The person01–03
01·Who they are
Who is Roger Cly?
Roger Cly is introduced as "the virtuous servant" — Dickens's irony is sharp — who claims to have served Charles Darnay "in good faith and simplicity." However, he is actually a professional spy and perjurer, characterized by Stryver as Barsad's "friend and partner," fittingly so, considering Barsad's own reputation as "a hired spy and traitor." His testimony in Book Second, Chapter III brings up an old suspicion over a silver tea-pot and a mustard-pot and a long acquaintance with Barsad, which he brushes off as mere coincidence.
02·Arc & motivation
What is Roger Cly's arc and motivation?
Cly's story shifts from active conspirator to presumed corpse to exposed fraud. He presents his motive at the trial as "true patriotism," a claim the novel treats with disdain. His true motivation is professional: Stryver presents him as the partner of a hired spy, one of a pair of forgers and false swearers. By the time of his fake funeral, he has become so despised by the London mob that pretending to be dead is his only escape, confirming that his career as a false witness has made him a public enemy.
03·Key moments
What are Roger Cly's key moments?
- The Old Bailey testimony (Book Second, Chapter III): Cly "swore his way through the case at a great rate," portraying himself as a patriotic servant who uncovered Darnay's treasonous lists. His testimony brings out an old suspicion over a mustard-pot and a suspiciously long friendship with Barsad, but ultimately, it is the resemblance between Carton and Darnay—not just Cly's discrediting—that saves Darnay.
- The funeral mob (Book Second, Chapter XIV): Cly's supposed funeral at Saint Pancras-in-the-Fields is taken over by a rioting crowd. Cruncher stays behind, noting Cly's youth and build, and visits a surgeon — a detail that hints at his grave-robbing profession and his interest in the body.
- The empty coffin revealed (Book Third, Chapter VIII): In Paris, Carton recognizes a disguised man as Cly. Barsad presents a burial certificate, but Cruncher flatly states, "you buried paving-stones and earth in that there coffin." Barsad admits: Cly "never would have got away at all but for that sham." This revelation becomes the "certain Guillotine card" Carton holds over Barsad.
- Carton's dying vision (Book Third, Chapter XV): Cly is mentioned among those Carton foresees "perishing by this retributive instrument," placing him among the new oppressors who will ultimately face destruction.
The cast04–05
04·Relationships
What are Roger Cly's most important relationships?
Cly's most significant relationship is with Barsad: they have known each other "seven or eight years" by the time of the trial, and Barsad later acknowledges Cly as his partner. Their shared unpopularity drives the fake funeral. Jerry Cruncher is Cly's unwitting nemesis: present at both the funeral and the Paris confrontation, it is his knowledge of the empty coffin — gained through his nocturnal trade — that undermines Barsad's alibi. Sydney Carton leverages Cly's fraudulent death, transforming a piece of criminal history into a tool for his own plan to save Darnay.
05·Connected characters
How is Roger Cly connected to the other characters?
Study06–07
06·Questions
Questions readers ask about Roger Cly
What role does Roger Cly play at Darnay's trial?
Cly pretends to be Darnay's faithful servant and claims that he discovered treasonous lists in Darnay's pockets and witnessed him showing similar lists to his French contacts in Calais and Boulogne. Later, Stryver describes him as Barsad's "friend and partner" in a plot involving forgery and perjury.
How is Cly's cross-examination used to discredit him?
The cross-examination brings up suspicions about a silver tea-pot and a mustard-pot and shows that Cly has known Barsad for about seven or eight years — a connection he brushes off as mere coincidence. His assertion that patriotism was his "only motive" is met with clear disbelief.
What happens at Cly's funeral?
A London mob takes over the funeral procession to the church of Saint Pancras-in-the-Fields, transforming it into a chaotic scene. Jerry Cruncher lingers in the churchyard, observing Cly's youth and build, and later calls on a surgeon—details that hint he means to dig up the body that night.
Was Cly really dead?
No. In Book Third, Chapter VIII, Jerry Cruncher discloses that the coffin held only "paving-stones and earth." Barsad backs this up by stating that the funeral was "a sham," noting that Cly had become so disliked by the crowd that "he never would have got away at all" without it.
How does the exposure of the fake burial matter to the plot?
Sydney Carton leverages the fact that Cly faked his death and that Barsad was in on it as a "certain Guillotine card" to pressure Barsad into aiding his plan. In revolutionary Paris, being associated with a spy who pretended to die could easily lead to Barsad's execution by guillotine.
What is Cly's fate according to Carton's final vision?
In his final vision in Book Third, Chapter XV, Carton sees Cly among those "perishing by this retributive instrument" — the guillotine — placing him among the new oppressors who have risen on the destruction of the old.
07·Essay angles
Use this in your essay
Tool · Essay angles
The fake funeral as social critique: The mob's takeover of Cly's burial procession illustrates how public anger, however justified, devolves into chaos
Retributive justice and the guillotine: Carton's vision places Cly among future victims of the Revolution