Skip to content
Storgy

Character analysis · revolutionary wine-shop keeper and implacable enemy of the Evrémonde family

Madame Defarge

in A Tale of Two Cities by Charles Dickens

Madame Defarge is the wife of Ernest Defarge, who runs the Saint Antoine wine-shop, and she stands out as a powerful figure in the revolutionary underground. She is depicted as a stout, composed woman with a keen eye, strong features, and an undeniable air of confidence—someone who seems to rarely make mistakes in the calculations she oversees. Her incessant knitting is far from a trivial pastime; it serves as a coded list of names and crimes, marking those she has sentenced to death. Calm, shrewd, and completely devoid of mercy, she communicates danger to her husband with just a raised eyebrow or a subtle cough. She takes charge of the women of Saint Antoine during the storming of the Bastille and the execution of Foulon, and she personally beheads the governor of the Bastille. Her deep-seated hatred for the Evrémonde family stems from a "brooding sense of wrong" she absorbed in her childhood, which has evolved into what the narrator describes as the nature of "a tigress." She is "absolutely without pity." As the story approaches its climax, she begins to act independently of her husband, whom she sees as too weak, scheming to denounce Lucie, little Lucie, and Doctor Manette along with Charles Darnay. Armed with a loaded pistol and a sharpened dagger, she sets out for Lucie's lodging, where she meets Miss Pross.

About this character

Role
revolutionary wine-shop keeper and implacable enemy of the Evrémonde family
Form
Novel
Author
Charles Dickens
First published
1859

The person01–03

01·Who they are

Who is Madame Defarge?

Madame Defarge is first introduced in Book First, Chapter V, seated behind the counter of the Saint Antoine wine-shop: "a stout woman of about his own age, with a watchful eye that seldom seemed to look at anything, a large hand heavily ringed, a steady face, strong features, and great composure of manner." Right from the start, she is characterized by concealment and control. Her knitting symbolizes a deeper purpose: a coded record of those she has condemned. Defarge himself tells the Jacques that it would be easier for "the weakest poltroon that lives" to erase himself from existence than to erase one letter of his name or crimes from the knitted register of Madame Defarge. The narrator, in Book Third, Chapter XIV, describes her as a woman of "strong and fearless character, of shrewd sense and readiness, of great determination," shaped from childhood by "a brooding sense of wrong, and an inveterate hatred of a class" — a woman whom circumstances have transformed into "a tigress."

02·Arc & motivation

What is Madame Defarge's arc and motivation?

Madame Defarge's journey shifts from a watchful, covert revolutionary to an open, autonomous agent of destruction. In the early chapters, she communicates through coded signals — a cough, a raised eyebrow, a rose pinned in her hair to warn customers away from a spy. As the Revolution progresses, she becomes more active: leading the women of Saint Antoine at the Bastille, orchestrating the killing of Foulon, and ultimately taking matters into her own hands when she judges her husband so weak as to relent towards the Doctor. Her motivation stems from her hatred of the Evrémonde family specifically and the aristocratic class in general, rooted in a "brooding sense of wrong" absorbed in childhood. She is "absolutely without pity" and sees Darnay not as an individual but as a representative of those who have wronged her.

03·Key moments

What are Madame Defarge's key moments?

  • Book First, Chapter V & VI: Madame Defarge communicates solely through knitting, eyebrow movements, and small coughs, directing her husband's attention to suspicious customers and members of the Jacquerie. She stands knitting at the door while Doctor Manette is carried away and "saw nothing."
  • Book Second, Chapter XV: When a man in the crowd at Versailles asks about her knitting, she replies: "shrouds." She also runs the wine-shop alone while her husband is away, and the Jacques discuss the reliability of her register.
  • Book Second, Chapter XVI: As the spy visits, she silently knits the name "BARSAD," using a rose in her hair as a signal to clear the shop. When she learns that Lucie is to marry the nephew of the Marquis St. Evrémonde, she remains outwardly calm while her husband visibly reacts.
  • Book Second, Chapter XXI: During the storming of the Bastille, she is seen "in the inner distance" with a knife in hand. She stands still beside the governor, and when he falls, "put her foot upon his neck, and with her cruel knife—long ready—hewed off his head."
  • Book Third, Chapter III: She visits Lucie at her lodging, pointing her knitting needle at little Lucie "as if it were the finger of Fate," and coldly dismisses Lucie's pleas by recalling how little the wives and mothers of the poor have ever been considered.
  • Book Third, Chapter XII: Sydney Carton visits the wine-shop and hears her say of him, "I swear to you, like Evrémonde!" He overhears her declare that the entire Evrémonde race is on her register, "doomed to destruction and extermination," and that nothing — not wind, not fire — will stop her.
  • Book Third, Chapter XIV: She acts independently of Defarge, organizing the denunciation of Lucie, the child, and the Doctor. She sets out armed with a loaded pistol and a sharpened dagger, described as walking "with the confident tread of such a character, and with the supple freedom of a woman who had habitually walked in her girlhood, bare-foot and bare-legged, on the brown sea-sand."

The cast04–05

04·Relationships

What are Madame Defarge's most important relationships?

Her marriage to Ernest Defarge is a partnership of unequal wills. He "walked up and down through life," admiring her management without interfering; she ultimately concludes she "cannot trust my husband in this matter" because he retains sympathy for Doctor Manette. Her relationship with The Vengeance is one of command and adoration — The Vengeance calls her "my Chief" and kisses her cheek. Her enmity toward the Evrémonde family, and by extension toward Lucie and Darnay, is absolute: she receives Lucie's desperate plea "as a compliment" and turns away. Barsad, who once tried information about Doctor Manette on her to open a familiar conversation, "always remembered with fear and trembling" that she had knitted when he talked with her. Carton recognizes her as the main threat to the Manette family and takes steps to counter her.

05·Connected characters

How is Madame Defarge connected to the other characters?

Ernest Defarge

Her husband and fellow revolutionary; she is the dominant partner, managing the wine-shop's accounts and the knitted register while he defers to her judgment in all things, though she ultimately judges him too weak to be trusted with her final plans against the Evrémonde family.

The Vengeance

Her devoted lieutenant and closest ally in the revolutionary sisterhood; The Vengeance executes Madame Defarge's orders without question and addresses her as 'Chief.'

Lucie Manette

Lucie's desperate appeals for mercy leave Madame Defarge unmoved; she views Lucie, her child, and her father as enemies to be destroyed alongside Darnay, and plans to denounce them all.

Charles Darnay

As a member of the Evrémonde family, Darnay is entered in her knitted register and she pursues his destruction with implacable determination, seeing in him not an individual but the embodiment of a hated class.

Doctor Manette

She views the Doctor's influence as an obstacle and ultimately decides she cannot spare him, resolving to include him in her denunciation despite her husband's sympathy for him.

John Barsad

She identifies and knits his name into her register during his visit to the wine-shop, and he later recalls with fear and trembling how she looked ominously at him as her fingers moved.

Miss Pross

Miss Pross is the last obstacle Madame Defarge encounters as she arrives at the Manettes' lodging armed with pistol and dagger; the two women come into direct confrontation.

Sydney Carton

Carton visits the wine-shop to observe her, overhears her plans to denounce the Manette family, and reflects that it might be 'a good deed to seize that arm, lift it, and strike under it sharp and deep.'

Mr. Jarvis Lorry

Mr. Lorry encounters her both in Book First, when she stands knitting at the door as Doctor Manette is taken away, and again seventeen years later in Paris, where he attempts to reassure Lucie about Madame Defarge's intentions.

Study06–07

06·Questions

Questions readers ask about Madame Defarge

What does Madame Defarge's knitting actually do?

Her knitting is a coded record of names and crimes — a list of those she has judged. Defarge explains to the Jacques that it is "knitted, in her own stitches and her own symbols," and that it would be easier for the weakest poltroon alive to erase himself from existence than to erase one letter of his name or crimes from her knitted register. In Book Third, Chapter VIII, Barsad remembers seeing her create these knitted records in the Section of Saint Antoine and denounce individuals "whose lives the guillotine then surely swallowed up."

How does Madame Defarge signal danger to her husband and the Jacquerie without speaking?

She communicates through subtle gestures that are nearly undetectable: a subtle cough, her eyebrows lifting just the width of a line, or a gentle shift in her seat. In Book Second, Chapter XVI, she signals the presence of a spy by pinning a rose in her hair, which prompts all customers to leave the wine-shop.

Why does Madame Defarge hate the Evrémonde family so intensely?

The narrator mentions in Book Third, Chapter XIV that she has been "imbued from her childhood with a brooding sense of wrong, and an inveterate hatred of a class," and that opportunity has shaped her into "a tigress." In Book Third, Chapter XII, she reveals that the peasant family the two Evrémonde brothers destroyed, as told in Doctor Manette's Bastille paper, was her own family, which is why her animosity targets the Evrémonde family as a whole. She tells Jacques Three and The Vengeance that she has had "this race a long time on my register, doomed to destruction and extermination."

What does Madame Defarge do at the storming of the Bastille?

She guides several women from Saint Antoine into the fortress, knife in hand. She remains steadfast next to the governor amidst the chaos, and when he succumbs to the crowd's attacks, she "put her foot upon his neck, and with her cruel knife—long ready—hewed off his head."

How does she respond to Lucie's plea for mercy?

She remains completely unfazed. In Book Third, Chapter III, she tells Lucie that all their lives she and her companions have watched wives and mothers suffer, The Vengeance adds that they have seen nothing else, and Madame Defarge asks whether the trouble of one wife and mother is likely to matter much to them now. She takes Lucie's fear "as a compliment" and departs without providing any comfort.

Why does Madame Defarge decide to act without her husband in Book Third, Chapter XIV?

She concludes that Defarge "has his weaknesses" and is "so weak as to relent towards this Doctor," which shows he still feels sympathy for Doctor Manette. She's worried that if she waits or shares her thoughts with him, he might alert the Manette family and help them escape. So, she decides: "I must act for myself."

What weapons does Madame Defarge carry when she sets out for the Manettes' lodging?

The narrator in Book Third, Chapter XIV describes her as carrying "a loaded pistol" tucked away in her bosom and "a sharpened dagger" concealed at her waist.

How does Sydney Carton assess the threat she poses?

After visiting the wine shop and overhearing her plans, Carton informs Mr. Lorry in Book Third, Chapter XII that the Manette family is "in danger of denunciation by Madame Defarge" and that a wood-sawyer has been "rehearsed by Madame Defarge" to give false testimony against Lucie. He warns that the ruse will be "a prison plot" and that it could endanger Lucie, her child, and her father. He also thinks, as she takes his arm to indicate a road, that it might be "a good deed to seize that arm, lift it, and strike under it sharp and deep."

07·Essay angles

Use this in your essay

Tool · Essay angles

  • The knitting as symbol

    How does Dickens use Madame Defarge's knitting to represent the recording of history, the inevitability of revolutionary justice, and the concealment of lethal intent beneath a domestic appearance?

  • Revolutionary justice vs. personal vendetta

    To what extent does Madame Defarge embody principled political grievance, and how much does her pursuit of the Evrémonde family devolve into personal revenge?

  • Gender and power

    Madame Defarge leads the women of Saint Antoine and acts more decisively than any male revolutionary in the novel; how does Dickens portray female agency in the Revolution, and what does her characterization suggest about his perspective on it?

  • The "tigress" and the absence of pity

    The narrator states she was "absolutely without pity" and that "if she had ever had the virtue in her, it had quite gone out of her." How does Dickens depict her as a figure beyond redemption, and what are the ideological implications of that portrayal?

  • Madame Defarge and Lucie as contrasts

    Both women are defined by loyalty and by the suffering of those they love; how does Dickens use the contrast between them to shape the novel's moral argument?

A Tale of Two Cities

Continue

Full study guide →