Skip to content
Storgy

A Farewell to ArmsNovel by Ernest Hemingway

Book III, Chapter XXV

25 of 41 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Book III, Chapter XXV of A Farewell to Arms?

The narrator arrives in Gorizia by truck from Udine in the autumn, taking note of the bare mulberry trees, muddy roads, and the numerous houses damaged by war. He carries his rucksack to the villa, where the major briefs him: the summer fighting was brutal, three ambulance cars were lost, and the narrator is assigned to relieve Gino and take over four cars on the Bainsizza plateau. The major tells him to leave the next morning with a small car and a guide named Peduzzi.

Upstairs, the narrator rests on the bed, thinks about Catherine, and waits for Rinaldi. When Rinaldi arrives, he examines the narrator's knee, declares the joint incomplete, and the two men share some Austrian cognac while chatting. Rinaldi confesses that the war is wearing him down, that he feels only happy when he’s operating, and that he has nothing else in his life. He asks if the narrator is in love with "that English girl" and, when he presses for intimate details, the narrator tells him to shut up.

At dinner, the major, Rinaldi, and the narrator are joined by the priest. Rinaldi, getting more intoxicated, teases the priest, laments the absence of their old mess companions, and then goes on a rambling monologue, hinting that he has syphilis and is treating himself with mercury. He becomes agitated but eventually settles down. After coffee, he heads out for town. The major tells the narrator privately that Rinaldi thinks he has syphilis, although the major isn’t sure. The major says goodbye, instructs the narrator to leave before daylight, and asks him to keep Rinaldi from drinking too much brandy.

Analysis

The chapter begins with a vividly described autumn scene—bare mulberry trees, muddy roads, and wet dead leaves—which sets a tone of desolation before any dialogue occurs. The narrator's blunt statement, "It did not feel like a homecoming," sharpens this mood and establishes the emotional backdrop for everything that follows: a return that lacks restoration.

The chapter unfolds in three parts: the briefing with the major, the private reunion with Rinaldi, and the communal dinner. Each part deepens the feeling that the war has drained the men who remain. The major "looked older and drier," while Rinaldi, despite appearing unchanged, confesses he is "only happy when I am working" and that outside of work, there are "only the two things"—both temporary or harmful. His surgeon's hands, admired as "fine surgeon's hands," symbolize his identity: the war has reduced him to merely his function.

Hemingway employs cognac as a recurring motif. Its repeated pouring throughout the chapter sets the pace of conversation and highlights Rinaldi's decline: what starts as friendly drinking culminates in his bitter, nearly incoherent outburst at the dinner table. The priest, in contrast, remains composed—"I could see that the baiting did not touch him now"—offering a calm counterbalance to Rinaldi's turmoil.

The narrator's inner thoughts are minimal yet revealing. He lies on the bed reflecting on Catherine, having already decided to think of her only at night, yet he finds it hard to stop. This small lapse in self-control subtly shows how much she occupies his mind, even as the chapter's focus is dominated by male camaraderie and discussions of war.

Key quotes from Book III, Chapter XXV

  • “It did not feel like a homecoming.”

    The narrator's first impression upon walking up the damp gravel driveway to the villa after arriving in Gorizia.

  • ““This war is killing me,” Rinaldi said, “I am very depressed by it.””

    Rinaldi speaks to the narrator during their private reunion in the upstairs room, early in their conversation.

  • “Already I am only happy when I am working.”

    Rinaldi reflects on his state of mind during the intimate conversation with the narrator before dinner.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01What assignment does the major give the narrator when he arrives at the villa?
  2. 02What physical complaint prevents the narrator from getting drunk with Rinaldi?
  3. 03What does Rinaldi say he kept in the room to remind him of the narrator while he was away?
  4. 04What does Rinaldi imply about his own health during the dinner conversation?
  5. 05What day of the week does the priest correct Rinaldi about during the dinner?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in