Skip to content
Storgy

Year 12–13 / Grades 11–12

The Taming of the Shrew — a five-lesson scheme of work

This sequence starts with the Induction's frame of illusion and expands through Acts I–IV, enhancing students' ability to interpret Shakespeare's language as a commentary on gender and power dynamics. Lessons 1–2 focus on the play's self-awareness and the marriage market in Padua. Lessons 3–4 closely examine the wooing and taming scenes, exploring how Petruchio's language shapes and challenges Katherina's identity. Lesson 5 brings together insights from all five chapters into a detailed analytical essay. By the end, students will be able to cite examples, analyze language and structure, and argue whether the play supports, mocks, or complicates Katherina's subjugation.

Objectives

  • Analyse how Shakespeare uses the Induction's frame narrative to position the audience as complicit in illusion and gender performance.
  • Explain how the language of commerce in Act I and Act II constructs women as exchangeable property within Padua's marriage market.
  • Close-read Petruchio's wooing speech in Act II Scene 1 to show how he imposes a fictional identity on Katherina through rhetorical contradiction.
  • Track how Act IV's taming scenes use food, clothing, and time as instruments of psychological control, supporting claims with embedded quotations.
  • Write a sustained, evidenced analytical essay arguing a coherent position on how Shakespeare presents power in the relationship between Petruchio and Katherina across the whole play.

The sequence

  1. Lesson 1: Who Is Watching Whom? Illusion and Identity in the Induction

    60 min · ch. 1
    Do now

    Without opening the play, write two sentences answering this question: if a lord dressed a beggar in fine clothes and told him he was a nobleman, and the beggar believed it — who has the real power in that situation? Be ready to defend your answer.

    Teacher input

    Model a close reading of Induction Scene 2, lines 66–79, where the Lord's servants inform Christopher Sly, "Your honour's players … are come to play a pleasant comedy." Highlight the choice of the word "pleasant" and the servants' use of the honorific "Your honour." Discuss how Shakespeare creates a layered experience for three audiences: Sly, the on-stage lords, and the theatre audience, illustrating that each act of watching also involves an element of deception. Show how to craft a single analytical sentence that identifies the technique, quotes the word, and explains its effect on a specific audience level.

    Independent task

    Using Induction Scenes 1 and 2, write one analytical paragraph of 120–150 words arguing how Shakespeare uses Christopher Sly's transformation to introduce the play's central concern with performed identity. Your paragraph must embed at least two quotations — one from the moment the Lord instructs his servants on how to treat Sly (Induction Scene 1, lines 40–66) and one from Sly's own acceptance of his new role (Induction Scene 2, lines 66–79) — and must explain what each quotation reveals about who controls identity and how.

    Exit ticket

    In one sentence, state what the Induction's frame narrative tells an audience about the relationship between power and illusion before the main play has even begun, using at least one word from the text to support your claim.

  2. Lesson 2: The Marriage Market: Women as Currency in Act I and Act II

    60 min · ch. 2, 3
    Do now

    Read Baptista's speech in Act I Scene 1, lines 48–52, where he announces that no man may court Bianca until Katherina is married. Write one sentence identifying the grammatical subject of Baptista's sentences — who is doing the action — and one sentence explaining what that grammatical choice implies about Bianca's and Katherina's agency.

    Teacher input

    Model how to read Act I Scene 1, lines 130–145, where Gremio and Hortensio decide to sponsor a suitor for Katherina to gain access to Bianca. Pay attention to the commercial language: 'bear the charge of wooing,' 'bestow,' 'get.' Guide students on how to annotate a group of lexical choices as a semantic field and then compose a sentence that identifies the field, lists three words, and discusses what this field suggests about how men in Padua view women. Make a clear distinction between identifying a technique and analyzing its ideological function.

    Independent task

    Write two analytical paragraphs — each 100–130 words — comparing how Baptista speaks about Katherina in Act I Scene 1 (lines 48–52) with how Petruchio and Baptista negotiate her dowry in Act II Scene 1 (lines 118–135). Your first paragraph must argue what the language of Act I Scene 1 reveals about Baptista's authority over his daughters. Your second paragraph must argue how the dowry negotiation in Act II Scene 1 extends, complicates, or confirms that picture. Each paragraph must contain at least two embedded quotations and must end with a sentence linking your point to the theme of women as property.

    Exit ticket

    Name one word from the Act II Scene 1 dowry negotiation that belongs to the semantic field of commerce, and write one sentence explaining precisely what that single word implies about Katherina's status in the exchange.

  3. Lesson 3: 'I Find You Passing Gentle': Petruchio's Rhetorical Takeover in Act II Scene 1

    60 min · ch. 3
    Do now

    Read Act II Scene 1, lines 182–188, where Petruchio reveals his plan before confronting Katherina: 'Say that she rail, why then I'll tell her plain / She sings as sweetly as a nightingale.' Without peeking ahead, predict in two sentences how this approach might impact Katherina — and how an audience observing her might react.

    Teacher input

    Model a close reading of Petruchio's first extended speech to Katherina in Act II Scene 1, lines 243–252, focusing on the rhetorical device of antithesis: 'thou art pleasant, gamesome, passing courteous … not so curst as they report.' Analyze how each antithesis doesn't merely describe Katherina but instead prescribes a new identity for her. Additionally, illustrate how to craft an analytical sentence that differentiates between description and prescription, identifies the rhetorical device, and argues its potency as a means of verbal coercion.

    Independent task

    Write one analytical paragraph of 150–180 words arguing how Petruchio uses rhetorical contradiction in Act II Scene 1 (lines 182–271) to strip Katherina of her own language and impose a new identity upon her. You must quote and analyse at least three moments from this passage — including Petruchio's pre-meeting soliloquy (lines 182–188), his antithetical description of Katherina (lines 243–252), and his public announcement of their betrothal (lines 300–308) — and you must argue whether this constitutes wit, cruelty, or something more ambiguous.

    Exit ticket

    Write one sentence explaining the difference between antithesis as a decorative device and antithesis as a tool of power, using a specific example from Petruchio's speech in Act II Scene 1.

  4. Lesson 4: 'He Kills Her in Her Own Humour': Control Through Deprivation in Act IV

    60 min · ch. 5
    Do now

    Read Grumio's account of the journey to Petruchio's house in Act IV Scene 1, lines 46–74. List three physical hardships Katherina has faced. Then, in one sentence, explain whose voice we hear describing these hardships and how that narrative choice impacts our understanding.

    Teacher input

    Model a close reading of Petruchio's soliloquy in Act IV Scene 1, lines 188–211 — 'Thus have I politicly begun my reign' — focusing on the extended metaphor of falconry: 'My falcon now is sharp and passing empty … She eat no meat today, nor none shall eat.' Analyze how this metaphor both legitimizes Petruchio's control—since falconry is regarded as a noble art—and reveals its inherent brutality, as Katherina is likened to a mere animal. Craft a sentence that captures this duality, maintaining the tension without forcing a resolution too soon.

    Independent task

    Write two analytical paragraphs — each 120–150 words — tracking how Shakespeare uses the motifs of food (Act IV Scene 1, lines 155–175), clothing (Act IV Scene 3, lines 87–175), and time (Act IV Scene 3, lines 187–198) as tools of Petruchio's psychological control over Katherina. In the first paragraph, focus on food and clothing, discussing what the denial of these essentials reveals about the connection between bodily needs and personal identity. In the second paragraph, concentrate on the time motif and Petruchio's claim that the sun is the moon (Act IV Scene 5, lines 1–22), analyzing whether Katherina's compliance by this point indicates defeat, a strategic move, or a more nuanced negotiation of power dynamics.

    Exit ticket

    In two sentences, explain how the falconry metaphor in Act IV Scene 1 (lines 188–211) both justifies and condemns Petruchio's method of taming, and state which reading you find more convincing and why.

  5. Lesson 5: Arguing a Position: Petruchio, Katherina, and the Politics of Submission

    60 min · ch. 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
    Do now

    Without your notes, write the most powerful single quotation you remember from anywhere in Acts I–IV that could be used to argue that the play endorses Petruchio's treatment of Katherina, and then write the most powerful single quotation you remember that could be used to argue the opposite. You have four minutes.

    Teacher input

    Model how to construct a thesis sentence and a counter-argument for this essay question, using Katherina's final speech in Act V Scene 2 (lines 136–179) as the crux. Show how the speech can be read as sincere submission, as ironic performance (recalling the Induction's lesson that performance is always watched), or as a pragmatic survival strategy. Demonstrate how to write a paragraph that names the critical debate, takes a position, and uses the Induction's frame as structural evidence for an ironic reading — connecting Chapter 1 to Chapter 5 in a single analytical move.

    Independent task

    Write a detailed analytical essay of 500–600 words in response to the question: 'How does Shakespeare portray the relationship between Petruchio and Katherina as a power struggle?' Your essay should: begin with a thesis statement that presents a clear, debatable position; include at least one paragraph discussing the Induction (Chapter 1) and how the frame narrative influences audience interpretation of the subsequent events; contain at least one paragraph focused on Act II Scene 1 (Chapter 3) that examines Petruchio's rhetorical approach; include at least one paragraph on Act IV (Chapter 5) analyzing the methods of taming; and conclude by revisiting Katherina's final speech in Act V Scene 2 (lines 136–179), debating whether it supports or challenges your thesis. You are required to embed and analyze at least six quotations from throughout the play, ensuring that each analytical sentence identifies a technique, quotes a specific word or phrase, and discusses its effect on the audience or on Katherina.

    Exit ticket

    Read back your thesis sentence and write one sentence explaining which single piece of evidence from the play you found hardest to accommodate within your argument, and how you dealt with — or chose to sidestep — that difficulty.

Activities

Sly Transformation Tableau 15 min · groups

Groups of four will work on either Induction Scene 1 (lines 40–66) or Induction Scene 2 (lines 1–30). They will create a frozen tableau that captures the moment of Sly's transformation, and then annotate a printed still photograph of their tableau with three quotations from their assigned passage. Each group will return the annotated photograph along with a sentence explaining whose power is highlighted in the tableau.

Semantic Field Auction 20 min · whole class

The teacher presents thirty words from Act I Scene 1 and Act II Scene 1. Students receive a printed grid featuring four columns labeled 'commerce,' 'violence,' 'courtship,' and 'law.' Working independently, they categorize each word into the appropriate column, after which the class discusses any disputed placements. Finally, students return their completed grids with a sentence at the bottom arguing which semantic field is most prominent in Padua's marriage market and what that prominence indicates.

Antithesis Rewrite 20 min · pairs

Each pair gets a printed excerpt of Petruchio's speech to Katherina from Act II Scene 1 (lines 243–271), with the contrasting phrases highlighted. They then rewrite the speech to reflect Katherina's true character using her own words from earlier in the scene. Finally, they write two sentences comparing the impact of the original antithetical version with their rewritten version. Pairs return the rewritten excerpt along with the two comparative sentences.

Falconry Metaphor Dissection 25 min · pairs

Pairs get a printed copy of Petruchio's soliloquy from Act IV Scene 1 (lines 188–211) along with a two-column table labeled 'What the metaphor naturalises' and 'What the metaphor exposes.' They fill in both columns with examples from the soliloquy and then craft one analytical paragraph based on the table. Finally, pairs submit the finished table and paragraph, ensuring that the paragraph includes at least two embedded quotations from the soliloquy.

Katherina's Final Speech — Four Readings 30 min · groups

Four groups each get a printed copy of Katherina's final speech (Act V Scene 2, lines 136–179), with annotations reflecting a different critical lens: (1) sincere submission, (2) ironic performance, (3) pragmatic survival, and (4) directorial ambiguity. Each group will prepare a two-minute spoken reading of the speech that captures their lens, and then submit a written explanation detailing three specific words or phrases they emphasized, along with reasons for those choices that support their interpretation.

Cross-Chapter Evidence Sort 20 min · individual

Each student gets a set of sixteen quotation cards taken from all five chapters. They sort the cards into two piles: one for 'evidence that the play supports Petruchio's power' and another for 'evidence that the play critiques it.' Next, they select their three strongest cards from each pile, write an analytical sentence for each of the six chosen quotations, and return the six annotated cards as a structured evidence bank for their summative essay.

Assessment

  • Lesson 1 exit ticket: checks whether students can connect the Induction's theatrical framing to the theme of performed identity using textual evidence.
  • Lesson 2 independent task: checks whether students can identify and analyse a semantic field of commerce across two separate scenes and link it to a thematic argument about women as property.
  • Lesson 3 exit ticket: checks whether students can distinguish between antithesis as decoration and antithesis as an instrument of power, using a specific textual example.
  • Lesson 4 independent task: checks whether students can track a developing motif — food, clothing, time — across multiple scenes of Act IV and sustain an argument about psychological control.
  • Cross-Chapter Evidence Sort activity: checks whether students can select and rank evidence from across all five chapters in preparation for a thesis-driven essay.

Summative task

Write a full analytical essay of 500–600 words in response to the question: 'How does Shakespeare present the relationship between Petruchio and Katherina as a struggle for power?' Your essay must open with a clear, arguable thesis; include analysis of the Induction's frame narrative, Petruchio's rhetorical strategy in Act II Scene 1, and the taming methods of Act IV; and conclude with a reading of Katherina's final speech in Act V Scene 2 (lines 136–179). Embed and analyse at least six quotations from across the play.

Marking notes

Top-band responses maintain a clear, nuanced interpretation—such as viewing the Induction's illusion as structural irony that challenges Petruchio's seemingly victorious stance—and effectively support this perspective throughout all five chapters with well-integrated quotations. Mid-band responses recognize relevant techniques but describe their effects in broad terms instead of presenting a clear argument. Lower-band responses tend to summarize the plot or simply list quotations without providing any analysis. The distinction between bands hinges on whether the student employs the Induction and Act IV's falconry soliloquy as evidence in their argument rather than merely using them for context.

Standards covered

Common Core 11 12
  • RL.11-12.1 — Cite strong and thorough textual evidence to support analysis of what the text says explicitly as well as inferences drawn from the text.
  • RL.11-12.3 — Analyse the impact of the author's choices regarding how to develop and relate elements of a story or drama, including where a story is set, how the action is ordered, and how the characters are introduced and developed.
  • RL.11-12.4 — Determine the meaning of words and phrases as they are used in the text, including figurative and connotative meanings; analyse the impact of specific word choices on meaning and tone.
  • RL.11-12.6 — Analyse a case in which grasping a point of view requires distinguishing what is directly stated in a text from what is really meant.
AP Literature
  • Literary Argumentation (LAN-1) — Develop a thesis that makes a defensible claim about an interpretation of literature and use evidence to support and develop that claim.
  • Figurative Language (FIG-1) — Explain the function of specific words and phrases in a literary text, including metaphor, antithesis, and extended metaphor.
  • Character (CHR-1) — Explain the function of a character, including how characters develop or change over the course of a text.
  • Narration (NAR-1) — Explain the function of a narrator or speaker, including the effect of a frame narrative on audience interpretation.
AQA
  • AO1 — Read, understand and respond to texts, maintaining a critical style and developing an informed personal response, using textual references including quotations to support and illustrate interpretations.
  • AO2 — Analyse the language, form and structure used by a writer to create meanings and effects, using relevant subject terminology where appropriate.
  • AO3 — Show understanding of the relationships between texts and the contexts in which they were written and received.
  • AO5 (Language) — Communicate clearly, effectively and imaginatively, selecting and adapting tone, style and register for different forms, purposes and audiences.
Edexcel
  • AO1 — Articulate informed, personal and creative responses to literary texts, using associated concepts and terminology, and coherent, accurate written expression.
  • AO2 — Analyse ways in which meanings are shaped in literary texts, with reference to language, form, structure and literary context.
  • AO4 — Explore connections across literary texts, including the significance of cultural and contextual influences on readers and writers.
IB Lit
  • Criterion A — Demonstrate knowledge and understanding of the text, including its literary features and the author's choices.
  • Criterion B — Analyse the effects of literary features and techniques on meaning, including how Shakespeare uses the frame narrative, rhetorical devices, and motif.
  • Criterion C — Develop a focused, coherent, and well-supported literary argument.

Storgy generator

Plan it for your class instead

Choose the curriculum, the year group, how many lessons you have, and what the sequence should be about. Grounded in Storgy's analysis of The Taming of the Shrew.

Plan The Taming of the Shrew for your class1 credit
The Taming of the ShrewWilliam Shakespeare

Powered by Claude. One credit per plan. First run free — no signup.