Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · Arabella's second husband

Cartlett

in Jude the Obscure by Thomas Hardy

Cartlett is Arabella Donn's second husband and the landlord of The Three Horns, a tavern in Lambeth known for being an "excellent, densely populated, gin-drinking neighbourhood." He is a minor yet significant character: described as a "short, rather bloated man, with a globular stomach and small legs, resembling a top on two pegs," his appearance mirrors the liquors he sells. Cartlett accompanies Arabella to the Wessex Agricultural Show, where he mostly serves as a contrast to her sharper observations—he misses much of what she notices about Jude and Sue, and his interest in Jude has "plainly flagged" over time. Importantly, Arabella keeps Cartlett unaware that her son with Jude has come to England; she sends the boy to Jude specifically to prevent Cartlett from seeing him. Following Cartlett's death—briefly noted as an event that occurred before Arabella's religious conversion—Arabella finds herself in somewhat diminished circumstances and lives on as the widowed Mrs. Cartlett. Although his presence in the novel is brief, it serves a purpose: he roots Arabella's London life, provides the domestic backdrop she manages around Jude's child, and his death triggers Arabella's temporary shift toward religion.

About this character

Role
Arabella's second husband
Form
Novel
Author
Thomas Hardy
First published
1895

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Cartlett?

Cartlett is the landlord of The Three Horns in Lambeth and the second husband of Arabella. He is described as "a short, rather bloated man, with a globular stomach and small legs, resembling a top on two pegs," and it’s noted that "the configuration of the landlord showed that he, too, like his customers, was becoming affected by the liquors he retailed." He speaks "in a thick voice," and his observations tend to be blunt and unremarkable.

02·Arc & motivation

What is Cartlett's arc and motivation?

Cartlett doesn’t have his own narrative arc; he exists in the story as a fixture in Arabella's life in London and as a practical obstacle for her to navigate. His main role is to remain oblivious: Arabella sends Little Father Time away to Jude specifically so that "her husband Cartlett, who was out," wouldn’t see the boy, and "Mr. Cartlett had no other idea than that his wife's child by her first husband was with his grandparents at the Antipodes." His death, which is mentioned briefly in Part Fifth, removes him from the story and prompts Arabella's short-lived religious phase.

03·Key moments

What are Cartlett's key moments?

In Part Fifth, Arabella's letter to Jude reveals that "I was married over again to Cartlett last Tuesday," marking him as her new husband and highlighting the domestic context that Jude's son cannot fit into. Also in Part Fifth, during the Wessex Agricultural Show, Cartlett accompanies Arabella and shares a stream of obtuse comments about Jude and Sue — failing to recognize Jude, missing the emotional nuances that Arabella notices in the couple’s behavior, and suggesting that Little Father Time is "their child." His flat perceptions contrast sharply with Arabella's more jealous gaze. They decide to separate at the show, with him heading to the malting exhibits while she follows Jude and Sue. In Part Fifth, after his death, Arabella tells Sue that passing a chapel after losing Cartlett led her to religion, and in Part Sixth she speaks to Phillotson of her affliction at losing him — positioning his death as the emotional low point that briefly transformed her.

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Cartlett's most important relationships?

With Arabella, Cartlett's relationship is based more on convenience than intimacy. She manages him, misleads him about her son, and uses his absence to send the boy away unnoticed. His fading interest in her "idiosyncrasies" and "supernumerary hair-coils" suggests that their marriage has settled into indifference. With Jude, Cartlett has no direct connection; he simply occupies the role Jude once held, and his dull curiosity about Jude at the show highlights how little he understands of his wife's past.

05·Connected characters

How is Cartlett connected to the other characters?

Arabella Donn

Cartlett is Arabella's second husband, the landlord she lives and works with at The Three Horns in Lambeth; she manages him carefully, concealing from him the existence of her son by Jude and quashing his guess that the child with Jude and Sue at the Agricultural Show is theirs.

Jude Fawley

Cartlett is the husband of Jude's former wife Arabella; his interest in Jude has 'plainly flagged' by the time of the Agricultural Show, and he remains unaware of the full significance of Jude's connection to Arabella.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Cartlett

Who is Cartlett?

Cartlett is Arabella's second husband and the landlord of The Three Horns, a tavern located in Lambeth. In a letter to Jude, Arabella shares the news of their marriage, signing it as "Arabella Cartlett."

Does Cartlett know about Arabella's son by Jude?

No. Arabella deliberately sends the boy on to Jude while Cartlett is out, and the narrator notes that Cartlett believes his wife's child by her first husband is with his grandparents at the Antipodes.

What does Cartlett look like?

He is described as a short, rather bloated man with a globular stomach and small legs, like a top on two pegs, and he speaks in a thick voice. The narrative also notes that his figure showed he, like his customers, was becoming affected by the liquors he retailed.

What happens to Cartlett?

He dies sometime before Part Sixth. Arabella mentions "my affliction at losing Cartlett" and explains how his death briefly pushed her toward practicing religion.

How does Cartlett behave at the Agricultural Show?

He goes along with Arabella but hardly pays attention; he doesn't recognize Jude, makes bland comments about Jude and Sue, and ultimately decides to part ways with Arabella at the show so they can each explore different exhibits on their own.

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • Cartlett as a foil: how his obtuseness at the Agricultural Show sharpens the reader's sense of Arabella's lingering attachment to Jude.

  • The publican's body as social commentary: what Cartlett's physical description and his "thick voice" suggest about the world Arabella has chosen over Jude.

  • Concealment and domestic management: how Arabella's deception of Cartlett regarding her son reveals her priorities and her pragmatism.

  • The function of off-page death: how Cartlett's death is used to motivate Arabella's religious conversion without requiring his character to be developed further.

Jude the Obscure

Continue

Full study guide →