Skip to content
Storgy

The Mayor of CasterbridgeNovel by Thomas Hardy

Chapter XVII

17 of 45 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Chapter XVII of The Mayor of Casterbridge?

The chapter begins with Elizabeth-Jane realizing she has embarrassed herself and Henchard by dancing in the mixed crowd at the public festivities. She slips away into the dark, tree-lined paths and is joined by Farfrae, who has just been dismissed by Henchard. As they walk together down the West Walk and the Bowling Walk, Farfrae hints that he might soon leave Casterbridge. He confesses that if he were richer and Henchard weren’t offended, he would ask her something, but he stops short of making a proposal. They part under the lamplight, and Elizabeth-Jane rushes home, breathless. The next day, she discovers a scrap of Farfrae's handwriting blown over the garden wall, copies his script, and playfully writes "Dear Elizabeth-Jane" before tearing the slip up in embarrassment. She soon learns that Farfrae has not left town but has purchased a small corn-and-hay business on Durnover Hill. She tries on her dance clothes to assess her appearance in the mirror, concluding that she inspired only a momentary interest. Meanwhile, Henchard, furious about Farfrae's independent venture, rants to the town councillors and then orders Elizabeth-Jane to promise she will not see Farfrae again, writing him a formal letter demanding they treat one another as strangers. Farfrae, determined not to take Henchard's customers, even turns away a large farmer who recently dealt with Henchard. Despite this self-restraint, Farfrae's business grows steadily, and the chapter ends with both men entrenched in open commercial rivalry, Henchard gazing stormily past Farfrae at the Saturday corn market while Farfrae still tries to offer friendly words.

Analysis

The chapter uses a series of contrasts—between darkness and lamplight, restraint and outburst, Farfrae's calm demeanor and Henchard's explosive temper—to define the two men's characters. The evening walk takes place at the literal boundary between shadow and streetlamp: "twenty steps further and the trees would end, and the street-corner and lamps appear." This creates a moment of near-declaration held in a transitional space, where returning to the light signals the end of possibility. The narrator notes that "darkness makes people truthful," adding a moral weight to the night setting.

Elizabeth-Jane's private moment with the scrap of paper is infused with delicate irony: as she copies Farfrae's handwriting, the unintended "Dear Elizabeth-Jane" reveals her feelings before she fully acknowledges them. Her laughter afterward—"not joyfully, but distressfully rather"—captures the chapter's tone of unfulfilled emotion. In her mirror scene, she judges that her looks could inspire only a passing regard and nothing more, which underscores her self-aware intelligence.

In stark contrast, Henchard's speech to the councillors is raw, repetitive, and steeped in self-pity, showing that beneath his civic dignity "there was still the same unruly volcanic stuff beneath the rind of Michael Henchard." The narrator's aphorism, "Character is Fate, said Novalis," highlights the difference between Farfrae's steady nature and Henchard's, who is compared to Faust—a "vehement gloomy being." The biblical reference to Jacob in Padan-Aram and the classical mention of Bellerophon elevate their rivalry to an archetypal level.

Key quotes from Chapter XVII

  • “darkness makes people truthful, and the Scotchman went on impulsively”

    The narrator's aside as Farfrae, walking with Elizabeth-Jane in the dark tree-lined Bowling Walk, is about to make his near-declaration.

  • “Character is Fate, said Novalis, and Farfrae’s character was just the reverse of Henchard’s”

    The narrator's philosophical comment after describing Farfrae's steady commercial rise despite his restraint.

  • “just enough to make him silly, and not enough to keep him so”

    Elizabeth-Jane's self-assessment after dressing in her dance clothes and studying her reflection in the mirror.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01Why does Elizabeth-Jane feel ashamed at the start of the chapter?
  2. 02What does Farfrae stop short of saying during their walk along the Bowling Walk?
  3. 03What does Elizabeth-Jane do with the scrap of Farfrae's handwriting she finds in the garden?
  4. 04How does Farfrae show restraint toward Henchard after setting up his own business?
  5. 05What does Henchard demand of Elizabeth-Jane regarding Farfrae?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in