What happens in Book II, Chapter XXIII of A Farewell to Arms?
On the night the narrator has to go back to the front, he arranges for the porter and a friend who is a machine-gunner to save him a seat on the midnight train that comes from Turin and leaves Milan for the front. After saying goodbye at the hospital, he waits in a wine shop and catches a glimpse of Catherine through the window. They stroll together through the foggy city, passing the cathedral square, where they see a soldier holding his girl close against a stone buttress. They pause at a leather goods shop window and chat about skiing at Mürren, then head into an armorer's shop where the narrator buys a used pistol, two extra clips, and cartridges to replace the one taken from him on his way to the hospital. They keep walking, sharing a kiss in a dark side street, before taking a carriage to a hotel near the station. Catherine stops on the Via Manzoni to pick up a nightgown. At the hotel, the manager shows them upstairs; they order woodcock, soufflé potatoes, purée de marron, salad, and zabaione, pairing their meal with Capri and St. Estephe. For a moment, Catherine feels "like a whore" in the lavish red-plush room but quickly shakes it off, and the room starts to feel like home. They share warm conversations about wine, their families, the baby, and the war, with the narrator quoting Marvell. As midnight draws near, they reluctantly get ready to say goodbye, exchanging tender, half-joking wishes that he might be only slightly wounded so he can come back soon.
Analysis
The chapter unfolds like a long evening that shifts from public spaces to intimate moments, with the looming midnight deadline creating a subtle but constant tension. The narrator's perspective is intimate and sensory: fog, rain, wet stone, the scent of a steaming horse, and the glow of street lamps come together to create an atmosphere of fleeting beauty that reflects the couple's circumstances.
The cathedral emerges early on as an ironic contrast. When the narrator asks Catherine if she wants to go inside, she declines. Moments later, she observes that the soldier and his girl "have the cathedral" — a grand but impersonal shelter, unlike the private home the couple is trying to create. The leather goods shop window, featuring riding boots, a rucksack, and ski boots displayed "as an exhibit," introduces the theme of objects that hint at a future (skiing at Mürren) that war continues to postpone.
The scene where they buy a pistol is presented with a deliberate flatness (the women shopkeepers, the used weapon recovered from a dead officer's orderly, the offer of swords, the bird-luring mirrors in the window), and its dark humor highlights how thoroughly war has commercialized even the act of violence. The hotel room, adorned with red plush, a cut-glass chandelier, and numerous mirrors, reflects Catherine back to herself and triggers her moment of distress. The mirrors emphasize self-awareness; the narrator sees her "in three other mirrors," multiplied and exposed. After they eat and drink, the room transforms into a space of comfort and warmth through habit. The Marvell quotation, introduced while the narrator's head feels "very clear and cold," briefly makes the chapter's time pressure explicit before the conversation shifts back to tenderness and gentle humor.
Key quotes from Book II, Chapter XXIII
“They’re like us,” I said. “Nobody is like us,” Catherine said. She did not mean it happily.”
The narrator and Catherine pass a soldier sheltering his girl against a cathedral buttress, and the narrator draws a comparison Catherine immediately rejects.
“I never felt like a whore before,” she said.”
Catherine speaks after sitting on the hotel bed and seeing herself reflected in the room's many mirrors, just after they have arrived.
Ask about this work
The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.
It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.
Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.
Create an accountSign inVocabulary in Book II, Chapter XXIII
- buttresses
- Projecting supports of stone or brick built against a wall to strengthen it; thick stone piers that stick out from a building's exterior.
- chandelier
- A large ornamental light fixture that hangs from the ceiling, typically with multiple branches holding bulbs or candles, often made of glass or crystal.