The person01–03
01·Who they are
Who is Bonello?
Bonello is a working-class Italian soldier-driver whom Piani teases as an anarchist who doesn’t go to church. He talks a lot and has a sharp wit, using bravado to mask the tension of the retreat—dreaming about sipping champagne in Udine, sleeping in the king's bed, and joking about treason. However, beneath this bravado lies a man genuinely scared and morally adrift in the chaos surrounding him.
02·Arc & motivation
What is Bonello's arc and motivation?
Bonello starts the retreat feeling upbeat, almost enjoying the chaos ("I like a retreat better than an advance"). As events unfold, his mood takes a downward turn with the stuck ambulances, the shooting of the sergeant, and Aymo's death. His motivation shifts from dark humor to survival. After Aymo is killed by friendly fire, Bonello realizes that pushing forward is a death sentence—"They'd have to shoot us all to prove they were right the first time"—and opts for capture instead of continuing the march. His journey reflects a loss of nerve, culminating in his eventual surrender.
03·Key moments
What are Bonello's key moments?
- Chapter XXVII: Bonello sets a tone of gallows humor at the villa, joking about sleeping in the major's bed and drinking champagne in Udine, while cautioning Henry not to oversleep lest the Austrians catch them off guard.
- Chapter XXIX: He finishes off the wounded sergeant with Henry's pistol, then proudly declares, "I never killed anybody in this war, and all my life I've wanted to kill a sergeant." This moment reveals underlying class resentment hidden beneath his jokes.
- Chapter XXIX: He offers to walk toward Austria for two hundred lire, indicating that his commitment to the retreat is already conditional.
- Chapter XXX: Following Aymo's death, Bonello becomes fatalistic and confrontational—"Who's dead next, Tenente?" and "You reason it out, Tenente"—constantly redirecting Henry's authority back at him.
- Chapter XXX: He sneaks away while he and Piani are searching the farmhouse for food, choosing to be taken prisoner. Henry later reflects that the night proved the path was safe, making Bonello's choice seem unnecessary.
The cast04–05
04·Relationships
What are Bonello's most important relationships?
Bonello's relationship with Frederic Henry is that of a subordinate who respects his officer but increasingly questions his decisions. He formally defers to Henry ("With the Sir Lieutenant's permission") yet pokes fun at him with "You tell us, Tenente" during Henry's rants about the undefended bridge. His surrender ultimately serves as a silent rejection of Henry's leadership. With Piani, Bonello shares a relationship built on mutual teasing—they trade jibes about anarchism, beds and brains—but Piani's comment after the surrender ("Bonello was a fool") highlights the limits of their camaraderie. The death of Aymo is pivotal: sitting beside the body without looking at it, Bonello expresses the fear that ultimately unravels him.
05·Connected characters
How is Bonello connected to the other characters?
Study06–07
06·Questions
Questions readers ask about Bonello
Why does Bonello surrender instead of continuing the retreat with Henry and Piani?
After Aymo is shot dead by the Italian rear-guard troops, Bonello grows convinced that it's too risky to go on, stating, "They'd have to shoot us all to prove they were right the first time" and "I'm not going to try them." He quietly slips away while Piani is looking for food and surrenders as a prisoner. Later, Henry thinks back on their nighttime walk and realizes there was no real threat, considering Bonello’s decision to be foolish.
What does Bonello mean when he says he always wanted to kill a sergeant?
After using Henry's pistol to finish off the wounded Italian sergeant of engineers, Bonello says, "I never killed anybody in this war, and all my life I've wanted to kill a sergeant." This statement, along with Piani's teasing label of him as an anarchist, suggests a strong resentment toward military authority rooted in class.
Is Bonello really an anarchist?
Piani calls Bonello an anarchist who doesn't go to church, and Bonello says the same of Piani. When Henry asks whether they really are anarchists, the answer is that they are socialists from Imola, so the label reads as banter between the two.
What is Bonello's relationship with Piani?
They are fellow drivers who share sleeping quarters, meals, and the march during the retreat. Their conversations flow with a mix of dark jokes and playful teasing, but after Bonello surrenders, Piani bluntly labels him "a fool."
How does Bonello react to Aymo's death?
He sits next to Aymo's body without looking at it, then turns to Henry, says Aymo is dead, and asks who will die next and where they go now. His tone turns bleak as he keeps pushing Henry's arguments back at him, hinting that Aymo's death shatters whatever determination he had left.
Is Bonello married?
Piani tells Henry that Bonello, unlike Piani himself, is not married, and Henry suggests that a married man might want to return to his wife. However, Henry also points out that being married doesn’t necessarily account for a man's decisions.
07·Essay angles
Use this in your essay
Tool · Essay angles
Bonello as emblem of disillusionment
Class and violence
Foil to Piani
The retreat as moral dissolution
Bonello's absence as narrative device