What happens in Chapter XXVIII of The Mayor of Casterbridge?
The chapter begins with Henchard attending Petty Sessions at the Town Hall, serving as magistrate in place of the absent Mayor, Dr. Chalkfield, while he occasionally glances toward Lucetta's windows at High-Place Hall. The single case at hand involves an old woman charged with being a nuisance near the church. Constable Stubberd delivers his evidence hesitantly, waiting for the clerk's pen, while the old woman interjects with sharp legal objections. When Henchard allows her to speak, she recounts how, twenty years earlier, she sold furmity laced with rum at Weydon Fair, where a man got drunk and auctioned his wife to a sailor for five guineas — and that man, she claims, is Henchard himself. Henchard, visibly shaken, confirms the story is true, steps down from the chair, and leaves the judgment of the woman to his fellow magistrate. News spreads quickly, as the furmity-woman had already hinted at her secret to neighbors. Lucetta learns of the story from her servant and, reflecting on the promise she made to Henchard the night before, feels a wave of dread. She goes out to the Ring and other places, then tells Elizabeth-Jane that she is leaving for Port-Bredy for a few days. Elizabeth suspects that Lucetta's gloom may partly be due to Farfrae's absence. Meanwhile, Henchard calls at High-Place Hall twice, first while Lucetta is away and again on the day she returns while she is out walking, each time restless and impatient to see her.
Analysis
The chapter unfolds like a courtroom drama, flipping the justice system on its head against the very man who enforces it. Hardy starts with a touch of irony, showing Henchard, a rough yet competent magistrate, sitting in the "big chair" while his gaze drifts toward Lucetta's house—his focus split between his public responsibilities and private longing. The humorous nature of Stubberd's testimony, marked by his hesitant respect for the clerk and his playful "dee"s and "bee"s, gives the reader a moment of ease before the furmity-woman's explosive testimony disrupts the atmosphere. Her speech is intentionally slow and meandering—she starts with "twenty years ago" and gets mocked for it—yet this very slowness builds tension and reflects how hidden histories gradually come to light.
Henchard's face, described as if "powdered over with ashes," serves as the chapter's most vivid image, merging color, guilt, and despair into one striking physical representation. His public admission—"upon my soul it does prove that I'm no better than she"—is both morally commendable and self-sabotaging, and Hardy presents it as a form of rough integrity that aligns with his "sledge-hammer directness."
The chapter then transitions from the public spectacle to private repercussions, shifting focus to Lucetta. Her reaction—a "gradual misery" spreading across her face—echoes Henchard's ashen look, connecting the two through this shared moment of revelation. Elizabeth-Jane misinterprets Lucetta's pain (thinking it's due to Farfrae's absence), adding a layer of dramatic irony that leaves the chapter filled with a quiet tension.
Key quotes from Chapter XXVIII
“the man who sold his wife in that fashion is the man sitting there in the great big chair.”
The furmity-woman delivers her climactic accusation directly to the court, nodding at Henchard as she concludes her testimony.
“’Tis as true as the light,” he said slowly. “And upon my soul it does prove that I’m no better than she!”
Henchard publicly confirms the furmity-woman's story, overruling the clerk's dismissal of it as a concocted tale.
“His face seemed strange, and in tint as if it had been powdered over with ashes.”
The narrator describes Henchard's appearance immediately after the furmity-woman identifies him before the court.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign in