor of CasterbridgeNovel by Thomas Hardy

Chapter XXXVIII

38 of 45 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Chapter XXXVIII of The Mayor of Casterbridge?

The chapter begins after the royal visit. Lucetta is radiant from her success and the gossip about Farfrae possibly being knighted, while Henchard, humiliated by Farfrae's public display and Lucetta's rejection of him in front of the other ladies, retreats in shame. He encounters Jopp in the archway to the Bull Stake; Jopp vents his frustrations about Lucetta, but Henchard is too preoccupied with his own hurt to listen. Determined to confront Farfrae, Henchard hastily eats dinner, heads to Farfrae's house, and leaves a note requesting a meeting at the granaries. In the vacant corn-store yard, he ties one arm to his side with a rope to ensure a fair fight, then climbs to the top floor and waits. Farfrae arrives, humming a tune from the Three Mariners; the familiar melody almost breaks Henchard's resolve, but he calls Farfrae up, shuts the hatch, and challenges him to a wrestling match with the open loft door—forty feet high—serving as the perilous exit for the loser. After a tense struggle, Henchard manages to push Farfrae's head over the window-sill and declares his life at stake. Farfrae tells him to take it. Overwhelmed, Henchard admits he cannot harm the man he once cared for, releases him, and sinks into remorse on the sacks. Without a word, Farfrae descends and drives off toward Weatherbury. Henchard, hoping to ask for forgiveness, finds out that Farfrae has already left and walks to the stone bridge to wait, faintly hearing strange rhythmic sounds rising from the town.

Analysis

The chapter revolves around a single, escalating arc of violence that ultimately leads to a moment of deep emotion. Hardy divides it into three movements: public humiliation, solitary preparation for murder, and the ensuing fight, which is followed by an emotional aftermath. The narrative closely follows Henchard, giving the bitter words he mutters to himself ("She has supplicated to me in her time; and now her tongue won't own me nor her eyes see me!"), allowing readers to feel his wounded pride even as they judge it.

Imagery of height and depth organizes the chapter's structure. The granary loft, situated thirty or forty feet above the ground, symbolizes the power struggle between the two men; the open door serves as a boundary between life and death. Henchard himself voices this vertical symbolism in the loft, saying that Farfrae's money and fine wife no longer lift him above Henchard and that his own poverty no longer presses him down, so the physical conflict mirrors the social one.

Music plays a crucial role. Farfrae’s humming of the old song from the Three Mariners—"And here's a hand, my trusty fiere"—temporarily softens Henchard's murderous intent, revealing that emotion, rather than logic, drives his actions. The melody evokes memories and feelings of love, making the ensuing violence feel even more tragic.

The wrestling scene is depicted with meticulous, almost clinical detail—collar-grips, toe-plants, and pinioned arms—adding a sense of documentary realism. Yet Hardy subverts the masculine display at the chapter's end: Henchard crouches on the sacks in a posture whose womanliness, the narrator says, "sat tragically on the figure of so stern a piece of virility." This phrase encapsulates the chapter's central irony—that the strongest man is also the most emotionally vulnerable.

Key quotes from Chapter XXXVIII

  • “God is my witness that no man ever loved another as I did thee at one time … And now—though I came here to kill ’ee, I cannot hurt thee!”

    Henchard speaks to Farfrae after holding him over the loft window-sill, at the moment he releases him instead of throwing him out.

  • “Its womanliness sat tragically on the figure of so stern a piece of virility.”

    The narrator describes Henchard crouching on the sacks in the loft after Farfrae has descended, overcome by remorse.

  • “As the strongest man I’ve tied one arm to take no advantage of ’ee.”

    Henchard explains to Farfrae the terms of the fight he has proposed in the granary loft.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01Why does Henchard tie one of his arms to his side before the fight with Farfrae?
  2. 02What nearly causes Henchard to abandon his plan to attack Farfrae before calling him up to the loft?
  3. 03What are the stated terms of the contest Henchard proposes in the loft?
  4. 04After releasing Farfrae, where does Henchard go to wait for his return?
  5. 05What does Henchard overhear Lucetta say to the other ladies after the royal visit?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in