What happens in Book IV, Chapter XXXIII of A Farewell to Arms?
The narrator drops off a slowing train in Milan just before dawn and heads into a wine shop for coffee. The owner, noticing he just arrived from the train, offers him a place to stay and warns him that the cut-away rank stars on his coat sleeves are very noticeable. He also offers forged leave papers, which the narrator turns down. After paying, they share a grappa, and the narrator leaves, steering clear of the station where military police are stationed.
He takes a cab to the hospital, where the porter and his wife greet him warmly. He finds out that Catherine Barkley left for Stresa two days earlier with another English nurse. He tips the porter and asks him not to mention he's been seen; the porter refuses the money but agrees to keep quiet.
Next, the narrator visits Simmons, an acquaintance studying singing, who lives near the Porta Magenta. He inquires about how to get into Switzerland; Simmons explains that the Italians would not let him out of the country, but that the Swiss would simply intern him and the internment itself is easy. Simmons offers the narrator some civilian clothes from his own wardrobe instead of making him buy new ones. The narrator agrees but mentions he needs to go to Stresa first, prompting Simmons to joke about rowing across to Switzerland. The chapter wraps up with Simmons singing a passage from "Africana" as the narrator heads downstairs to pay his cab fare.
Analysis
The chapter revolves around a series of brief, cautious encounters, each testing how much the narrator is willing to share about himself. Hemingway's signature minimal dialogue—short questions and even shorter denials—reflects the narrator's instinct to hide: "I would not know about the front," "I am in no trouble," "Nothing definite yet." This repetition of evasions creates a rhythm of avoidance that conveys danger more powerfully than any direct statement could.
The wine-shop scene begins with vivid sensory details—"swept dust, spoons in coffee-glasses and the wet circles left by wine-glasses"—immersing the reader in physical reality before the underlying political tension becomes apparent. The proprietor's offer of shelter, papers, and the warning about the coat sleeves represents the chapter's most concrete moment of risk: the discolored fabric where the stars were cut out serves as a visible, tangible sign of abandonment that the narrator cannot conceal.
A noticeable shift in tone occurs when the narrator meets Simmons. The tense, clipped exchanges of the earlier scenes give way to the relaxed, affectionate banter between two expatriates. Simmons’s self-mocking remarks about his singing career in Piacenza, his cheerful offer of clothes, and his exuberant rendition of "Africana" introduce a moment of comic relief. Yet, even in this light-hearted exchange, the narrator's predicament emerges: he does not explain why he needs civilian clothes, saying only that he must go up to Stresa first.
The chapter’s progression moves from darkness and secrecy (pre-dawn, back streets, avoided station) toward a tentative warmth, culminating in Simmons’s voice filling the room—a moment of liveliness that starkly contrasts with the fugitive silence the narrator has maintained throughout the morning.
Key quotes from Book IV, Chapter XXXIII
““On the sleeves it shows very plainly where the stars have been cut away. The cloth is a different color.””
The wine-shop proprietor warns the narrator that his officer's coat betrays him, near the end of their conversation.
Check your understanding
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign in