Skip to content
Storgy

The Count of Monte CristoNovel by Alexandre Dumas

Chapter 59: The Will

59 of 117 · summary, analysis, and key quotes

What happens in Chapter 59 of The Count of Monte Cristo?

Barrois arrives with a notary called by Noirtier, who, due to his paralysis, cannot speak or move. Villefort describes his father's condition, but the notary hesitates to proceed, saying he cannot authenticate a will from someone who can't communicate. Valentine steps in to explain Noirtier's methods of signaling—closed eyes for "yes" and a wink for "no"—and demonstrates them effectively. The notary is persuaded, but Villefort pulls him aside to express doubts about Noirtier's mental state. Valentine counters this by pointing out that for the past six years, Noirtier has always managed to communicate clearly with her. With her as the interpreter, the notary agrees to continue.

Using the alphabet and dictionary method, Valentine spells out that Noirtier wants to make a will. The notary verifies the estate's value: 900,000 francs in bank scrip, which Barrois retrieves from a casket. When asked who should inherit, Noirtier surprises everyone by not leaving the fortune to Valentine. When she presses him, he gestures toward her hand, leading her to realize that he disapproves of her engagement to Franz d'Épinay. He confirms that he is excluding her from the inheritance solely because of this marriage. Villefort asserts that the marriage will go ahead regardless. When asked where the money will go if the marriage takes place, Noirtier states it will be given entirely to charity. Villefort dismisses this as the whims of an old man but agrees not to contest it and departs. The will is drafted that same day, witnessed, sealed, and entrusted to the family notary, M. Deschamps.

Analysis

The chapter revolves around a single extended scene in Noirtier's room, where the drama lies in the reversal of authority. Villefort, as a procureur — someone who interprets law and language — finds himself consistently outsmarted by his paralyzed father and his own teenage daughter. The notary’s initial refusal to act sets the stage for the chapter's main conflict: can a voiceless person possess and exert legal will? Valentine’s teaching of the two-signal system resolves this issue in Noirtier's favor, shifting the moral weight of the scene entirely onto her.

A recurring motif throughout the chapter is the eyes, representing intelligence and emotion. Noirtier's gaze takes on the role of speech: it is described as "earnest and imperative," "beaming with delight," conveying "unutterable fondness," and, at the suggestion that Edward should inherit, something "almost amounting to hatred." Each depiction of his eyes serves as a stage direction, guiding the reader through the scene.

The structure reflects the legal proceedings it portrays: question, answer, question, answer. This formal pattern makes each deviation — such as Noirtier’s refusal to name Valentine as his heir and his dismissal of every Villefort family member — hit harder. The sequence where Valentine spells out "Will" highlights the chapter's theme: meaning must be painfully drawn from silence. Madame de Villefort’s barely hidden delight at Valentine’s disinheritance, contrasted with Valentine’s tearful appreciation for her grandfather's enduring love, intensifies the division between those eager for wealth and the one person who desires none of it.

Key quotes from Chapter 59

  • “I have now been six years with M. Noirtier, and let him tell you if ever once, during that time, he has entertained a thought which he was unable to make me understand.”

    Valentine answers Villefort's attempt to persuade the notary that communicating with Noirtier is impossible.

  • ““Oh, grandpapa, I see now that it is only your fortune of which you deprive me; you still leave me the love which I have always enjoyed.””

    Valentine responds to Noirtier after he has signalled that she is not to be his heir.

  • “The winking of the eyes which answered this speech was most decided and terrible, and expressed a feeling almost amounting to hatred.”

    The narrator describes Noirtier's reaction when Madame de Villefort suggests leaving the fortune to Edward de Villefort.

Check your understanding

5 questions · answers checked on this page, free

  1. 01How does Noirtier signal 'yes' during the making of his will?
  2. 02How much money does Noirtier declare he possesses?
  3. 03What is the method Valentine uses to establish which word Noirtier wishes to communicate?
  4. 04Why does Noirtier disinherit Valentine?
  5. 05To whom does Noirtier declare he will leave his fortune if Valentine's marriage to Franz d'Épinay goes ahead?
0 of 5 answered

Ask about this work

The reader has this chapter in front of it — the summary, the analysis, the key quotes and the vocabulary — along with the rest of the book’s chapters. Ask what happens and why it matters, or push back on a reading.

It cites the chapter or the line it is working from, and it says so plainly when the guide doesn’t cover something. It’s instructed never to write an essay, a paragraph or an answer for you to hand in, and never to grade anything — it will show you how to approach the question instead. The reader is an AI, not a person, and its replies are written by Claude, from Anthropic. The people behind Storgy are at hello@storgy.com.

Sign in to ask the reader about this work — 1 credit covers three messages.

Create an accountSign in